Primate ontogeny cognition and social behavior. Edited by J.G. Else and P.C. Lee New York Cambridge University Press. xiii + 410 pp. figures tables index. $59.50 (cloth) $19код для вставкиСкачать
BOOK REVIEWS body of non-American literature on shifting attitudes towards nature and a somewhat nonexhaustive account of the literature on his chosen vehicle, the wolf. On balance, Dunlap’s book is an engaging read of considerable utility and a not insignificant message to us, prone in the immediacy of our PRIMATE ONTOGENY, COGNITION AND SOCIAL BEHAVIOUR. Edited by J.G. Else and P.C. Lee. New York: Cambridge University Press. xiii + 410 pp., figures, tables, index. $59.50 (cloth),$19.95 (paper). 133 work, not to lose sight of the social context within which that work is conducted. SHARP HENRYS. Department of Anthropology University of Virginia Charlottesville, Virginia thinking primate a t the cost of “worry,”measured as the physiological consequence of social stress. Asquith offers some insights into the ways in which western, in contrast to Japanese, primatologists think about behavior and the mind. Part I11examines “Primate Behaviour and This work contains revisions of a selection Cognition in Nature.” Fragaszy and Box recof papers presented at the Tenth Congress of ommend the usefulness of cognitive conthe International Primatological Society in cepts, especially in studies on resource exNairobi, Kenya, in July, 1984. The book con- ploitation, spatial mapping abilities, intains much of interest, although little that is strumental activities, and attentional abiliprofound. Perhaps this is because “[the] pa- ties and social learning. Andrews describes pers were kept relatively short in order to species-specific differences in foraging effiinclude as many contributors as possible in ciency between groups of Saimuri and Callieach of the sections,” a very egalitarian ap- cebus studied experimentally in captivity. proach to publishing but not one that pro- Sigg first lists the several difficulties in motes excellence in research or scholarship. studying the mental capacities of wild priTwo of the most interesting papers, by mates, then overcomes them in a careful Mason and by Rhine, are placed by them- analysis of hamadryas baboons’ travel to selves in Part I, Introduction, no doubt be- water holes. Gibson, arguing from comparacause they have little to do with the rest of tive data on relative brain size, metabolic the book. Mason argues that resolution of the requirement, and foraging strategies, condissonance between causal and functional cludes that the relatively large neocortices of explanations of behavior may lie in resolu- several genera of Primates, including Homo, tion of the meaning of the concept of “behav- correlate with a particularly difficult alioral trait.” Rhine characterizes the strate- though profitable strategy: “omnivorous exgies, travails, and triumphs of long-term tractive foraging.” Whitehead carefully obfield research. served infant howler monkeys in a seasonal Part I1 is devoted to papers on “Primate forest in Costa Rica and demonstrates the Thinking.” Candland and Kyes review the preponderance of socially dependent learnhistory of the epistemology of the theory of ing in the acquisition of leaf-eating behavior. mind. Rumbaugh reviews various experi- Box and Fragaszy point out that novel social mental procedures used to evaluate the pres- settings during development may reveal laence and degree of animal thinking and con- tent cognitive abilities not observed in wild cludes that studies of observational learning members of a species. may be of special value in elucidating animal Part IVis entitled “Perception and Perforcognition. Following Anthony Shafton, mance: Growth, Manipulation and CommuSingh sees the timing and orientation of nication.” DeVito and four coauthors designals in episodes of communication among scribe the pre- and postnatal growth of the primates as particularly revealing of the major subdivisions of the brain from crosshigher mental states, in particular of the sectional samples of Macaca nemestrina. Alstate of consciousness. Reynolds suggests though Sharma and La1 apparently have that the heightened awareness of compli- available longitudinal observations on physcated social relations and statuses among ical growth and dental eruption in rhesus primates gives selective advantages to the monkeys, they report their results as cross- 134 BOOK REVIEWS sectional means and standard deviations. Dienske compares the relative rates of development of brain and social behavior in Macaca, Pan, and Homo and concludes that both neoteny and heterochrony explain the slow maturation of humans. Spinozzi and Natale compare the progression of a macaque infant, a gorilla infant, and five human infants through Piaget’s five stages of prehension. Peters wonders whether the observed simultaneous variation of the several acoustic components of primate calls might be matched by the “cognitivecomplexity to synthesize simultaneously the information in multiple cues” (p. 162). Liska struggles to define “symptom,”“ritual,” and “symbol” as regions along the continuum of arbitrariness of signs within animal and human systems of communication. Part V, “Functional Aspects of Development,” is introduced by Lee and Bateson, who suggest that the behavior of juveniles should be studied as adaptive in immediate circumstances instead of merely as on a trajectory toward an adult state. Then Bateson clearly outlines the conceptual issues that are implicated in the study of the functions of behavior during development. Hauser illustrates a game-theoretical model of parentoffspring conflict with observations on infant care-soliciting behavior and the mother’s response in two mother infant pairs of vervets in Amboseli. Collins speculates on the possible functions of adult male carrying of infants among savanna baboons as suggested by detailed tabulations of such instances. Datta promotes the currently popular idea that inheritance of maternal dominance rank in macaques is largely conditioned by support by others in agonistic interactions. Noting that play behavior amongjuvenile vervets was infrequent when food was scarce, Lee urges that ecological variation be included in studies of ontogeny and social organization. Part VI is called “Social Interactions: Development and Maintenance.” Tartabine and Simpson demonstrate a method for assessing behavioral scores made on individuals in very small groups and, in addition, offer insightful comments on the nature of statistical inference in naturalistic studies. Mendoza and Mason report on a series of experiments that, taken together, suggest that the distribution of parental care between the mother and father is largely under the control of the infant in the monogamous species Callicebus moloch. Although the amount of social interaction varied with the age of infant Papio cynocephalus and P . anubis studied by Hendy, maternal dominance rank and infant’s sex curiously had no effect, in contrast to the findings of many other studies. Quiatt develops a curious metaphor of “the household to characterize interactional subgroups of rhesus monkeys. Netto and van Hooff observe that interventions in agonistic interactions among Macaca fascicularis are patterned to minimize risk to the intervening monkey and could account for the stability of dominance relations between families. Messeri and Giacoma summarize comparisons between hierarchies based on several components of agonism among female pit-tail macaques and show strong concordance of the rankings. Thierry studied one group each of rhesus, java, and Tonkean macaques and found significant contrasts between the three species in the patterning of four variables: the intensity of aggression, symmetry in agonistic interactions, behaviors in response to aggression, and reconciliation following aggression. The last section of the book is on “Social and Reproductive Strategies.” Stern and Leiblum seek clues to assumed contrasts in sexual receptivity among the great apes and humans. They compare self-reports of nursing and bottle feeding groups of “young . . . , married, healthy, non-obese, no-drug-taking . . . Caucasian paid volunteers with no history of infertility problems or irregular menstrual cycles prior to conception, or prepregnancy sexual dysfunction.” Would that such carefully controlled samples were available on wild apes! Abbott and three coauthors observe that dominant male talapoin monkeys suppress the mating of subordinate males, but subordinate females seem to enjoy a self-imposedcelibacy. Wasser and Starling offer a complicated set of hypotheses that offers a test of the assumption that coalitions among female baboons serve to reduce competition by suppression of reproduction among subordinates. Glatston reports that among captive mouse lemurs offspring of communally nesting females suffer less infant mortality than offspring of solitary nesters. Manley describes in an entertainingly dramatic manner harem accretion in the purple-faced leaf monkey. Manzolillo discusses the factors that influenced male immigrations in a group of Anubis baboons. BOOK REVIEWS The possible reproductive benefits of alliances among male savanna baboons are examined in the context of a reciprocal altruism model by Noe. Blurton Jones argues that topics generally studied in isolation, such as “economic defensibility of territory, dominance hierarchies, polygyny, food sharing, hoarding” (p. 4041, might find unification in a set of propositions about conflict over resources in which fitness pay-offs are func- 135 tions of the amount of resource held. Is the book to be recommended? At the least it is less expensive to acquire the work now than it would have been to travel to Nairobi to hear the original papers. DONALD STONE SADE Department of Anthropology Northwestern University Evanston, Illinois BOOKS RECEIVED Bamforth DB (1988) Ecology and Human Organization on the Great Plains. New York: Plenum Publishing. 217 pp. $29.50 (cloth). Blakely RL (ed.) (1988) The King Site. Continuity and Contact in Sixteenth-Century Georgia. Athens, GA: The University of Georgia Press. 170 pp. $11.50 (paper). Burkhardt F, and Smith S (eds.) (1989) The Correspondence of Charles Darwin, Vol. 4 1847-1850. New York: Cambridge University Press. 711 pp. $37.50 (cloth). deWaal F (1989) Peacemaking among Primates. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press. 294 pp. $29.95. Feder KL, and Park MA (1989) Human Antiquity. Mountain View, CA Mayfield Publishing Company. 412 pp. $26.95 (paper). GnffithJ (1988)Free: The End o f theHuman Condition. Sydney, Australia: Center for Humanity’s Adulthood. 228 pp. (paper). Handwerker WP (1989) Women’s Power and Social Revolution. Fertility Transition in the West Indies. Newbury Park, CA: Sage Publications. 254 pp. $16.95 (paper). Hoffman A (1989) Arguments on Evolution. A Paleontologists’ Perspective. Oxford: Oxford University Press. 274 pp. $29.95 (cloth). Martin L, Boyde A, Grine F, and Jones S (eds.) (1989) Scanning Microscopy of Ver- tebrate Mineralized Tissues. Chicago: Scanning Microscopy International. 384 pp. $43.00 (paper.) Mascie-Taylor CGN, and Boyce AJ (eds.) (1988) Human Mating Patterns. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press (Society for the Study of Human Biology Symposium 28). 237 pp. $49.50 (cloth). Rosaldo R (1989) Culture and Truth. The Remaking of Social Analysis. Boston: Beacon Press. 253 pp. $21.95 (cloth). Smith JM (1989) Did Darwin Get It Right? New York: Routledge, Chapman and Hall. 264 pp. $22.95 (cloth). Stein PL, and Rowe BM (1989) Physical Anthropology, fourth edition. New York: McGraw-Hill. 512 pp. $30.95 (paper). Theunissen B (1988)Eugene Dubois and the Ape-Manfrom Java. Dordrecht, The Netherlands: D. Reidel Publishing Company. 216 pp. $49.00 (cloth). Wynn T (1989) The Evolution of Spatial Competence. Champaign, IL: University of Illinois Press. 107 pp. $13.95 (paper). Young M (1989) The Technical Writer’s Handbook. Mill Valley, CA: University Science Books. 232 pp. $22.50 (cloth). Young TK (1989) Health Care and Cultural Change. The Indian Experience in the Central Subarctic. Toronto: University of Toronto. 177 pp. $14.95 (paper).