close

Вход

Забыли?

вход по аккаунту

?

Небосвод

код для вставкиСкачать
Журнал для любителей астрономии, №10 за 2010 г.
Небосвод №10, 2010 1 !
!"#$%
"!
! #!#$#%
#!$
# ! "$&%
%$
" !& &$"'%
!#" &
'% (
"&%
&
')#(#
& & !&%%
*++(
!!%
,$!
" #!'
,
" #!
, !%
# " "
%
,"!#
& !"
#%
-..!
(
%
!
"
*/.%%
&"#$ '%
*/.%
# !$ '%
0*/..%'
$'
)*%
%%%
.1!+2..,+)23
-4'5+
"!%
%%%
%%
6)78.0.9
!'.(
$!
*+
%
,,*
%
+
%#
:;;p,==>>>3pop@ec:3CD=
0 +EE F) 7/9 F
)(G1!),
+! !
%
%-./0123%451%67432829%
*
*
%
'
$'
)*
%-674328%:%;.5%3/<542%=>9%
$
*
%
*
%-32%.2?@5%87AB2C%.@423DAE2%/%67432859%
F%
*
%%%%%%%%
,
*
) F+
H)I)J3
$%%p'##a)%*o,e%.*/
$%%p'##0*a,1.*/
$%%p'##222.,34
7KLH9
%
%
%%%%%%%%%%%%%G.585332C%
H4/.@423.@;/%G45<C%%
+
%%
%
7
09
/M*!NI!
$,
*
%%
,%
'I$,
%%%%
$,
'$, '
%
$,
'$,,'
%%
$,
'$,!,'
%%
$,
'$,,'
%
$,
'$,'
%
$,
'$,'
%
Небосвод №10, 2010 3 5 6
"
!" # $! %&!'()"*! ""
+),' $'!"! $""-
".!"' ) $"-! ! / -0"'
%&!! ".*!*". !&/ -
%!"(/ $ & #"1 23.&4
5 ) "1 $$- $!"1!(6
.! %".!" ()"* ! "" 7"" 8
" !!/)$"1#)."-(!"'()"*
! "" &'! #'6" ".!" 6!" )"* "! """1' "
()"* ! "" 9) -%*
%(6"* ."1 )'/ " $)!" -
$&)"-0"' . +) 9 !.
) 1 -&1! " $!* "!
%&!:1 !" ()"" ! ""/ --
$-. $-"-/ 6!" (! 1-
&$-;!!/!$- $1(<'!"#
-! " ! ""''(' $""-"
".!"' $! ",' !!! '
%! )! $$"1'!.&)%!
%&!$! ""/!'=!&%!.!!"
'.-,' $-"-" ()&("!> 0"( $
! "" %!!*"";!!/!!&%!
.!1/ "-1/ $"-"-".&( (
! &&(/ "1 *"!&("!> 0"(
+) ' $'1"!!&("
$.!&("!> 0"( ' ()"* ! ""/
" $1! "# !"0# / .'
&- " "# ()"* ! ""; =
." '.1 . )$"'!&( >&!
$! ()"1-* ! "" 7"" $" & %&! +)/ ()"' "
! "" " $&-1'" &"".!"'/
- '' .1 *" "%/ !$!" '!"!#".!"* " / 7"*-' ()"1-' ! "'
!#"'."""?%*".!1!"
" '' ' 1( "
! "- )6?%* %
!" $"1!* - ()" &(!&-&/
!)('/ >"-"&'/ ))'" $&)"-&'
.&1@!!)"&$!#!)(!"*A
(новости астрономии)
!
"#
$%
Юрий Горячко (
&
''(
)!!
*
Роман Бакай &
+
$
'
+
+
,
Наталия Вирнина &-
.!
!
!/0
/
Анатолий Максименко
12
3!
4!'
&
5
!
&
#
Сильвестер (Старлаб) 16
3
78!"9&:
1-
;
/
!/
<eep?@y9
B!
'C
!'$
1D
,EFGH
5
&
Александр Козловский Обложка:Пэкман и комета Хартли B
e
D
E!1-' - ," F BGHIP HLeD ) M!!&(
" &.NO-P)"1!*$"FH-')'!
)& )"% - 3 / FQ -')' $*P . &(
)".-&(-M!0&-&)":'!/!P ! '! !)
P % %! )& &"1!&%P!! .' 8 $-
- $')*"!&(01'-$+
!'!* >>"" !1#"! P 1!'
.P!' - + = -/ !! F -')'/ - & -!*".&1!* & !!1( RSC FQG"
.P. " .."'?"$" UP ! $ )-! >!
'6'.& !!"$#%"!"--*3
-&( &.! &( > & & !!1 $&""&( -"-&
U& !!1 =- ! + >! - %! .""1 1!
'-"* $'%P!!* ' - V! $-./ -- !
"1! >!.P. ' WP -" - *
=-$."0"*: !" &(6"#!-1-"# !* - ," F )& $1 " *!.P.! -$!"' X!')'. !* - "-"* $$ %! $1
YHH -" # ' - 5 $$" >"0"1!!.!"ZPOX]/!-)"-".!$
" ! ^<"$; $-^
7 ':1!88
'<%* "_!!
$%%p'##222.a)%*o,o81ca.e)#
4
Небосвод №10, 2010 /+O-O
7"&!-G5"".)%!"'-$!"'CB::!"-"D
""AieLLGNpN/!1')".-$%!!-$!"'
-"-/ $-.( $'!"' =>>- M(!'c31"
:#!'' ' $!1 $-. "'!" =>>- M(!'c
31"!".)%!" -$!"' C/ $&!!
^!- ^q #!'' $' $!1 c ! % !!/
$&!! $&!"- ROsAT u! )"#".)%!"'#
$$0"!1!"!!"!" "!?!&
!!-"# !!# -%!!!!".)%!" ^!-^
' )1*!'!" <' !!"' $! %
".)%!"'/! !%!! " $"-" "".)%!"' "
-$!"' $ !! vhehh
eb sa sje 7$%!!!
'!"" IHH ""! # / -$!" C
.!" !!) )1 ) F &/ &
) X & . $!* w&! V)1 -%
".)%!"'c! !" )1F&B;.)%!"ZsA
xy]zHy]C
hq".)%!"ROsATE-c!-c;!"&
{ exee
h
ce P
haq".)%!" vss +8M8/ ZsA/"
vhehhmebsasjeFD
:".)%!"'-*
e
%%
=/.<DA5.ED?%2JJ242@%KH823EKF%J4/;/1C%J/83L?%/M0/4%35M2%;%
<DE4/;/83/;/<% 1D2J20/35F% J/87AD8% J54;L5% D0/M42653DC%
.E/J853D?% N282E@DEF%.2<LO% M/8PBDO%/MQ5E@/;%;/%
G.58533/?% H4D% R@/<% ML8% D.J/8P0/;23% RSS5E@% TU3C5;2,
V58P1/;DA2F%;% 45078P@2@5% 15?.@;DC% E/@/4/N/% R@D%/MQ5E@L%
1/863L?%/.@2;8C@P% O242E@543L5%.851L% 32% 458DE@/;/<%
<DE4/;/83/;/<% S/35% WMQ51D3CC% 1233L5%.% 1233L<D%
<D..DD% XY% KZ((,>PU@/3K% 7128/.P% J/E202@PF% A@/%/13/% D0%
3DO% C;8C5@.C% 42355% 35D0;5.@3L<%.;54O.E/J853D5<%
N282E@DE%%%
G5[5.@;/%;/% G.58533/?% 42.J4515853/%/A53P%
3542;3/<543/F%/3/%.N47JJD4/;23/%/./M533L<%/M420/<%
0;501L%E/3\53@4D47U@.C%;%N282E@DEDF%N282E@DED%S/4<D47U@%
/N4/<3L5%.E/J853DCF%/E476533L5%/MBD43L<D% J7.@L<D%
J4/.@423.@;2<D% TE/J853DC% N282E@DE% </N7@%./15462@P% 1/%
@L.CAD% N282E@DEF%/3D% J/N47653L%;% N/4CAD?% N20F% E/@/4L?%
.D8P3/%.;5@D@%;% 453@N535]% E4/<5% @/N/F% M/8PB2C% A2.@P% DO%
<2..L%./.@/D@% D0% @5<3/?% <2@54DD% >2% 5[5% M/8PBDO%
<2.B@2M2O%.7[5.@;7U@%.;54O.E/J853DC%,%./15462[D5%
Небосвод №10, 2010 5 <3/N/AD.8533L5% N47JJL% D%.E/J853DC% N282E@DEDF% E/@/4L5%
42.J/8/653L%;% J545.5A53DCO% 8D.@/;% D% 3D@5?%;% CA5D.@/?%
.@47E@745% G.58533/?% H/.E/8PE7%.E/J853DC% D%
.;54O.E/J853DC% J4/.856D;2U@% 42.J4515853D5% E2E%
.;5@C[5?.C% <2@54DDF% @2E% D% @5<3/?% <2@54DD%;/% G.58533/?F%
@/% DO% 32M8U153D5% E42?35%;263/F% A@/ML% D..851/;2@P% E2E%
.S/4<D4/;28D.P% D% 420;D8D.P% E/.<DA5.ED5%.@47E@74L%;%
\58/<%%%%
7"&!- F 5 "'".)%!"* $-. -$!" AieLL
FIGn " ."!# !# -!#/ XX pXp dd0
,"!!'."" 1"'!"'=>>-M(!'c
31": # -*!"# #".)%!"'#/
&(6"# !"% FGY dd0/ "! "0!
B$!"!" 0 Dq=.!/-$!"-%'
)#! / !"* "! CMB/ -- &#
-*!"# $#".)%!"'#/ &(6"# FGY dd0/ -$!" ) '/ >!/" "!
$%"1!* B$!!* -! 0 D V&"
"!! !&1c$&!- FGY dd0 c )!!1 =>>-
M(!'c31" 7. -%".)%!"' c
$")"."1! F & B;.)%!" ZsA xy] z Hy]
C
hD%
W.3/;32C%\58P% 2JJ242@2% KH823EK%./.@/D@%;%
@/<F% A@/ML% D..851/;2@P% 458DE@/;/5%
E/.<DA5.E/5% D087A53D5% -C+% (+
*%
B+$
%,% C(B9F% 18C% R@/?%\58D% 32% 35<%
7.@23/;853L% % 12@ADE2% -3D0E/A2.@/@3L?% D%
;L./E/A2.@/@3L?9F%/O;2@L;2U[DO% 15;C@P%
A2.@/@3LO% E2328/;%;% <DE4/;/83/;/<%
1D2J20/35%/@%!% 1/% &#%``\% a2E/5% BD4/E/5%
.J5E@428P3/5% J/E4L@D5% 125@%;/0</63/.@P%
D.E8UAD@P%;.5% D.@/A3DE/;F% 35% C;8CU[D5.C%
D.@/A3DE2<D% C(BF% A@/ML% J/.@4/D@P%.2</5%
@/A3/5% D0/M42653D5<% 42335?% G.58533/?% b@/%
@2E65% 15825@% KH823EK% J45;/.O/13L<%
/O/@3DE/<%02%.E/J853DC<D%N282E@DE%%%
c2E@DA5.EDF% 15;C@P% A2.@/@3LO% E2328/;% @585.E/J2% KH823EK%
ML8D% D032A28P3/%;LM423L% D<533/%.% 7A5@/<% J/D.E2%
J4/C;853D?% RSS5E@2% TU3C5;2,V58P1/;DA2% b@/@% RSS5E@%
/JD.L;25@%D0<5353D5%R354NDDF%E/@/4/5%D.JL@L;2U@%S/@/3L%
C(BF%1;D67[D5.C%J/%32J42;853DU%E%32<F%J4D%.@/8E3/;53DD%
./%.E/J853D5<% N282E@DE% G% 45078P@2@5% 32%.DN3285% C(B%
/.@25@.C%.;/5/M4203L?% K/@J5A2@/EK% R@/N/%.E/J853DC%
T851/;2@58P3/F% RSS5E@% TU3C5;2,V58P1/;DA2%
J451.@2;8C5@% 73DE28P3L?% D3.@47<53@% 18C%/M3247653DC%
.E/J853D?% N282E@DEF% D% 1265% 32% M/8PBDO% E42.3LO%
.<5[53DCO%%%
H/.E/8PE7% J54;L5% S/@/3LF%/M420/;2;BD5.C%/@% d/8PB/N/%
;04L;2F% J545.5E2C% G.585337U%;02D</15?.@;7U@%.%
;5[5.@;/<F% @/% J4D% J4/O/6153DD% A5450%.E/J853D5% N282E@DE%
S/@/3L% C(B% 42..5D;2U@.C% 32%.;/M/13LO% R85E@4/32O%
N/4CA5N/% N202% b@D%.@/8E3/;53DC%;L0L;2U@%
J54542.J4515853D5% A2.@/@% S/@/3/;%/./ML<%.J/./M/<F%
E/@/4L?%J/0;/8C5@%/@158D@P%.DN328%/@%.E/J853DC%/@%.DN3282%
C(B% a2E% E2E% N/4CAD5% R85E@4/3L%;%.E/J853DCO% 32<3/N/%
M/855%R354NDA3LF%A5<%S/@/3L%C(BF%;02D</15?.@;DC%<5617%
R@D<D% 1;7<C% 4203/;D13/.@C<DF% E2E% J42;D8/F% J4D;/1C@% E%
42..5C3DU%S/@/3/;%.%M/855%;L./ED<D%R354NDC<D%-/M42@3L?%
E/<J@/3,RSS5E@9%;%453@N53/;.E/<%1D2J20/35%b@/%/032A25@F%
A@/% 5.8D% <54D@P% C(B%;% 32J42;853DD%.E/J853DCF% @/% M715@%
32M8U12@P.C% 15SD\D@% 3D0E/,R354NDA3LO% S/@/3/;%
/@3/.D@58P3/%.45135N/%.DN3282% C(BF% D% 32/M/4/@F% D08DB5E%
M/855% R354NDA3LO% H/4/N/;2C% A2.@/@2F% 420158CU[2C%
15SD\D@% D% D08DB5E% S/@/3/;F%.//@;5@.@;75@% #%``\%
e5@5E@/4L% H823E2% D..8517U@%.J5E@4% 3D65% D%;LB5% R@/N/%
J/4/N2F%2%/1D3%D0%E2328/;%E2E%420%32.@4/53%32%R@7%A2.@/@7%;%
#%`N\%%%
KH823EK%.% 5N/% M5.J45\5153@3L<%.J5E@428P3L<% 1D2J20/3/<%
</65@%/M32476D;2@P% E2E% J/8/6D@58P3L?% @2E% D%
/@4D\2@58P3L?%.DN328%/@%.E/J853D?% N282E@DEF% D% C;8C5@.CF%
@2ED<%/M420/<F% D.E8UAD@58P3L<% D3.@47<53@/<% 18C%
D153@DSDE2\DD%<5.@/J/8/653DC%R@DO%/N4/<3LO%.@47E@74%J/%
;.5<7% 35M7% D% D0<5453DC% DO% SD0DA5.ED5% O242E@54D.@DED%
H54;L5% J/87A533L5% D0/M42653DC% 35E/@/4LO% O/4/B/%
D0;5.@3LO%.E/J853D?F% @2EDO% E2E% C% -G/8/.L% G54/3DED9F%
/A53P% N/4CA5N/% D% M8D0E/N/%.E/J853DC% N282E@DEF% D% % ! "%
J451.@2;853L%32%4D.73E2O% %D%%%%
%KH823EK% ML8%.E/3.@47D4/;23F%;% A2.@3/.@DF%.J5\D28P3/% 18C%
/M3247653DC% RSS5E@2% TU3C5;2,V58P1/;DA2%/@%.E/J853D?F%
42..5C33LO%;.U17% J/% 35M7F%/132E/% 42045B53D5% 5N/%
2JJ242@74L% 351/.@2@/A3/% 18C%;LC;853DC% 15@285?%
.@47E@74L%.E/J853D?F%/./M533/% 18C%/MQ5E@/;% 32% M/8PB/<%
E42.3/<%.<5[53DD% H/R@/<7% 35/MO/1D<L% 32M8U153DC% 32%
147NDO%18D32O%;/83F%A@/ML%;LC;D@P%15@28D%R@DO%<2..D;3LO%
.@47E@74%a2E%E2E%N/4CAD?%N20%;%.E/J853DCO%N282E@DE%.;5@D@%;%
453@N535F% 32M8U153DC%;% R@/<% 1D2J20/35%/E20L;2U@.C%
/./M533/% J/8503L<DF% J/.E/8PE7%/3D% D..8517U@% @/@% 65%
.2<L?%E/<J/353@F%E/@/4LO%/@;5@.@;53%02%RSS5E@%TU3C5;2,
V58P1/;DA2%%%
7"&!- I 5".)%!" $-. -
#-$!" -"-/ )!&%!! ^!- ^" ^XMMc
+1(!^ 5 $ #-$!"/ - $ 61(
=>>- M(!'c31" M c".)%!"/ $&!!
^!- ^'$!1$-.".)%!"/$&!!
$ 61( )"" ^XMMc+1(!^ "! " -$!"'
-"-/ - '( = #-$!" <'
!'!" -!& !!-".)%!"'!!!!
".)%!" ^!-^:"!/ "! #-$!"'
''' .&1 & "! # 1!#
-$!"* . %! $!"1! - -!"* &-& B>" !D %&!" " ~
'!" %& #!" -$!" " !" ". -$!"* !"%! $ && ' $")"."1! Yp "!& &"
)-&-!&/'!!$(&/!'.!
#-$!" q !" --" ! !!-"
"!"-"/ $%!""!.! $!"" $
#-$!" /" - /''(' -"! "' "
-"- 7!!-".&!"/ $-.!!!".)%!""
^XMMc+1(!^/ !''"$.! %&IHHe"FHHHe/
& $&! & "$.!& Ip ""!
FI ""! & 7. ".)%!"' '
$")"."1!Gp "!&&"B;.)%!"!-ZsAxy]
zHy]C
hq".)%!"XMMc+1(!ZsAD%
f@/ML% J/1@;541D@P% DO% D153@DA3/.@PF% E231D12@L,/MQ5E@L%
KH823E2K%;%.E/J853DC% ML8D%.42;353L%.%.7[5.@;7U[D<D%
E2@28/N2<D%.E/J853D?F% @2ED<D% E2E% E2@28/N%.E/J853D?%
453@N53/;.E/N/% 2JJ242@2% gOYT% j.8D% E231D12@L% 35%
.//@;5@.@;7U@% 3DE2E/?% D0;5.@3/?%.@47E@745F% J4/;/1D@.C%
@[2@58P3L?%2328D0%.DN3282%RSS5E@2%TU3C5;2,V58P1/;DA2F%
D% 12855%/3D%.@23/;C@.C%/MQ5E@2<D% J/.8517U[DO%
6
Небосвод №10, 2010 32M8U153D?% 453@N53/;.E/?%/M.54;2@/4D5?% XY% KZ((,
>PU@/3K%%%
KZ((,>PU@/3K%.% 5N/% D.E8UAD@58P3/?% A7;.@;D@58P3/.@PU%,%
D1528P3L?% J24@354% KH823E2K%;%.;C0E5% J/%/M3247653DU%
D.@/A3DE/;% J/% RSS5E@7% TU3C5;2,V58P1/;DA2% k<533/%
M82N/124C%./;<5.@3L<% 15?.@;DC<% <5617% R@D<D% 1;7<C%
<D..DC<D% XYF% E/@/4L5% J/0;/8D8D% 2.@4/3/<2<%
D.J/8P0/;2@P% KZ((,>PU@/3KF% A@/ML% J/1@;541D@P%/@E4L@DC%
H823E2F% ML8D%/@E4L@L%.E/J853DC% N282E@DE% D%/13/%
.;54O.E/J853D5%>2M8U153DC%KZ((,>PU@/32K%J/E2028DF%A@/%
/1D3% D0% E231D12@/;%;%.E/J853DC%,% S2E@DA5.ED%
.;54O.E/J853D5F%./.@/C[55% J/% E42?35?% <545% D0% @45O%
/@158P3LO% <2..D;3LO%.E/J853D?% N282E@DEF% E/@/4L5%/13D<D%
@/8PE/% 32M8U153DC<D% KH823E2K% 42045BD@P% ML8/%
35;/0</63/%%%
T/;<5.@3L5% 15?.@;DC% <5617% R@D<D% 1;7<C% <D..DC<D%
/E2028D.P%A450;LA2?3/%7.J5B3L<DF%D%KZ((,>PU@/3K%M715@%
J4/1/862@P%D..851/;23D5%/M32476533L5%/MQ5E@L%KH823E2KF%
A@/ML% J/1@;541D@P% J4D4/17% E231D12@/;%;%.E/J853DC% k%
M/855% @/N/F%;% M717[5<% KZ((,>PU@/3K% </65@% J4/;/1D@P%
M/855% N87M/ED5% 32M8U153DC% 35E/@/4LO%.E/J853D?F% A@/ML%
M/855%J/14/M3/%D0<54C@P%DO%O242E@54D.@DED%%%
TDN328%/@%/@E4L@/N/%.;54O.E/J853DC% C;8C5@.C% 45078P@2@/<%
.7<<L%.DN328/;%/@% @45O%/@158P3LO%.E/J853D?F% E4/<5% @/N/F%
;/0</653%1/J/83D@58P3L?%;E821%/@%;/8/E3D.@/?%.@47E@74L%
<5617%.E/J853DC<D% b@/%;%.;/U%/A5451P% 125@%;263L5%
E8UAD% E% J/3D<23DU% 42.J4515853DC% N202% 32%/A53P% E47J3LO%
<2.B@2M2OF% E/@/4/5F%;%.;/U%/A5451PF% E42?35%;263/% 18C%
J/3D<23DC%;E8212%@5<3/?%<2@54DD%%%
H54;L?%/M0/4%;.5N/% 35M2% KH823E2K% ML8% 32A2@%;%.5451D35%
2;N7.@2% "% N% D% 02E/3A53%;% DU35% % N% =/<2312% 7A53LO%
KH823E2K%;% 32.@/C[55%;45<C% 2328D0D475@% 1233L5% D0%
J54;/N/%/M0/42%;.5N/% 35M2F% A@/ML% D153@DSD\D4/;2@P% E2E%
D0;5.@3L5F%@2E%D%3/;L5%.E/J853DC%N282E@DE%18C%./.@2;853DC%
E2@28/N2F% E/@/4L?% M715@%;LJ7[53%;% C3;245% % N%
H451J/82N25@.CF% A@/% KH823EK% J4/1/86D@%./MD42@P% 1233L5%
1/% E/3\2% % N/12F% R@/%/032A25@F% A@/% M715@%.15823/% 5[5%
M/855%A5<%A5@L45%.E232%J/%;.5<7%35M7%
$%%p'##a)%*o,e%.*/#FG#8)0#CEHICJC
!FF
4)))
%
%
lD.% %%
WSD\D28P3/%J823/;L?%.4/E%6D03D%1;7O%<24./O/1/;F%Y
%D%
O
F%./.@2;8C8%"% 135?% H4/B8/% M/855% B5.@D% 85@%
d/855% N/12% 32021% m2E.D<% d/4D./;% JD.28%;% a4G% n!% -/@% !%
<2C% &F%.@4% &9F% A@/% m24.% <518533/F% 3/%;543/% 1/MD;25@%
1/8N/6D@585?%o%/3D%5[5%;J/835%6D;Lp%j.8D%Y
F%J/O/65F%
/.3/;2@58P3/%02.@4C8%D%</65@%J54512;2@P%1233L5%@/8PE/%.%
/13/N/%<5.@2F%@/%O
%7;54533/%1;D65@.C%J/%42;3D35%
E%3/;/?%\58D%q%E42@547%X*
%-J/JL@E29%1D2<5@4/<%%
E<%H/.8513D?%q%420%;%1;21\2@P%M/8PB5%E42@542%GDE@/4DCF%
;% E/@/4/<% O
% J4/;58% 1;2% N/12% a45@P% J7@D% 765%
J4/?1532F%/.@28/.P% , !% E<% b@D% E42@54L% D% <5.@/F% N15%
.5?A2.%32O/1D@.C%O
F%J/E2023L%32%.3D<E5%.%/4MD@L%
-S/@/% 9%%
>2% 1;7O%.3D<E2O% -3D659%;D153% M/4@% E42@542F% E/5,N15%
;L.@7J2U[D?% 321% 42;3D3/?% e5@28D% M/4@2% 765% J/87AD8D%
320;23DC% J/% </@D;2<% J7@5B5.@;DC% e65?<.2% =7E2% 32%
E/42M85% rX*
s% t58PF%;% A2.@3/.@DF% D3@545.32% @5<F%
A@/F% J/% 1233L<%/4MD@28P3LO% 2JJ242@/;F%;% E42@545% D%/E/8/%
35N/% 5.@P% N8D32F% E/@/42C% </N82%/M420/;2@P.C% @/8PE/% J4D%
328DADD%;/1L%%
%
%
%
%
e/4/N2%.2<2% J/%.5M5% @/65% D3@545.32%;.CED<D% 32O/1E2<D%
>2J4D<54F% 32%.3D<E5% -3D659% q%.2<L?% E47J3L?% -%.<9%
<5@5/4D@F% 32?1533L?% <24./O/12<D% b@/% 658503/,
3DE585;L?% <5@5/4D@F% 32%.8517U[5<%.3D<E5%.% M/8PBD<%
7;58DA53D5<%J/E2023%7A2.@/E%5N/%J/;54O3/.@D%420<54/<%!%
O%!%<<%- " 9%rH28/AEDs%D%r@457N/8P3DEDs%/M420/;28D.P%
F%<841%85@%32021F%E/N12%<5@5/4D@%/.@L;28%GJ/.851.@;DD%
R4/0DC%;LC;D82%R@D%15@28D%%
%
%
%
Небосвод №10, 2010 7 %
a5J54P% 6582U[D5% </N7@% r42.J/032;2@Ps%;% R@DO% 15@28CO%
145;3D5%/E2<5358/.@D% 35D0;5.@3LO% S/4<% 6D03DF% A@/% 765%
D<58/%<5.@/%.%<5@5/4D@2<DF%32?1533L<D%32%V5<85%%
%
%
e47N2C% 32O/1E2% q%.8/D.@L?% E2<53P%./%.8512<D%
42.J82;8533/?% E/4LF% E/@/42C%/M420/;282.P%;% </<53@%
4/6153DC%/@3/.D@58P3/% </8/1/N/% 71243/N/% E42@542F%
42.J/8/6533/N/%35J/1285E7%%
%
%
>2E/35\F% J54;L?%.<54A% -JL85;/?% 1PC;/89F%.3C@L?%
O
% %DU8C%R@/N/%N/12%%
AA
p"##po o%ou'(a*%p*(a+a,o-
.. /0
%
P0Q F%+% F%Km24.D23.ED5%O4/3DEDK%%%%
%
$%%p'##%*KL)c1e,ce.*/#ca%e0o*y#,e2)#)c1e,ce,e2)#
%
+4
..
%
uA53L?% 6D;5@F% E/35A3/F% 35%/13D<%\D@D4/;23D5<F%/132E/%
;/03DE25@% 65823D5% J4/2328D0D4/;2@P%;LM/4ED%.@2@5?F%
E/@/4L5% J/% R@/<7% J242<5@47%;L158CU@.C%.451D% J4/ADO%
e65?% c4/N58% -v% w
9%;%.;/5<% 3512;35<% 5,J4D3@5% x y%
;L158D8% J/%./@35%.2<LO%\D@D475<LO% 2.@4/3/<DA5.EDO%
42M/@% E261/N/% N/12% J/.85135N/% 15.C@D85@DC% -q"9%
jN/%2328D0%;%/.3/;3/<%.;C023%35%.%./154623D5<%.@2@5?F%2%.%
327E/<5@4D5?%W%@/<F%A@/%J/87AD8/.PF%42..E20L;25@%T54N5?%
H/J/;%%
tD@D4/;23D5% 32%/@3/.D@58P3/% E/4/@E/<% <2.B@2M5%;45<53D%
1/863/% O/4/B/%/@4262@PF% A@/%.5?A2.% C;8C5@.C% 32DM/855%
rN/4CAD<Ds% @5<2<DF% E2ED5% @DJL% 42M/@% 32DM/855%
;/.@45M/;23LF% @5% 32DM/855%;8DCU@% 32% 420;D@D5% 327ED%
rJ4C</%.5?A2.s% H/R@/<7% 42..</@453D5% @/N/F% E2ED5%.@2@PD%
.@23/;C@.C% 32DM/855%\D@D475<L<D% 02% 35.E/8PE/% 85@%
-.E265<F% @5/45@DA5.ED5% D8D% RE.J54D<53@28P3L59F% E2E%
<53C5@.C%;E821% E/882M/42,\D?% 4203/N/% @DJ2% D% 420<542%;%
32DM/855%\D@D475<L5% D..851/;23DCF%;% E2EDO% 6743282O%
J/C;8CU@.C% R@D%.@2@PD% D% @JF% q% J451.@2;8C5@% D3@545.%
l207<55@.CF% 42..<2@4D;2@P% R@/% 321/%/@158P3/% 18C% 4203LO%
327E%e8C%2.@4/3/<DD%R@/%.15823/%;%3512;35?%42M/@5%e65C%
c4/N582%x y%%%%
o;@/4% D.J/8P0/;28% 1233L5% D0% M20L% zYz% k<% ML8/%;L15853/%
J/%./@35%.2<LO%\D@D475<LO%.@2@5?% 02% E261L?% N/1%
J/.85135N/% 15.C@D85@DC% -"9% T7[5.@;533/F% A@/%
\D@D475,</.@P%.AD@282.P% 32% </<53@%./.@2;853DC%;LM/4ED%
-@5%.@2@PD% "% N% D<58D% <53PB5%;45<53D% 18C% 32M/42%
..L8/EF% A5<%.@2@PD% % NF% R@/@% RSS5E@% J/@/<% 7MD428.C%
3/4<28D02\D5?9% =4/<5% R@/N/F% ML8D% 1/M2;853L%.2<L5%
\D@D475<L5%.@2@PD% 02% ""% D% ""% NNF% A@/ML% J/.</@45@P%
@4531L% 32% M/8PB5<% <2.B@2M5%;45<53D% G% D@/N5F%
42..</@453/% %.@2@5?%%
W.3/;32C%;LM/4E2% -q"% NN9% q% %.@2@5?% H/%
.@2@PC<% q% NN% J4/<567@/A32C%;LM/4E2% ML82%
./.@2;8532%;% #% NF% A@/% J/0;/8D8/% D07AD@P% 1D32<DE7%
-32J4D<54F%A2.@P%.@2@5?F%;O/1D;BDO%;%@/J, %J/%1233L<%32%
#% NF%;LJ282% J/% 1233L<% % NF% @2E% E2E% DO%;L@5.3D8D%
147ND5%42M/@L9%%
G%/.3/;3/<% R@/%.@2@PD% D0% JC@D%;517[DO% <5617324/13LO%
D0123D?% +% v
%;<5.@5%.% {
% -v9F%
+% v
% Y% -vY9F% +%
v
%-v9F%(%)+%'%%g%
+%Y+%
-()gY9F% % % +% -|9% =4/<5% R@/N/F%
E/35A3/F% 1/M2;D8D.P%.@2@PD% D0% )
F% Y++% D%/M0/43/N/%
D0123DC% % g*% % % % +%
-g9% GE821% 147NDO% 674328/;% 35;58DEF% O/@C%;%
D..851/;23DD% @2E% D8D% D32A5% D.J/8P0/;28D.P% 1233L5% J/%!%
6743282<F% E82..DSD\D4/;233L<%;% % NF% E2E%
2.@4/3/<DA5.ED5F%2%18C%&%N%q%J/%!%%
%
+ "!! B! $! " - $cGHH *.
!!* / $ & !%!!!GHHHD ! " -
. FHHHcFHHn ."" " ! 1" 7!%"!"
$!$0""& "B".1"_XhjGHHppIYYD
%
G%;LM/4E7% J/J28D%.@2@PD% D0% Y
% P+% D% z+
% >/F%
;D1D</F%.//M[5.@;2% 7A53LOF% 023D<2U[DO.C%./835A3L<D% D%
J8235@3L<D% D..851/;23DC<DF% 351/.@2@/A3/%;58DEDF% A@/ML%
ML.@4/%32MD42@P%M/8PB/5%AD.8/%..L8/E%%
a2E65%;%;LM/4E5% 5.@P% 3/;L5% D0123DCF% J/.;C[533L5%
E/.</<DE4/SD0DE5% D%.;C0233L<% @5<2<% >2J4D<54F% v
%
'% C% % +% P+% b@D% 3/;L5% 674328L%
.</N8D%ML.@4/%32M42@P%;5.%D%2;@/4D@5@%M82N/124C%@/<7F%A@/%
J4D;85E8D%;517[DO% 2;@/4/;F% 42M/@2U[DO%;% M743/%
420;D;2U[DO.C%/M82.@CO%327ED%%
W@158P3/% ML8D% J4/.</@453L% 674328L% r;@/4/N/% RB58/32s%
+% +F% % g
F% % {
F%
+% )+
+F% v
% '% +F% g*%
(+% % |% +F% O
*
% D% B+%
%>/%D0%3DO%;%/E/3A2@58P3L?%.JD./E%J/J28/%@/8PE/%
1;5%.@2@PD% D0% +% +% -/M0/4% J545<533LO% 0;501% D%
O~{X9% D% 1;5%,D0% +% )+
+F%/M5% J4/% YYY%
-Y% % Y$% Y
*%,M/8PB/?%/M0/4% 35M2%;%;D1D</<%
8
Небосвод №10, 2010 1D2J20/35F% R@/@% <2..D;% 1233LO% E42?35%;/.@45M/;23%;%
.2<LO%4203LO%/M82.@CO%2.@4/3/<DD9%%
G%D..851/;23DD%35%/@M42.L;28/.P%.2</\D@D4/;23D5%l2355%
ML8/% J/E2023/F% A@/%.2</\D@D475</.@PF% 3502;D.D</%/@%
/M82.@DF%.@423LF%6743282%D%@JF%./.@2;8C5@%-;%2.@4/3/<DD9%
/E/8/% % % xy% T5?A2.F%.% 4/.@/<% AD.82% 2;@/4/;F% RSS5E@%
1/8653% 42.@DF% 3/%;% 1233/?% 42M/@5% R@/% 3DE2E% 35%
7AD@L;28/.PF%@2E%E2E%18C%.2<LO%\D@D475<LO%42M/@%;8DC3D5%
1/863/%ML@P%/@3/.D@58P3/%35;58DE/%%
l207<55@.CF%;% 42.A5@5% 32%/137%.@2@PU%.2<L<D%
J451.@2;8533L<D%;%.JD.E5%.@28D% gF% )
F% Y++% G%
R@DO% 6743282O% J5A2@25@.C% 35M/8PB/5% E/8DA5.@;/%
@[2@58P3/%/@/M4233LO% <2@54D28/;% a2EF% )
% D% Y++%
J7M8DE/;28D%;% #q"% NN%;%.45135<% J/% 2.@4/.@2@P5%;%
35158U% W.3/;32C% 65% <2..2%.@2@5?%;%.JD.E5%
/M5.J5AD;25@.C%;LB57J/<C37@/?%JC@54E/?%D0123D?%%
b@D%674328L%-vF%vYF%v%F%|%D%()gY9%/M5.J5AD;28D%
/@% &% 1/% &% % J/83/N/% AD.82%\D@D4/;23D?% -D<55@.C%;%;D17%
\D@D4/;23D5% 32%.@2@PDF% 2% 35% D0%.@2@5?9%;% @5A53D5%
42..</@4533/N/%D3@54;282%;45<53D%G%3DO%ML8/%32J5A2@23/%
##%%D0% %.@2@5?F%J/J2;BDO%;%.JD./E%T%147N/?%.@/4/3LF%
R@2% JC@54E2%/M5.J5AD;25@%#,&% %;.5O% 2.@4/3/<DA5.EDO%
J7M8DE2\D?% -c4/N58F%/A5;D13/F% 35% M545@%;% 42.A5@%
<3/N/AD.8533L5% r<740D8EDs]% 45AP% D15@% 8DBP%/% 6743282OF%
D315E.D475<LO% zYz% D% J4/SD8P3LO% 18C% 2.@4/3/<DDF% J8U.%
)
% D% Y++9% G.5N/% 8DBP% F% %.@2@5?% 674328/;% @/J,
JC@54ED% J/J28/%;% 42..<2@4D;25<L5%.JD.ED%.2<LO%
\D@D475<LO%%
+ "!! " -! $cQ * -% B".
1"_XhjGHHppIYYD%
=2ED<D%65%.;/?.@;2<D%/M8212U@%32DM/855%\D@D475<L5%-J/%
N/4CAD<%.8512<9% 42M/@L% H54;/5F% A@/% M4/.25@.C%;% N8202%
J/A@D%;.5%R@/%q%45078P@2@L%42M/@L%M/8PBDO%E/882M/42\D?%
l2M/@F% J/1JD.233LO% 8DBP%/13D<% D<535<F%.% E261L<% N/1/<%
;.5% <53PB5% D% <53PB5% G% #% N% oM@/<% x!y% ML8/% J/E2023/F%
A@/F% J/% 1233L<%/% J7M8DE2\DCO%;% A5@L45O%;517[DO%
2.@4/3/<DA5.EDO% 6743282O% -vF% vF% ()gY% |9% 02%
J54D/1%.% % J/% % N/1F% 1/8C%.@2@5?%.%/13D<% 2;@/4/<%
7J282%.% F#% 1/% F!% % e8C%;LM/4ED%.2<LO%\D@D475<LO%
42M/@% q"% NN% J/% @5<% 65% A5@L45<% 6743282<%
J/87A25@.C%.8517U[55%;% % N% 1/8C%.@2@5?%.%/13D<%
2;@/4/<%./.@2;8C82%&%F%2%;%%N%7J282%1/%!%%%
G% 2.@4/3/<DD% 35% @/8PE/% 7<53PB25@.C% 1/8C%.@2@5?%.%/13D<%
2;@/4/<F% 35% @/8PE/% J2125@% DO% AD.8/%.451D%
;L./E/\D@D475<LO%.@2@5?F% 3/% D% J4/.@/% 42.@5@%.451355%
AD.8/%2;@/4/;%32%.@2@PU%-O/@CF%E/35A3/F%R@/%.;/?.@;533/%35%
@/8PE/% 2.@4/3/<DDF% E2E% J/E2023/F% 32J4D<54F%;% 42M/@5% xy9%
>/F%@5<%35%<5355F%.@2@PD%.%/13D<%2;@/4/<%;.5,@2ED%D0451E2%
J/J212U@.C%1265%.451D%.2<LO%\D@D475<LO%D%.5?A2.p%G%v%
;% ""q """%NN%;%.45135<%7%.@2@PD%ML8/%!F&%2;@/42%TJ7.@C%
% 85@%.451D%.@2@5?% D0% vF% J/J2;BDO%;%.JD./E% 32DM/855%
\D@D475<LOF%;%.45135<% 7%.@2@PD% 765% &% 2;@/4/;% T451355%
AD.8/% 2;@/4/;% 42.@5@% J/@/<7F% A@/% 7<53PB25@.C% AD.8/%
.@2@5?%.% AD.8/<% 2;@/4/;% <5355% % =4/<5% @/N/F% J4/.@/%
7;58DAD;25@.C% AD.8/% D31D;D1728P3LO% 2;@/4/;% -/3/%
71;/D8/.P% 02% % 85@9F% @5%;.5% M/8PB5% 8U15?% J/J2125@%;%
AD.8/% 2;@/4/;%.@2@5?F%;% @/<% AD.85% D%.451D%.2<LO%
\D@D475<LO% l/.@% AD.82% 73DE28P3LO% 2;@/4/;% J45;/.O/1D@%
4/.@% AD.82% A853/;% moT% -m5617324/13L?% 2.@4/3/<DA5.ED?%
./U09F%AD.82%A853/;%ooW%-o<54DE23.E/N/%2.@4/3/<DA5.E/N/%
/M[5.@;/9% D% 147NDO% J/1/M3LO% D31DE2@/4/;% AD.82%
2.@4/3/</;%;% <D45% b@/% </65@% J4/D.O/1D@P%;%/.3/;3/<% 02%
.A5@%;E8UA53DC%;%./2;@/4L% D3653543LO% E/<231% D%
</8/156D% T451D% % 42..</@4533LO%.@2@5?% &% % D<58D%
M/855%%2;@/4/;F%F%%q%M/855%F%D%!F%%q%M/855% %
a2E65%;% J/.8513D5% N/1L%;.5% A2[5% A58/;5E% SDN74D475@%;%
M/855%A5<%/13/?%42M/@5%D0%AD.82%@/J, %02%1233L?%N/1%
%
UM/JL@3/F% A@/% 32DM/855%\D@D475<L5%.@2@PD%;%.45135<%
18D3355%-4207<55@.CF%@7@%42..<2@4D;28D.P%@/8PE/%674328L%
@DJ2% vF% ()gYF% |F% @2E% E2E%/M0/43L5%.@2@PD%;% g%
N/4201/%/MQ5<355F% 2%.//M[53DC%;% )
% D% Y++F% q%
32/M/4/@F%/A53P% E42@ED5]% @2E65% 35% 7AD@L;28D.P%/3,82?3,
<2@54D28LF%J4D82N25<L5%E%.@2@PC<9%GD1D</F%R@/%.;C023/%.%
@5<F% A@/% 18C%/JD.23DC% J451.@2;8533LO%;% 3DO% 45078P@2@/;%
@45M75@.C% M/8PB5% <5.@2F% J/.E/8PE7%.2<L5%\D@D475<L5%
42M/@L% q% 45078P@2@% M/8PB/N/F% A2.@/% <3/N/85@35N/% @4712%
/A53P% M/8PBDO% E/882M/42\D?% H4D% R@/<%;% 8D@542@745% 765%
/@<5A28/.PF% A@/%./%;45<535<%/MQ5<%.@2@5?%;%\58/<%;%
2.@4/3/<DD%42.@5@%%
%
M!"*!1"$0""& "."" "!
!$"&:-"*B! GD!$0""& "
&!")1 & "& -! 1(:-"*
! $ "& !")1 & "& B". 1"
_XhjGHHppIYYD%
G%/.3/;3/<%.451D%.2<LO%\D@D475<LO% 42M/@F%/./M533/% 32%
;54BD35% N/1DA3LO%.JD.E/;% @/J, F% 32M8U12@58P3L5%
42M/@L% M/8PBDO% E/882M/42\D?% T2<L?% C4ED?% J4D<54% q%
(P%j.8D%ML%E2ED5,@/%J45<DD%;L12;28DF%/.3/;L;2C.P%32%
\D@D475</.@DF%@/%/3D%;0C8D%ML%;.5%T@2@PD%J/%45078P@2@2<%
42M/@L% R@/N/% J4/5E@2F%/J7M8DE/;233L5%;% "% N%;% vYF%
/M8212U@% 23/<28P3/%;L./E/?%\D@D475</.@PU% G//M[5%
<3/ND5% D0%.@2@5?% J/% 1233L<% (P% 35% @/8PE/%;/B8D%;%
.JD.EDF% 3/% D% J/E2028D% 45078P@2@LF%;LMD;2U[D5.C%;;54O% D0%
/M[5?% 02;D.D</.@D% a2E65%.451D% 87ABDO% YYYF% (YY% D%
147ND5% 2328/NDA3L5% J4/5E@L% W@<5@D<F% A@/% 45078P@2@L%
RE.J54D<53@2%P(X{%@2E65%J/87AD8D%23/<28P3/%;L./E7U%
\D@D475</.@P% 02% E/4/@E/5%;45<C% b@/%;.5% 32M8U12@58P3L5%
42M/@L% T451D% 23/<28P3/%;L./E/%\D@D475<LO% 42M/@% ML82%
8DBP%/132% 42M/@2F% 35%.;C02332C%.% 32M8U153DC<D% b@/%
.@2@PC% !% N% B
% D% C
% J/% 0;5013/<7%
J/J78C\D/33/<7%.D3@507%a2E%A@/%7%@5/45@DE/;F%E2E%J42;D8/F%
<28/% B23./;% ML.@4/% J/J2.@P% 32%;54BD37% dL.@455%;.5N/%
;54BD3% 1/.@DN2U@% 32M8U12@58D%;%/M82.@D%
;35N282E@DA5.E/?%2.@4/3/<DD%W132E/%/3D%1/;/8P3/%ML.@4/%
.% R@DO%;54BD3%.E2@L;2U@.C% kO% <5.@/% 023D<2U@%.@2@PD% J/%
147N/?%-35%;35N282E@DA5.E/?9%@5<2@DE5%G%@/<%AD.85%/M0/4LF%
E/@/4LO%;%/M.76125</<%.JD.E5%/E/8/%%%%
R+L
12/
/
0340
5/ 607 8/
5 60
9 6 0:/ ; <=0:
>? 0: 6 0 ; <6@5
5AA<67
Небосвод №10, 2010 9 B C: <6. 0 0: D6 ; 5 0:E
30
.E
F G
;/ 0 /9
/ . H
<6.;
/
0 .3 .E <6.E; 66/ =
.; ; 0 69 /9
I J0
/ . =
9
H6. . .E;
H9
. 9 K ;/ H6
<9 6 6
<9/.%
T2</% AD.8/%.@2@5?%;% 2.@4/3/<DDF% E/35A3/% 65F% J/@DO/3PE7%
42.@5@% a5<J%./.@2;8C5@% J4D<543/% % %;% N/1%`/4201/%
ML.@455% 42.@5@%/.3/;32C% 18C% 2.@4/3/<DD%
MDM8D/N42SDA5.E2C% M202% 1233LO% )Y% Y% fD.8/%
J/8P0/;2@585?% M20L%;L4/.8/% 02% % 85@% 32% J/4C1/EF% 2%
E/8DA5.@;/% 2M.@42E@/;%;% M205% 7;58DAD8/.P% 32% J/8@/42%
J/4C1E2p% )Y% Y% @2E65% 87AB5%.AD@25@%..L8EDF% A5<% zYz%
a/A355F%E2E%712;%ML8%18D3355%;%J/J7N2COF%A5<%;%.8/353E2OF%
@2E%D%\D@D475</.@P%-2%@2E65%;.5%/.@28P3L5%D315E.L%D4B%D%
@19% M/8PB5% J/% 1233L<% )Y% Y% T;C023/% R@/% E2E%.% @5<F%
A@/% M202% 7AD@L;25@%..L8ED% D0% o4OD;2% D% 4C12% <2@54D28/;%
E/3S5453\D?% -5.8D%/3D% J/J28D%;% M2079F% @2E% D%.% @5<F% A@/%
r.E/4/.@P% 452E\DDs%;LB5F% @2E% E2E%.4207% 65% D.J/8P07U@.C%
1233L5% D0% 1/.@7J3LO%/3,82?3,<2@54D28/;% G//M[5%
k3@5435@%.D8P3/%/M85NAD8% 42M/@7% 2.@4/3/</;F%.1582;%
;/0</63L<D% J4/5E@LF% E/@/4L5% 423PB5% ML8D%
@4713//.7[5.@;D<L% k<533/% 4/.@%;/0</63/.@5?% J/%
7128533/<7%./@4713DA5.@;7F% 42M/@2%.% 1233L<D% D% @J%
J4D;/1D@F% J/% <353DU% c4/N582F% E% 4/.@7% AD.82% D% 420<542%
E/882M/42\D?% D% E% 7;58DA53DU% DO% 4/8D%.451D%.2<LO%
\D@D475<LO%.@2@5?% >2;543/5F% 4/..D?.ED<% 2.@4/3/<2<%
.85175@%/M42@D@P% 32% R@/%;3D<23D5F% 2E@D;355% 7A2.@;/;2@P%;%
./@4713DA5.@;5%D%./012;2@P%<5617324/13L5%E/882M/42\DD%
%v%w
%- 9%
Z*% !##%
%%T
%- "&9%P%
%Y+%P+F%"&F% !#%
!%H%%-#9%Y+
+F%#!F%& %
%Y%+F%Bw%vF%B%%-#9%Y++F%! F% !%
%
P0Q F%+%#F%K>2%J5451/;/?K%%%%
$%%p'##%*KL)c1e,ce.*/#ca%e0o*y#)c1e,ce#
%
>2%RE0/J8235@5%32?153/%
02N21/A3/5%N/4CA55%JC@3/%
%
>2%RE0/J8235@5%kJ.D8/3%o314/<51L%%/M3247653/%N/4CA55%
JC@3/F% J4D4/12% E/@/4/N/% 35C.32% HC@3/%.%.2</?%;L./E/?%
@5<J542@74/?% 42.J/8/653/% 35% 32% @/?%.@/4/35% J8235@LF%
E/@/42C% J/.@/C33/%/M42[532% E% 0;5015F% 2%;% 42?/35%
@54<D32@/42%,% 8D3DDF%/@158CU[5?%/.;5[5337U% A2.@P%
35M5.3/N/% @582%/@% 35/.;5[533/?% l2M/@2% D..851/;2@585?%
/J7M8DE/;232%;% 6743285% +% v
F% 2% 55% E42@E/5%
/JD.23D5% J4D;5153/%;% J45..,458D05% 2M/42@/4DD%
452E@D;3/N/%1;D653DC%-vP{9%J4D%)Y%%
kJ.D8/3%o314/<51L%F%71285332C%/@%V5<8D%32%%.;5@/;LO%
N/12F%/@3/.D@.C%E%E82..7%@2E%320L;25<LO%N/4CADO%JD@54/;%
,% J8235@F%/M42[2U[DO.C%./;.5<% 4C1/<%./%.;/5?% 0;501/?F%
420<54% E/@/4LO%./J/.@2;D<%.% 420<54/<% JC@/?% J8235@L%
T/835A3/?%.D.@5<L% kJ.D8/3% o314/<51L% % ML82%/@E4L@2%
5[5%;% ""% N/17F% D%.@282%/13/?% D0% J54;LO% 32?1533LO%
7A53L<D%RE0/J8235@%%
H8235@2%./;54B25@%/1D3%/M/4/@%;/E47N%.;/5N/%.;5@D82% 02%
F% 13C% D%;.5N12% J/;5437@2% E% 0;5015%/13/?%.@/4/3/?%
TAD@28/.PF% A@/% D<533/% 32% R@/?%.@/4/35% @5<J542@742%
J8235@L% <2E.D<28P32% W132E/% 32M8U153DC%.%
D.J/8P0/;23D5<%D3S42E42.3/N/%@585.E/J2%Y
%J/E2028DF%
A@/% R@/% 35% @2E% a585.E/J%.J/./M53% 782;8D;2@P%
D3S42E42.3/5% -@5J8/;/59% D087A53D5F% D.O/1C[55%/@%
35M5.3LO%@58%f5<%N/4CA55%/MQ5E@F%@5<%M/855%D3@53.D;3L<%
/3/% M715@% k0<5453DC% J/E2028DF% A@/% M/8PB5%;.5N/% @5J82%
J8235@2%D.J7.E25@%35%@/N12F%E/N12%1/%32M8U12@58C%1/O/1D@%
D087A53D5% 55%/.;5[533/?%.@/4/3LF% 2% @/N12F% E/N12% kJ.D8/3%
o314/<51L% % J/;/42AD;25@.C% E% @585.E/J7% KM/E/<K% k0% R@DO%
1233LO% 2.@4/3/<L% 02E8UAD8DF% A@/%;% 42?/35% K.7<545A3/?%
0/3LK% J8235@L% 5.@P% 7A2.@/EF% @5<J542@742% E/@/4/N/%
J45;LB25@%@5<J542@747%/.;5[533/?%A2.@D%%
%
5-.$!;$"!8! i. "#&%!"-
;.)%!"RAsAPxcCLec
o.@4/3/<L%;L1;D378D%35.E/8PE/%NDJ/@50F%/MQC.3CU[DOF%E2E%
</N8/%.S/4<D4/;2@P.C% @2E/5% @5J8/;/5% JC@3/% H/%/13/?%
;54.DDF%;5[5.@;/F%D0%E/@/4/N/%./.@/D@%J8235@2F%32N45;25@.C%
D0,02% @/N/F% A@/% 17U[D5% 32% 35?%./%.;54O0;7E/;/?%.E/4/.@PU%
;5@42F% K;0MD;2U@K% 5N/% D% 420/N45;2U@% W132E/% R@/@%;24D23@F%
E2E% D%;.5% J4/AD5F% @45M7U@% 1/J/83D@58P3/?%
RE.J54D<53@28P3/?% J4/;54ED% % >2%.5N/13CB3D?% 153P%
2.@4/3/<L%/M32476D8D%;% E/.</.5% M/855% JC@D%./@53%
RE0/J8235@F%/132E/% @/8PE/% 35E/@/4L5% D0% 3DO% 7A53L5% </N7@%
32M8U12@P% 35J/.451.@;533/% W%.7[5.@;/;23DD% D%
O242E@54D.@DE2O%/.@28P3LO%;35./835A3LO% J8235@%
D..851/;2@58D%.71C@% J/% E/.;533L<% J4D032E2<% >512;3/%
E/885E@D;% 7A53LO% J4518/6D8% <5@/1F% @5/45@DA5.ED%
J/0;/8CU[D?%.71D@P%/% J4D.7@.@;DD% 32% RE0/J8235@2O%
2E@D;3LO%;78E23/;%
$%%p'##Ne,%a.*/#,e2)#EDCD#CD#ED#$o%%e)%#
%
H8235@24E2%/@%K2MM82K%
%
2!-4RSCNFGH;.)%!"ZsAHiiLebRAsA
%
W4MD@28P3L?% @585.E/J% K2MM8K%.S/@/N42SD4/;28%
J8235@2437U% @7<233/.@P% )~C% %,%/M82E/% N202F%
.M4/B533/5% 7<D42U[5?% 0;501/?% T3D</E%;%;L./E/<%
42045B53DD% D% 5N/%/JD.23D5% 1/.@7J3L% 32% J/4@285%
Y++% WMQ5E@% )~C% % 42.J/8/653%;%./0;501DD%
`54E785.2% D% 712853%/@% V5<8D% 32% 42..@/C3D5% F% @L.CA%
.;5@/;LO% 85@% WJ@DE2% J4DM/42% J/0;/8D82% 2.@4/3/<2<%
J/87AD@P% D0/M42653D5%;37@45335?% A2.@D% @7<233/.@D%.%
/A53P%;L./E/?%.@5J53PU% 15@28D02\DD% H8235@243L5%
@7<233/.@D%/M4207U@.CF%E/N12%0;501LF%32J/<D32U[D5%32B5%
T/83\5F% 1/.@DN2U@% 02;54B2U[DO%.@21D?%.;/5?% 6D03D%
H/.85%.M4/.2% N20/;LO%/M/8/A5E% @2E/5%.;5@D8/% 35451E/%
J45;42[25@.C%;% M58/N/% E248DE2%,% D<533/% @2E/?%/MQ5E@%
32O/1D@.C%;%\53@428P3/?% A2.@D% @7<233/.@D% )~C% %
WMLA3/% J8235@243L5% @7<233/.@D%/M8212U@%/E47N8L<D%
/A54@23DC<DF%/132E/%;% 35E/@/4LO%.87A2CO% DO% S/4<2% </65@%
ML@P%;5.P<2% 35/MLA3/?% >2J4D<54F% 3512;3/% 2.@4/3/<2<%
7128/.P%.S/@/N42SD4/;2@P% J8235@243L5% @7<233/.@DF%
32J/<D32U[D5%7<D42U[7U%J@D\7%D%NDN23@.E7U%1;/?E7%
$%%p'##Ne,%a.*/#,e2)#EDCD#CD#CO#,o)%a*#
%
%%%%%
10
Небосвод №10, 2010 %
:".)%!"' - 1" *
ilec
Lee
h
a
%
+$,-./
-. 0&%$
123-&$&&24
5$ %$$%$P78"
1$4$. $2/ - $.9
.:
+;2.&.:<&,$%
=&,$><P!m7*
@/$ $<%
A$.9.:
#$.9%3
B$%.C4
%
%%
%
-3
%
=/N12,@/% 12;3/F% E/N12% C% @/8PE/% 32AD328% 023D<2@P.C%
2.@4/S/@/N42SD5?F% C% <5A@28% J/87AD@P%/N4/<3/5%
@585.E/JDA5.E/5% D0/M42653D5% 73L%\58DE/<F% @2E/5F% A@/ML%
5N/% </63/% ML8/% J/;5.D@P% 32%.@537% a2E/5% S/@/F% 32% </?%
;0N8C1F% 35.5@%/J451585337U% <2NDU% % 5N/% </63/%
42..<2@4D;2@P%J/1/8N7F%J545J/802C%.%E42@542%32%E42@54F%@/%
/@128CC.PF% @/% J4DM8D62C.P% >/% J/1/M3/5% M/8PB/5%
D0/M42653D5F% A@/ML%/3/% ML8/% A5@ED<F% 35;/0</63/%.3C@P%
/13D<% E214/<% % 5N/% 3763/%.E85D;2@P% D0%/@158P3LO%
S42N<53@/;F% @5% 1582@P% </02DE7% H/% <545% 420;D@DC%
\DS4/;LO% D% E/<JPU@543LO% @5O3/8/ND?% J4/\5..%./0123DC%
</02DE%.@28%M/855%1/.@7J3L<%H54;L5%@2ED5%</02DED%ML8D%
<3/?%./M423L% D0%/1D3/A3LO% E214/;F%.158233LO%\DS4/;L<%
S/@/2JJ242@/<% wwP% Y% -.% 35.Q5<3L<%
/MQ5E@D;/<9%;% @585.E/J% (+% - &F% w &9%;%
/E78C43/?% J4/5E\DD% =/35A3/F% @5% </02DED% ML8D% 1285ED%/@%
D15282% >/%.% 32E/J853D5<%/JL@2% @5O3DED%.Q5<ED% D%
/M42M/@ED% 45078P@2@L%.@23/;D8D.P%;.5% 87AB5% D% 87AB5%
H4/\5..% J/87A53DC% M/8PBDO% 8733LO% </02DE%
<3/N/.@7J53A2@L?% >2% E261/<% R@2J5% 32.% J/16D12U@% E2ED5,
Небосвод №10, 2010 11 @/%@4713/.@DF%M71P%@/%.Q5<E2F%M71P%@/%/M42M/@E2%>/%;D1D</%
J/R@/<7%R@/@%J4/\5..%E265@.C%<35%;.5N12%7;85E2@58P3L<%D%
02O;2@L;2U[D<% >DE/N12% 35% 0325BP% 1/% E/3\2F% A@/% 65%
J/87AD@.C%;% D@/N5% H/%/[7[53DC<% R@/% <35% A5<,@/%
32J/<D325@%.M/4E7% E24@D3/E% D0% 15@.EDO% J208/;% G% R@/?%
.@2@P5% C% O/A7% 42..E202@P% 8DBP%/M%/13/<% D0% R@2J/;F% 2%
D<533/%/% @/<F% E2E% K.BD;2@PK%/13/% M/8PB/5% 8733/5%
D0/M42653D5% D0% <3/65.@;2% <2853PEDO% e8C% R@/?%\58D% C%
J/8P07U.P% J4/N42<</?% PT~F% E/@/42C% 32% </?%;0N8C1%
C;8C5@.C% J45E42.3L<% D3.@47<53@/<% 18C%.M/4ED% </02DE% >/%
J45615F% A5<% N/;/4D@P% 35J/.451.@;533/%/% PT~F% C% O/A7%
E/4/@E/% 02@4/37@P% 35E/@/4L5%/M[D5% </<53@LF% E/@/4L5%
</N7@%.7[5.@;533/%J/;8DC@P%32%E/35A3L?%45078P@2@%%%
&S3
%
k@2EF% 32A35<%./M.@;533/%.%.2</N/% 32A282F% 2% D<533/%./%
.Q5<ED%73L%H/.E/8PE7%45AP%J/?15@%/%.M/4E5%</02DEDF%R@/%
32E821L;25@%35E/@/4L5%/./M533/.@D%32%J4/\5..%.Q5<ED%
%
a585.E/J% 732%,% R@/%/1D3% D0% 35<3/NDO% E/.<DA5.EDO%
/MQ5E@/;F%E/@/4L?%;.5N12%E42.D;/%;LN8C1D@%D%;%<2853PED?%D%
;% M/8PB/?% @585.E/J% H/R@/<7F% 18C%.Q5<ED% 8733LO% </02DE%
N/1D@.C% J42E@DA5.ED% 8UM/?% @585.E/JF% E2E% 45S42E@/4F% @2E% D%
45S85E@/4%
G% J4/\5..5%.Q5<ED% <L% 35D0M563/%.@28ED;25<.C%.% 4C1/<%
J4/M85<F% E/@/4L5% 32<% J4DO/1D@.C% 45B2@P% W132% D0% @2EDO%
J4/M85<F% D<5U[2C% 35J/.451.@;533/5%/@3/B53D5% D% E%
@585.E/J2<% D% E%.M/4E5% </02DEF% 02E8UA25@.C%;% 328DADD% 7%
/J@DA5.EDO%.D.@5<% N5/<5@4DA5.E/N/% D.E2653DC% J/8C% D8D%
1D.@/4.DD%-4D. 9%%
%
4D.%%%%
"M
p"##'uNLOLpeQLao',#NLOL#M
%
b@2% J4/M85<2% 35%/[7[25@.C% 1/% @5O% J/4F% J/E2% <L% D<55<%
158/%.%/1D3/A3L<D% E2142<D% >/% E2E% @/8PE/% <L% JL@25<.C%
./M42@P% R@D% E214L%;% </02DE7% -/./M533/% E214LF%.3C@L5% 32%
M/8PBD5% <2@4D\L9F% @/% 02<5A25<F% A@/% N5/<5@4DA5.E/5%
D.E2653D5% J/8C% J4D;/1D@% E% J8/O/<7%./;<5[53DU%
/@158P3LO% D0/M42653D?% 32% E42CO% b@/@% RSS5E@% 32DM/855%
C;.@;533/% J4/C;8C5@.C% J4D% 47A3/?%.M/4E5% J23/42<% =4/<5%
@/N/F% 015.P% </65@%.E20L;2@P.C% D0<5353D5% 4C12% 7.8/;D?%;%
J4/\5..5% 02JD.D% M/8PB/N/% AD.82%;D15/4/8DE/;% -32% R@/%
@45M75@.C% 35<28/%;45<53D9% a5<J542@743L5% 15S/4<2\DDF%
35M/8PBD5%7O/1L%S/E7.2F%J4/;D.23DC%S/E7.542%D%E2<54L%%
;.5%R@/%</65@%J4D;/1D@P%E%35./;J2153DU%/@158P3LO%A2.@5?%
M717[5?% </02DED% =%.A2.@PUF% 18C% PT~% R@D% J4/M85<L% 35%
C;8CU@.C% 35J45/1/8D<L<DF% @E%;% J4/\5..5% 42M/@L%
J4/N42<<2% 7<55@% 7.@423C@P% 8UML5% 421D28P3L5% D.E2653DCF%
;%@/<%AD.85%D%1D.@/4.DU%%
*3% WJL@3L5% 2.@4/S/@/N42SL% 032U@F% A@/% 18C% 8733/?%
.Q5<ED% -D% 35% @/8PE/9% 35@% 3DA5N/% 87AB5F% A5<% A543/,M582C%
HVT% E2<542% -% CC,+
9% k% R@/% 15?.@;D@58P3/%
J42;12%/@CF%E2E%C%765%32JD.28%;LB5F%J54;L5%J23/42<L%C%
.3D<28%/MLE3/;533L<%\DS4/;L<% S/@/2JJ242@/<% >/F%
J/J4/M/;2;%/13261L% HVT,E2<547F%;/0;42[2@P.C% 32021% E%
S/@/2JJ242@7% 765% 35% 02O/A5@.C% t;5@% 18C% 73L% %;5[P%
./;54B533/% 35%/MC02@58P32C% -E4/<5%/./MLO%.87A25;9F% 2%
A543/,M582C% E2<542% 12.@% 02<5@3L?%;LDN4LB%;%
A7;.@;D@58P3/.@D% J/%.42;353DU%.%\;5@3/?% D% E% @/<7% 65%
J/0;/8D@%D.J/8P0/;2@P%.;5@/SD8P@4LF%E/@/4L5%32<%J/</N7@%
J/87AD@P% 32D87ABD?% 45078P@2@% l20<54% <2@4D\L%;% E2<545%
@2E65% D<55@% 032A53D5% G% 32B5<% 42.J/4C653DD% D<55@.C% AM%
HVT,E2<542% ,#%.% 420<54/<% <2@4D\L% !&&O %
JDE.585?% d/8PBD3.@;/% <5355% 1/4/NDO% E2<54% D<5U@%
.@23124@37U% <2@4D\7% O&% JDE.585?% =/35A3/F% 71/M355%
D.J/8P0/;2@P% E2<547%.% M/8PB/?% <2@4D\5?% % J/321/MD@.C%
.3C@P% <53PB55% E/8DA5.@;/%;D15/4/8DE/;% 732%;M8D0D%
J/83/873DC%;% 32B5<%.87A25% -YF% !F% w!9%
@45M75@%.Q5<ED% J/4C1E2% % 0/3% T% E2<54/?% O&%
J/@45M75@.C%.3C@P%;% ,% 420% M/8PB5%;D15/4/8DE/;% W132E/%
35%.@/D@% J7N2@P.C% uAD@L;2CF% A@/% 32% M/8PBDO% <2@4D\2O%'%
.Q5<ED%<53PB5%;% ,!%4202F%;45<53D%32%.Q5<E7%;.5?%73L%
32% <2853PE7U% <2@4D\7% J/321/MD@.C%;% % 4202% M/8PB5F% A5<%
32% M/8PB7U% o% R@/% 35% @2E% <3/N/% % J4D% 328DADD% J/N/1L%
</63/%D%J/;/0D@P.C%./%.Q5<E/?%G45<53D%32%/M42M/@E7%;.5%
42;3/% J/321/MD@.C% 032AD@58P3/% M/8PB5% H4D%
<3/N/@/A5A3/<%;L42;3D;23DD% E/8DA5.@;/% @/A5E%
;L42;3D;23DC%;% J4/N42<<2O% g% D% *+$%;% 42.A5@5%
32%;.U% 737% D%.//@;5@.@;533/%/M[55%;45<C%/M42M/@ED% 35%
M717@% E241D328P3/%/@8DA2@P.C% 18C% M/8PBDO% D% <2853PEDO%
<2@4D\% <2@4D\F% J/R@/<7%;LDN4LB% M/8PBDO% <2@4D\% M715@%
.;/1D@P.C% 8DBP% E% <53PB5<7% E/8DA5.@;7% <23DJ78C\D?%.%
;D15/4/8DE2<D%%%%
&H+3% 737% M50% J4/M85<% </63/%.3D<2@P% D% 32%
\;5@3L5% <2@4D\LF% 3/% D<533/% </3/O4/<3L5% <2@4D\L% 12U@%
32<%1/J/83D@58P37U%;/0</63/.@P%18C%<235;42%,%<L%</65<%
D.J/8P0/;2@P%.;5@/SD8P@4L% k0;5.@3/F% A@/% 42045B2U[2C%
.J/./M3/.@P%/J@DED%/N423DAD;25@.C% 1DS42E\D5?% D% 02;D.D@%
/@% 18D3L%;/83L%.;5@2% b@2% 02;D.D</.@P%/J45158C5@.C%
S/4<78/?%
12
Небосвод №10, 2010 1D2N/3285?s%,% J4D% 352EE742@3/?%.Q5<E5% 1L4L%;% </02DE5%
A2.@/%.87A2U@.C%;% 32J42;853DCO% % A2.2F% % A2.2F%#%
A2./;% D% % A2./;%/@%\53@42% 73L% -4D.!9% H/R@/<7%;/%
;45<C%.Q5<ED% 32% R@D% <5.@2% 3763/%/M42@D@P%/./M/5%
;3D<23D5%%
%
4D.!%%
GL1546E7% D% 7.D853D5% E2<54L% 3763/%;LMD42@P% @2ED<DF%
A@/ML% 3D%/1D3%.2<L?% C4ED?% E42@54% 32% 735% 35% ML8%
J545.;5A53F% J/@/<7% A@/%;/..@23/;D@P% 15@28D%;% <5.@2O%
J545.;5@/;%;% 128P35?B5<% 35% J451.@2;8C5@.C%;/0</63L<%
H4D% R@/<% 0/32%;M8D0D% @54<D32@/42% </65@%/E202@P.C% 32%
RE4235% 3/7@M7E2%;5.P<2% @5<3/?% >/% J42E@DE2% J/E20L;25@F%
A@/% J4D%.8/653DD% 1/.@2@/A3/N/% E/8DA5.@;2% E214/;F% 0/32%
@54<D32@/42%K;L@CND;25@.CK%M50%/./MLO%J4/M85<%GJ4/A5<F%
./;.5<%@5<3/?%E24@D3E7%J4D%.Q5<E5%@2E65%1582@P%35%.@/D@%%
R@/%J4D;515@%E%8DB35<7%B7<7%;%@53CO%j.8D%N/;/4D@P%7<3/F%
3763/% <2E.D<28P3/% 02J/83C@P% ND.@/N42<<7%;%.;5@2OF% 3/% 35%
/M4502@PF% A@/ML% <2E.D<28P3/% RSS5E@D;3/% D.J/8P0/;2@P%
\DS4/;7U% 4204C13/.@P% -MD@3/.@P9% D0/M42653DC% G//M[5F%
M/8PB/?% 1D32<DA5.ED?% 1D2J20/3% -J545J21% C4E/.@5?9% 32%
735% 1/M2;8C5@% 32<% 8DB3DO% J4/M85<% D% R@/% @/F%.% A5<%
8UM/<7% 873/,S/@/N42S7% J4DO/1D@.C% M/4/@P.C%;% J4/\5..5%
/M42M/@ED%=.@2@DF%D.J/8P0/;23D5%k=,J2..%SD8P@42F%E2E%32<%
J/E2028/.PF%.85NE2%.3D625@% J545J21% C4E/.@5?% 32% 735% D%
J/R@/<7% 35.E/8PE/%/M85NA25@% % 32B7% 0212A7% 765% 32%.@21DD%
.Q5<ED%%
e8D32%;D15/4/8DE/;% 02;D.D@%/@%./.@/C3DC% 2@</.S54L% %
A5<% O765% 2@</.S542F% @5<% M/8PB5% E214/;% 3763/%.3D<2@P%
WMLA3/%<L%.3D<25<%J/% ,%E214/;%32%4/8DE%%
H/.8517U[2C%/M42M/@E2%/@.3C@/N/% <2@54D282%,% R@/%
/@158P32C%M/8PB2C%D.@/4DCF%E/@/42C%;LO/1D@%02%42<ED%R@/?%
.@2@PD% H/R@/<7% M715<%.AD@2@PF% A@/% <L% 765% D<55<%
J/1N/@/;8533L?% 32M/4% ,MD@3LO% E214/;% 18C% D0N/@/;853DC%
</02DED%%%
/44
3
%
e8C%42M/@L%32<%J/321/MD@.C%.8517U[D?%32M/4%%
% PT~% %/SD\D28P3L?%.2?@% -J4/N42<<2% J82@32C9%
+
% % e8C% 32JD.23DC% R@/?%.@2@PD% C% D.J/8P0/;28%
;54.DU%& %P
%
u.@23/;8533/?% PT~%./M.@;533/% 765% 1/.@2@/A3/% 18C%
.M/4ED% </02DED% W132E/% 45E/<5317U% 7.@23/;D@P% 32%
E/<JPU@54%1/J/83D@58P3L5%J4/N42<<L%J/%..L8E2<%3D65%
%
%H82ND3%Y
%
+
%%
$
Y
B
%%
b@/@% J82ND3%;L42;3D;25@% 4203/.@P%;% C4E/.@CO% 32%.@LE2O%
D0/M42653D?%D%5N/%D.J/8P0/;23D5%E42?35%6582@58P3/%%
!%H2E5@%P
%T%'
%%-*
%#" 9%
+
%%
+PTY#" %%
PT~% D.J/8P075@%.;/?% 1;D6/E% 18C%/J@D<D02\DD%
E/3@4/8P3LO% @/A5E% G<5.@/% 35N/% <L% </65<% D.J/8P0/;2@P%
1;D6/E% P
% TF% 42M/@2% E/@/4/N/% 35.E/8PE/%
/@8DA25@.C% H/%/@0L;2<% 35E/@/4LO% J/8P0/;2@585?%/3%
42M/@25@% 35.E/8PE/% @/A355F% 3/% <5355%.@2MD8P3/% /@C%
J4D032@P.CF% J/% 735% <53C%;J/835% 7.@42D;25@% D% PT~%
H/R@/<7% </63/%/M/?@D.P% D% M50% R@/N/% J2E5@2F% 3/% D<5@P% 1;2%
D3.@47<53@2%;.5%65%87AB5F%A5<%/1D3%%%%%
TPTWDX3
%
u.@232;8D;25<% PT~F% P
% TF% 24OD;%.% J82ND3/<%
Y
% 42.J2E/;L;25<%;% 8UM/5% <5.@/% 32% E/<JPU@545%
V2J7.E25<% PT~% H54;L<% 158/<% D15<%;% TOF%
A@/ML% J4/D0;5.@D% 35E/@/4L5% J451;24D@58P3L5% 32.@4/?ED%
J4/N42<<L%G%02E821E5%P
%T%<L%1/863L%7;D15@P%
..L8E7% 32% S2?8% PTY+
% D0% J2E5@2% P
% T%
-4D.9%%
%
lD.%%
j.8D% <L%;.5% 7.@232;8D;28D% J/% 7</8A23DUF% PT~%.2<2%
32?15@% J42;D8P3L?% J7@P% G% J4/@D;3/<%.87A25% R@/@% J7@P%
J4D15@.C%7E202@P%;47A37U%e2855%D15<%;%02E821E7%P%D%
;%.//@;5@.@;7U[5<% J/85% Y
% +% 7E20L;25<%
J7@P%E%S2?87%Y
%-4D.9%%
%
Небосвод №10, 2010 13 G% 02E821E5% w
% |% w% <L% </65<% 7E202@P%
28P@5432@D;3L5% J2JED% 18C% O42353DC%;45<533LO% S2?8/;%
-4D.9% b@/%;263/F% E/N12% 32%.D.@5<3/<% 1D.E5% 35<3/N/%
.;/M/13/N/% <5.@2% %;% J4/\5..5% 42M/@L% PT~% </65@%
./012;2@P%/A53P%M/8PBD5%J4/<567@/A3L5%S2?8LF%/./M533/%
J4D%42M/@5%;% % MD@%H@DAE/?%P
'
%<L%</65<%/@<5@D@P%
;45<533L5% J2JEDF% E/@/4L5% M717@% D.J/8P0/;2@P.C%;% J54;7U%
/A5451P%
%
lD.%%
kF%32E/35\F%;%02E821E5%C
%P%~
%C%45E/<5317U%
7;58DAD@P% 032A53DC% <2E.D<28P3/N/% E/8DA5.@;2%
E/3@4/8P3LO% @/A5EF% E/@/4L5% M715@% D.E2@P% J4/N42<<2% 32%
E261/?%J245%E214/;%D%32%</02DE5%;%\58/<%-4D.#9%
%
lD.#%%
W.3/;3L5% 32.@4/?EDF% E/@/4L5% </N7@% J/;8DC@P% 32%.M/4E7%
8733LO%</02DEF%<L%.15828D%DF%3262;%E3/JE7%OF%<L%</65<%
J545?@D%35J/.451.@;533/%E%42M/@5%.%J4/N42<</?%%
/
+ 4
F3
%
T32A282% 420M545<.C%.% E3/JE2<D% 32% N82;3/?% J2358D%
D3.@47<53@/;%-4D.&9%%
lD.&%%
T85;2%32J42;/%%
T/012@P%3/;L?%J4/5E@%
V2N470D@P%42355%./O42333L?%J4/5E@%
V2N470D@P%B2M8/3%-@DJDA3L?F%0242355%./O42333L?%J4/5E@9%
T/O423D@P%1233L?%J4/5E@%
G5437@P.C%32%B2N%32021%
G5437@P.C%32%B2N%;J541%
>2.@4/?ED%J4/N42<<L%
u;58DAD@P%
u<53PBD@P%
W@E4L@P02E4L@P%/E3/%P
%X
%-4512E@/4%J23/42<9%%
02J/<3D<%R@7%;2637U%E3/JE7p%
H/E202@P%@2M8D\7%E/3@4/8P3LO%@/A5E%-C
%P%T9%
H/E202@P% J/</[3DE% E/3@4/8P3LO% @/A5E% -C
% P%
9%
T1;DN%</02DED%J/%F%%D%J/;/4/@%32%/J45158533L?%7N/8%
H/</[P%%
a5J54P% <L% </65<% J4D.@7JD@P% E% 42M/@5% <5<% E3/JE7% {%
% -.85;2%;;54O7%/E32% J4/N42<<L9% D% 02N47625<%
D0/M42653DCF% J45132032A533L5% 18C%.M/4ED% </02DED% %
J/C;8C5@.C%/E3/%C
%%-XZzw9%-4D."9%%
%
lD."%%
e8C% J42;D8P3/?% 42M/@L% J4/N42<<L% <L% 1/863L%;JD.2@P%
S/E7.3/5% 42..@/C3D5% 32B5?%.D.@5<L% D% E4/J,S2E@/4% -D8D%
SD0DA5.ED?% 420<54% <2@4D\L%;% <<9% G3D<23D5p% G% E2A5.@;5%
15.C@DA3/N/% 420158D@58C% PT~% D.J/8P075@% 02JC@7U%
H4D<53D<% J242<5@4LF% 3262;% E3/JE7% O% H/.85% 02E4L@DC%
1233/N/%/E/BE2% 35/MO/1D</% 3262@P% E3/JE7% *+%
-4D. 9%;% J42;/<%;54O35<% 7N87%/E32% J4/N42<<LF% A@/ML%
2E@D;D0D4/;2@P%1/J/83D@58P3L5%02E821ED%%%
%
lD. %%
=4/<5% @/N/F% 35/MO/1D</% J4/;54D@PF% E2E/?% @DJ% J4/5E\DD%
;LM423%;%/E/BE5% {% % % 1/863/% ML@P%;LM423/%
g+
% -
%9% -4D. 9F% A@/%/032A25@%
J4C</7N/8P3L?%@DJ%J4/5E\DD%%
G263/p% e8C% J42;D8P3/?% 42M/@L% PT~% E42?35% 6582@58P3/F%
A@/ML%;.5%;O/1C[D5% D0/M42653DC% D<58D%/1D32E/;L?%
420<54%;% JDE.58CO% j.8D% <L%/M42M2@L;28D% 32B5%;D15/%
A5450%;L4/;3533L5%;% g% 4/8DEDF% @/% 5.@5.@;533/%
420<54L%/@158P3LO%D0/M42653D?%M717@%/@8DA2@P.CF%@E%J4D%
./O42353DD%;L4/;3533LO% 4/8DE/;%;D15/% J/145025@.C%
W132E/F% J5451% 02N470E/?%;% PT~% 35@% 3761L% J4D;/1D@P%;.5%
E214L% E%/13/<7% 420<547% -;% c/@/B/J5F% 32J4D<549%,% 32B2%
J4/N42<<2% 85NE/% </65@% R@/%.1582@P% V2?15<%;% 02E821E7%
C
F%;LM545<% J54;L?% E214% -\DS42% % 321% E24@D3E/?9% D%
;JDB5<%JDE.58P3/5%032A53D5%BD4D3L%<2@4D\LF%32%E/@/47U%
<L%.3D<28DF%;%/E/BE/%g%-4D. 9F%JDE.58P3/5%032A53D5%
;L./@L%,%;%/E/BE/% B% -4D. 9% =% J4D<547F% 5.8D% <L%
.3D<28D% 32% <2@4D\7% 420<54/<% O&% JDE.585?F% @/%
;JD.L;25<%.//@;5@.@;533/%,%%-g9F%&%-B9%V2@5<%
.@2;D<% J@DAE7% z*% +
% -4D. +9% H/.85% R@/N/%
J545O/1D<% E% E2147% 3/<54% % D% 15825<% @/% 65%.2</5%
14
Небосвод №10, 2010 H/1/M3L<%/M420/<% D0<53C5<% J242<5@4L% g% D% B% 32%
;.5O% E2142O% a5%;% 1233/<%.87A25% C
% 42M/@25@% 35% 32%
/M45023D5% E214/;F% 2% 32% 42.BD453D5% O/8.@2% G% 45078P@2@5F%
<L%35%J/@54C5<%3D%JDE.58C%32BDO%M5.\533LO%D0/M42653D?F%
2% J/C;D;BD5.C% A543L5% J/8C% M717@% 2;@/<2@DA5.ED%
;LM4/B53L% J4/N42<</?%;% J4/\5..5% D0N/@/;853DC% </02DED%
=%./62853DUF%;%;54.DD% PT~% & % D.A5082%/A53P% 71/M32C%
E3/JE2% % % % F%.% J/</[PU% E/@/4/?% J242<5@4L%
g% D% BF%;L.@2;8533L5% 18C% J54;/N/% E2142% </63/%
ML8/%/13D<%E8DE/<%J4D<53D@P%E/%;.5<%/.@28P3L<%E2142<%
j.8D% 32BD% D0/M42653DC% 32%;O/15% J4/N42<<L% D<58D%
/1D32E/;L?% 420<54F% @/% 02O/1D@P%;% 02E821E7% C
% 35%
J/321/MD@.C%%
%
lD. %%
H/.85% R@/?% 35.8/63/?% J4/\5174L%;/0;42[25<.C% E% J54;/?%
02E821E5% P
+% % D% 326D<25<% E3/JE7% % %
H4/N42<<2% 2;@/<2@DA5.ED% 32O/1D@% E/3@4/8P3L5% @/AEDF%
/J@D<D0D475@% DO% D%;L125@% J451;24D@58P3L?%;D1% 32B5?%
M717[5?%</02DED%;%/E35%P
%X
%-4D. 9%%%
%
lD. %%
WE3/% P
% X
% 18C% 32.%;263/5% -J/<3D<F% A@/%/3/%
;L0L;25@.C%E3/JE/?%%
%32%N82;3/?%J2358D%D3.@47<53@/;9F%
@E%;% J4/\5..5% 42M/@L% 32<% J/.@/C33/% J4D15@.C% E% 35<7%
/M42[2@P.C% j.8D% S/3%;% KB2B5AEDK% E2@5N/4DA5.ED% 35%
342;D@.CF% 5N/% </63/%.1582@P% A543L<F% D0<53D;% 32.@4/?ED%,%
TOF% 02E821E2% P
% X
F%.3C@P% J@DAE7% %
++$
%
%%
lD. !%
l20M545<.C%.% 32032A53DC<D% E3/J/E%/E32% P
% X
%
-4D. !9%%
T85;2%32J42;/%%
l512E@D4/;2@P%/@158P3/5% D0/M42653D5% -;LMD425@.C%
32;5153D5<% 32% 35N/% E74./429% =3/JE2%.@23/;D@.C% 2E@D;3/?%
J4D%3262@/?%E3/JE5%%
l512E@D4/;2@P%/@158P3/5% D0/M42653D5% -;LMD425@.C% J/%
3/<5479%
l512E@D4/;2@P%;.U%J23/42<7%
u.@23/;D@P%\53@4%J23/42<L%
u.@23/;D@P%<2E.D<28P3L?%420<54%/E32%J23/42<L%
o;@/<2@DA5.ED%\53@4/;2@P%J23/42<7%
o;@/<2@DA5.ED%;L4/;3C@P%8D3DU%N/4D0/3@2%
H4/D0;5.@D%;L42;3D;23D5F% 0212;% 032A53DC%;%\DS4/;/<%
;D15%
H4C</7N/8P3L?%@DJ%J4/5E\DD%
tD8D314DA5.ED?%@DJ%J4/5E\DD%
H4/5E\DC%.S54L%32%J8/.E/.@P%
e47ND5%@DJL%J4/5E\D?%
H451J4/.</@4% J23/42<L%;% 0242355% 7E20233/<%
J4/.</@4/;[DE5%
l56D<%/E32%P
%X
%J/;54O%147NDO%/E/3%%
e8C%32.%32DM/8PB55%032A53D5%M717@%D<5@P%1;5%E3/JED%%D%%
k3/N12F% J/.85%/J@D<D02\DD% J4/N42<<2%./0125@% <3/N/%
8DB35N/% J/8C%;/E47N% 32B5?% </02DEDF% E/@/4/5%.D8P3/%
7;58DAD;25@% 420<54%;45<533LO% S2?8/;% D% 18D@58P3/.@P%
SD328P3/N/%.8/653DC% D8D% 32/M/4/@%/.@2;8C5@% A2.@P%
D0/M42653DC%02%E42C<D%/E32%G51P%@/F%A@/%<L%7;D1D<%;%/E35%
P
% X
F%;% D@/N5% <L% J/87AD<% D% 32%;LO/15% D0%
J4/N42<<LF% @/8PE/% M/8PB5N/% 420<542% HR@/<7F% 5.8D% 32B5%
8733/5% D0/M42653D5% 42.J/8/6D8/.P% 35%;%\53@45%/E32%
P
% X
% D%;/E47N%.8DBE/<% <3/N/% J7.@/N/% J/8CF%
3763/% J/%/A5451D% 326D<2@P% 32% E3/JED% % -
Небосвод №10, 2010 15 %
%lD. IE4F.'3
%
>D65% -4D. 9% J/E2023%;D1%/E32% J4/N42<<L% D%;% A2.@3/.@D%
/E32% P
% X
F% E/@/4/5% D3/N12% <L% </65<% 7;D15@P%
J/.85%J54;/N/%2;@/<2@DA5.E/N/%.8/653DC%</02DED%%
%
4D. %%
H/C;D;B2C.C%D3S/4<2\D/332C%J2358P%32<%.//M[25@F%A@/%;%
2;@/<2@DA5.E/<% 456D<5% J4/N42<<2% 35%.7<582% 42..@2;D@P%
;.5% 35/MO/1D<L5% E/3@4/8P3L5% @/AED% D% J42;D8P3/%./M42@P%
</02DE7%G%@2E/<%.87A25%J4D15@.C%5?%J/</AP%>/%18C%32A282%
<L% 1/863L% J/3C@PF% N15% D.E2@P%J4DAD37% 35712AD% <5<%%
D% J545O/1D<% E% D3.@47<53@7% C
% P% %
-;L0L;25@.C% @2E65% E3/JE/?%
16
Небосвод №10, 2010 32?@D% 32B7% 87337U% 15@28P%;/%;@/4/<%/E35% D% E8DE/<% <LBD%
J/.@2;D@P% 32% 355% @/AE7% j5% J/8/653D5% 71/M3/%
E/445E@D4/;2@P%.@458E2<D%32%E82;D2@745%%%
4D. &%
E%j.8D%E3/JE2%3262@2F%@/%J4D%42..@23/;E5%E/3@4/8P3LO%
@/A5E% -32AD32C%.% @45@P5?9% J4/N42<<2% 35% @/8PE/%
2;@/<2@DA5.ED% J545.E2ED;25@%;%./.51355%/E3/F% 3/% D%
2;@/<2@DA5.ED%.@2;D@% @/AE7% WMLA3/% 55% J/8/653D5%
J4DO/1D@.C% J/1E/445E@D4/;2@P% J545@CND;23D5<%.% J/</[PU%
85;/?% E82;DBD% <LBD% D8D%.% J/</[PU%.@458/E% 32%
E82;D2@745%%/MLA3/%/@E8UA2U%R@7%E3/JE7%
F"!
% H4D% 3262@/?% E3/JE5% J/8/.L% J4/E47@ED% 42M/@2U@%
/13/;45<533/%;%/M/DO%/E32O% -32AD32C%.% @45@P5?% J24L%
@/A5E9%
C!%H4D%3262@/?%E3/JE5%C4E/.@P%D%E/3@42.@%;%J82;2U[5<%
7;58DAD@58P3/<%/E/BE5% 2;@/<2@DA5.ED% D0<53C5@.C% 18C%
87AB5N/%;D0728P3/N/%J4/.</@42%%
H45615%A5<%J4D.@7J2@P%E%42M/@5%%;%02E821E5%C
%PF%
45E/<5317U% J/RE.J54D<53@D4/;2@P%.% R@D<D% A5@L4P<C%
E3/JE2<D% J4D% 42..@23/;E5% E/3@4/8P3LO% @/A5EF% J/@/<7% A@/%
J/32A287% DO% 42M/@2% D%/J542\DD%;%/E32O% </N7@% J/E202@P.C%
35J/3C@3L<D% DB3D5% D%/BDM/A3L5% E/3@4/8P3L5% @/AED%
85NE/% </63/% 7128D@P% D0% @2M8D\L%;3D07%/E32% J4/N42<<LF%
;L158D;%DO%D%3262;%32%E82;D2@745%E3/JE7%%%
a5J54P%.;C65<% 1;2% 32BDO% J4/M85<3LO% D0/M42653DC%
E/3@4/8P3L<D% @/AE2<D% kO% 3763/% J/.@2;D@P% E2E% <D3D<7<%
@4DF% 3/% A5<% M/8PB5F% @5<% 87AB5% -D<55<%;%;D17F% A@/%/132%
E/3@4/8P32C% @/AE2%,% R@/% 1;5% @/AED% 32% 1;7O% 4203LO%
D0/M42653DCO9%e8C%R@/N/%.32A282%32?15<%/137%D%@7%65%0/37%
32%/M5DO% E24@D3E2O% H/.@2;D<% 85;/?% E82;DB5?% <LBD%
E/3@4/8P37U% @/AE7% 32% E2E/?,3DM71P% E/3@42.@3/?% 15@28D%;%
85;/<%/E35% V2@5<% J/.@2;D<% @/AE7% 32% @/?% 65%.2</?% 8733/?%
15@28DF% 3/%;% J42;/<%/E35% -4D. &9% H54;2C% E/3@4/8P32C%
@/AE2% N/@/;2% a2ED<% 65%/M420/<% 42..@2;8C5<% D%/.@28P3L5%
WM42[2U%;3D<23D5F% A@/% J/8/653D5% 8UM/?% @/AED%;.5N12%
</63/% J/1E/445E@D4/;2@PF%;L158D;% @/AE7% E8DE/<% J/%
.//@;5@.@;7U[5<7% S826E7% D% 02@5<% J545<5[2C% 55%.%
J/</[PU%.@458/E% 32% E82;D2@745% =/N12% <L% 02E/3AD<%.%
42..@23/;E/?% @/A5EF% 35/MO/1D</% 023/;/% J4/;5.@D%
/J@D<D02\DU%-J54;L?%420%J4/N42<<2%2;@/<2@DA5.ED%158282%
/J@D<D02\DU% J/.85% 3262@DC% E3/JED% % 9% k%
;//M[5F% J/.85% 8UMLO% D0<5353D?F%.;C0233LO%.%
E/3@4/8P3L<D% @/AE2<DF%;.5N12% 3763/% 1582@P%/J@D<D02\DU%
.3/;2% e8C% R@/N/% 02O/1D<%;% 02E821E7% O
%,%;%/E/BE5%
(%%
%45E/<5317U%;LM42@P%H*%o%02@5<%
6<5<% E3/JE7% g% O
%;3D07%.85;2%/E32% J4/N42<<L%
-4D. "9%%%%
4D. "%%
H/.85%/E/3A23DC% J4/\5..2%;L.E/AD@% J2358PE2%.%
45078P@2@2<D%/J@D<D02\DD% f5<% <53PB5%.451355F%
<D3D<28P3/5% D% <2E.D<28P3/5% 032A53DC%/@E8/353D?%
-+9F% E/@/4L5% D0<54CU@.C%;% JDE.58COF% @5<% 87AB5%
=4/<5% @/N/F% J4/N42<<2% 32<%.//M[D@F% A@/%/32% 17<25@%/%
Небосвод №10, 2010 17 45078P@2@5%.8/653DC%,% A@/,@/% @DJ2% *
% F% % % D% @J%
-4D.9%%
4D.%%
>26<5<% O% a5J54P% <L% </65<%.3/;2%/@E4L@P% P
%
X
%.//@;5@.@;7U[5?% E3/JE/?%
32% N82;3/?% J2358D%
D3.@47<53@/;% % D% J/.</@45@PF% 787ABD82.P% 8D% @/A3/.@P%
.8/653DC%V2@5<%/@E4/5<%C
%P%%-E3/JE2%
lD.%%
f@/% 1582@PF% 5.8D% <L% J/87AD8D% J/1/M3L?% 45078P@2@% T%
4203L<D%C4E/.@C<D%32%85;/<%D0/M42653DD%420M545<.C%A7@P%
J/065%;% 4201585% KGL42;3D;23D5% C4E/.@5?K% f@/% E2.25@.C%
J8/O/N/%./;<5[53DC%.BD;25<LO% D0/M42653D?F% @/% J4DAD3%
R@/<7%</65@%ML@P%35.E/8PE/%
l208DA3L?%420<54%;%JDE.58CO%D.O/13LO%D0/M42653D?%
m28L5%J545E4L@DC%D.O/13LO%D0/M42653D?%
m28/5% E/8DA5.@;/% E/3@4/8P3LO% @/A5E% D8D%/BDMED%;% DO%
42..@23/;E5%
a5<J542@743L5% 42.BD453DCF% 35M/8PBD5% 7O/1L% S/E7.2F%
J4/;D.23DC%S/E7.542%D%E2<54L%;/%;45<C%.Q5<ED%%
f@/% E2.25@.C% J73E@2% F% @/%/% @/<F% E2E%/@E4/JD@P%
4203/420<543L5% D0/M42653DC% K;%/M42@37U%.@/4/37KF% C% 765%
JD.28%;LB5%%%
H/% J73E@7% % </63/%.E202@P%.8517U[55% G% J4/\5..5%.M/4ED%
J23/42<%PT~%D.J42;8C5@%1D.@/4.DU%e8C%R@/N/%J4/N42<<2%
D.J/8P075@% J/8D3/<%!,?%.@5J53DF% E/RSSD\D53@L% FF+% 18C%
E/@/4/N/%;LAD.8CU@.C% D0% 2328D02% J/8/653DC% E/3@4/8P3LO%
@/A5E%%%
%
%
j.8D% <L% D<55<% <28L5% J545E4L@DC% D0/M42653D?% D%
E/3@4/8P3L5% @/AED% @/8PE/% 32%.2<LO% E42COF% @/% @/A3/.@P%
/J4515853DC% R@DO% E/RSSD\D53@/;% 7<53PB25@.C% G%
45078P@2@5%<L%D<55<%351/J545D.J42;85337U%1D.@/4.DU%D%
35./;J212U[D5% A2.@D% D0/M42653D?% b@/@% 65% 3U23.%
.J42;518D;% D% J/%/@3/B53DU% E% J73E@7%!F% @E% <28/5%
E/8DA5.@;/% E/3@4/8P3LO% @/A5E%;L@5E25@% D0% <28LO%
J545E4L@D?%,% R@/% @2E65%.3D625@% @/A3/.@P% 42.A5@/;% =4/<5%
@/N/F% J4D% 2;@/<2@DA5.E/?% 42..@23/;E5% E/3@4/8P3LO% @/A5E%
-12% D% J4D% 47A3/?% @2E659% </N7@%;/03DE2@P%/BDMED% H/R@/<7%
5.@P%.<L.8% 7128D@P% D0% 42.A5@/;% E/3@4/8P3L5% @/AED%.%
32DM/8PBD<D%/@E8/353DC<D% e8C% R@/N/% E3/JE/?% %
18
Небосвод №10, 2010 45B53D5%mL%</65<%J4//J@D<D0D4/;2@P%E/3@4/8P3L5%@/AED%
;%456D<5%D31D;D1728P3LO%32.@4/5E%18C%E261/N/%E2142%
%%
%
lD.!%%
e8C% R@/N/% 02?15<%;% 02E821E7% {% Y% D%;%@2M8D\5% %
*% %'
% 1;/?3L<D% E8DE2<D% J/% 321JD.C<%
{% D% Y'% 2E@D;D0D475<% -J/.@2;D<% J@DAED9%
D31D;D1728P3L5%J242<5@4L%18C%E261/N/%E2142%-4D.9%
%
%
lD.%%
H242<5@4%{%/@;5A25@%02%D.J42;853D5%1D.@/4.DD%,%@5J54P%
PT~% M715@% 42..AD@L;2@P% E/RSSD\D53@L% FF+%
D31D;D1728P3/% 18C% E261/N/% E2142% H242<5@4% Y'%;3/.D@%
1/J/83D@58P3L5%J/J42;ED%-E/RSSD\D53@L%%D%9%;%S/4<787%
42.A5@/;F% 5.8D%/J@DA5.E2C%/.P% 35%./;J2125@%.%\53@4/<%
D0/M42653DC%,% PT~% M715@% 42..AD@L;2@P% R@D%
E/RSSD\D53@L% @2E65% D31D;D1728P3/% 18C% E261/N/% E2142%
uAD@L;2CF%A@/%E261L?%D0%32BDO%E214/;%</02DED%ML8%.8/653%
D0% <3/65.@;2%/1D3/A3LO% E214/;%;D15/4/8DE2F% E/@/4L5%;%
J4/\5..5%.Q5<ED%.<5[28D.P% 147N%/@3/.D@58P3/% 147N2%
-D0/M42653D5%;/%;45<C%.Q5<ED% 35%.@/D@% 32% <5.@59F% @2ED5%
D31D;D1728P3L5% 32.@4/?ED% J/</N7@% J4/N42<<5% 7A5.@P%
<3/ND5%/./M533/.@D%.Q5<ED% D% @/A355% J4/;5.@D% 42.A5@L% k%
15?.@;D@58P3/F% 7% <53C% ML8D%.87A2D% </02DEF% E/N12% @/8PE/%
J/.85% 2E@D;D02\DD% R@/N/% 456D<2%;.5%.BD;28/.P% E2E%
J/8/653/%j[5%/1D3%J242<5@4%Y
%;3/.D@%J/J42;E7F%E/N12%
/J@DA5.E2C%/.P% 35J54J531DE78C432% J8/.E/.@D% <2@4D\L%
-N/;/4C@F% J/</N25@% J4D%.BD;E5% </02DE% D0%/@.E23D4/;233LO%
D0/M42653D?9% >/% C% R@D<% 35% J/8P0/;28.CF% E% @/<7% 65%
D.J/8P0/;23D5% Y
% D3/N12% </65@% J4D;5.@D% E%
35J451.E2075</<7% 45078P@2@7% H/.85%;.5O% J4/;51533LO%
<23DJ78C\D?% E/35A3/% 65% 35/MO/1D</%.3/;2% J4/;5.@D%
/J@D<D02\DU% D% J4/;54D@P% 32B7% </02DE7% 32% 328DAD5%
24@5S2E@/;%%
R4'L.PaZoCa@aToo[\3
%
j.8D%<L%7.@232;8D;28D%J2E5@%J4/N42<<%P
%T%'
%
% -*
% #" 9F% @/%;<5.@/%/J@D<D02@/42%
PT~% <L% </65<% D.J/8P0/;2@P%/J@D<D02@/4% P
%
T%`/;/4C@F% A@/%/J@D<D02@/4% PT~% 42M/@25@% M/855%
.@2MD8P3/F% 3/% <5355% @/A3/F% 2%/J@D<D02@/4% P
% T%
42M/@25@% M/855% @/A3/F% 3/% <5355%.@2MD8P3/% k3/N12% D<55@%
.<L.8% J4/;/1D@P%/J@D<D02\DU%;% 1;2% J4D5<2% %.32A282%
N47M/%/J@D<D02@/4/<%PT~F%2%02@5<%@/A355%/J@D<D02@/4/<%
P
% T% GLM/4%/J@D<D02@/42% J4/D0;/1D@.C%;%
/E/BE5%O%%-02E821E2%O
9%-4D.9%
%
%
lD.%%
H45182N2U%G2<%.2<D<%/J45158D@P.CF%E2ED<%/J@D<D02@/4/<%
J/8P0/;2@P.C% TE267% 8DBPF% A@/% D3/N12%/J@D<D02@/4%
P
% T%;L12;28% <35%./;.5<% K02M2;3L5K%
45078P@2@L%%%
0+.3
%
G5435<.C% E% J4/M85<5% J545J212% C4E/.@5?% <5617%
/@158P3L<D%A2.@C<D%</02DED%f@/ML%R@/N/%D0M562@PF%87AB5%
E/35A3/% J/1./;L;2@P% PT~% E214LF% 0242355%;L4/;3533L5%
J/% C4E/.@DF%.E265<%;% c/@/B/J5% >/% 5.8D% <L% R@/N/% 35%
.15828D%D8D%.15828D%351/.@2@/A3/%@/A3/F%32B2%;/8B5M32C%
J4/N42<<2% J/</65@% 32<% D% 015.P% e8C% R@/N/% J/.85%;.5O%
/J@D<D02\D?%02O/1D<%;%02E821E7%X
Hg%W@E4L;25<%
P
% X
%.//@;5@.@;7U[5?% E3/JE/?%
% 32% N82;3/?%
J2358D% D3.@47<53@/;F% A@/ML%;D15@P%;.5% D0<5353DCF%
E/@/4L5%<L%J4/D0;515<%>2%J2358D%+%
%%
+
% % 6<5<% E3/JE7% Y% D% 7.@232;8D;25<%
J242<5@4LF%E2E%J/E2023/%32%4D.%%
%
lD.%
Небосвод №10, 2010 19 /A7%/M42@D@P%;3D<23D5F% A@/% PT~% @2E65% J/1J42;8C5@%
;D3P5@D4/;23D5% -O% 9% T/O423C5<%
;LM4233L5% J242<5@4L% E3/JE/?% O% mL% @2E65% </65<%
D0<53D@P% C4E/.@P% D0/M42653DC% -X
9% D%\;5@/M2823.%
18C%\;5@3LO% D0/M42653D?% -% +9F% O/@C% C%
J451J/AD@2U% R@D<% 023D<2@P.C% 32%.@21DD% J/.@,/M42M/@ED%;%
c/@/B/J5% H/.85% @/N/F% E2E% <L%;.5% 32.@4/D8DF% 6<5<%
O% p% D% 71D;8C5<.C% J/87A533/<7% 45078P@2@7%
-4D.#9%%
%
lD.#%%
G/@%@2E%85NE/%D%J4/.@/%;.5N/%02%35.E/8PE/%E8DE/;%45B2U@.C%
E2028/.P% ML%.8/63L5% J4/M85<L% >5%.@/D@%/132E/% 7J/;2@P%
32%;/0</63/.@D% PT~% DF% 5[5% 420% J/;@/4U.PF% 87AB5% 35%
J/1./;L;2@P% J4/N42<<5% E214L%.% 02;51/</% 4203L<D%
C4E/.@C<D%%
KF3
%
H545?15<% E% 02;54B2U[5<7% R@2J7% D0N/@/;853DC% 32B5?%
</02DED%W@E4L;25<%02E821E7%C
%P
%D%15?.@;75<%
J/%J/4C1E7%-4D.&9%%
%
lD.&%%
%%
<5<%]e;op;X@D@\X^e%D%;LMD425<%MaxX@D@\X^e3%
GLMD425<%S/4<2@%S2?82%aX[eboC@a;!P:o;o\:op3p\c3%%
G% 32.@4/?E2O% S/4<2@2% ]e;;XZd\%;LMD425<%.8517U[D5%
7.@23/;ED%BX;cep;: fX;\Co@pCe\\XoZhoZeiayeC\!
a[a;;eZec3%
H242<5@4%iayeC\;LMD425<%B[eZcecpaZoCa@aoZ[y3%
G%OD;pD;bX[e%7E20L;25<%J7@P%18C%./O42353DC%</02DED%
G% ];X;c: D\XZd%;LMD425<% PTWDX3% m/63/% @2E65%;LM42@P%
PTWDX fD; >aCp D\XZd PaZoCa@a Too[\% %;% @2E/<%.87A25%
J4D%.<5BD;23DD% E214/;% M715@% 42M/@2@P% 1;D6/E% PaZoCa@a
Too[\3%
G% B[eZc D\XZd%;LMD425<% ]@aC;f[eZc p[DdXZ% -1/8653% ML@P%
J/1E8UA53%;% 32.@4/?E2O% J4/N42<<L9% b@/@% J82ND3%
;L42;3D;25@% C4E/.@D% 32% E42CO%/@158P3LO% E214/;% D% 321/%
.E202@PF%@2E65%42M/@25@%;/8B5M3L<%/M420/<%
H@DAE7%l\eba\;;CaZ\boC@%.3D<25<%
mZ;eCpo[a;oC BXcDfXc ZoC@a[% -;J4/A5<% </65@5%
J/RE.J54D<53@D4/;2@P%D%.%147ND<D%D3@54J/8C@/42<D9%
OD;pD;Ce\o[D;XoZ%</65<%/.@2;D@P%!%
T/O423C5<% 32%;.CED?%.87A2?% 32B% J4/5E@% D% 6<5<% CCea;e
PaZoCa@a3%
G.5p% a5J54P% </65<% D1@D% E74D@P% j.8D% </02DE2% M/8PB2CF% 2%
E/<JPU@54%.82M53PED?F%;LE74D@P%J4D15@.C%<3/N/%99%
%
H/87A5332C% </02DE2% E/35A3/% J/@45M75@% 1/J/83D@58P3/?%
J/.@,/M42M/@ED%;% c/@/B/J5F% 3/% R@/% @5<2% 765% 147N/?%
.@2@PD%%
3
%
/A7% J/158D@P.C% 35E/@/4L<D% <2853PED<D% OD@4/.@C<DF%
E/@/4L5%J/</N7@%32<%35.E/8PE/%7./;54B53.@;/;2@P%J4/\5..%
.8/653DC%8733LO%</02DE%;%PT~%%
n 4.3% H4D%.8/653DD% </02DE%;% 2;@/<2@DA5.E/<%
456D<5%;% PT~% D% 147NDO% J/1/M3LO% J4/N42<<2O% <L%
35D0M563/%.@28ED;25<.C%.%/13/?% J4/M85<E/?% T7@P% 55%
02E8UA25@.C%;% @/<F% A@/% 5.8D% <L% D<55<% E214L%.% O/4/BD<%
J545E4L@D5<F% 3/%.% 4203/?% A5@E/.@PU% -D0,02% 35.@2MD8P3/?%
2@</.S54L9F% 32% <5.@2O% J545E4L@DC% J4/N42<<2% 35%;.5N12%
;LMD425@% 87AB55% D0/M42653D5% % @/F% E/@/4/5% O/@58/.P% ML%
32<% l5BD@P% R@7% J4/M85<E7% </63/% @2E% H4D% SD328P3/<%
.8/653DD% D0<53C5<% 32.@4/?ED% J!% D% J%.8517U[D<%
/M420/<%%
!% G% 32.@4/?E2O% S/4<2@2% ]e;;XZd\;LMD425<%.8517U[D5%
7.@23/;ED%BX;cep;: fX;\Co@pCe\\XoZhoZeiayeC\!
iayeCec3%
%H242<5@4%iayeC\;LMD425<%B[eZcecaZciayeC\3%
%
H/.85%.8/653DC% </02DED% 32%;LO/15% J4/N42<<2%./O423D@%
32<% ,J4/5E@F%;% E/@/4/<% 3D63D<%.8/5<% M715@% 32B2%
</02DE2F% 2%.8/C<D%;LB5% 42.J/8/62@.C%/@158P3L5% E214LF%
J4DA5<%;L4/;3533L5%J/%J/8/653DU%/@3/.D@58P3/%</02DED%
H4/5E@F%/@E4L@L?%;% c/@/B/J5%;LN8C1D@%.8517U[D<%
/M420/<%-4D."9%%
%
lD."%%
>2<%@/8PE/%/.@235@.C%;0C@P%D3@545.7U[D5%32.%35420<L@L5%
2@</.S54/?% 7A2.@ED% D0% 3763LO%.8/5;% WM42@D<%;3D<23D5F%
A@/% J4/N42<<2% PT~% E% E261/<7%.8/U%./01282% <2.E7F%
028D@7U%A543L<%H/R@/<7%<L%35%;D1D<%D0/M42653D?%.8/5;%
f@/ML% 7;D15@P%;LM4233L?%.8/?F% <2.E7% 32%;45<C% 3763/%
/@E8UAD@P% E8DE/<% J42;/?% E82;DB5?% <LBD% J/% <2.E5% -;%
J/C;D;B5?.C% <53UBE5% 326<5<% GLE8UAD@P%.8/?,<2.E79%
a5J54P% E8DE2C% J/% N820DE7%.8/CF%.42;3D;25<% D0/M42653D5%
1233/N/%.8/C%.%D0/M42653D5<%</02DED%j.8D%<L%32O/1D<%;%
1233/<%.8/5% M/855% 450ED5% 7A2.@EDF%;E8UAD<% J42;/?%
E82;DB5?% <LBD% <2.E7% -GE8UAD@P%.8/?,<2.E79F%;/0P<5<%
M587U% ED.@P%.% >5J4/042A3/.@PU% % D% >26D</<% %
T</@4D<F% A@/ML%.8/?,<2.E2F%.% E/@/4/?% <L% 42M/@25<% ML82%
;LM4232% -<D3D2@U42%.8/?,<2.ED% 1/8632% ML@P%/M;515329% D%
4D.75<% ED.@PU% J/% @5<% 0/32<F% E/@/4L5% <L% O/@D<%;0C@P% D0%
1233/N/%.8/C%H/.85%R@/N/F%E8DE2C%J/%N820DE7%.8/CF%.</@4D<%
A@/% D0<53D8/.P% >51/.@2@E/<% R@/N/%.J/./M2% C;8C5@.C% @/F%
A@/% 32<%.E/455%;.5N/% J4D15@.C%;47A37U%;L42;3D;2@P%
C4E/.@D%.8/5;F% @E%/3D% </N7@%/@8DA2@P.C%/@% C4E/.@D%
/.3/;3/?%</02DED%
n .3% l5B25<% @7% 65% J4/M85<E7F% 3/% 147ND<%
.J/./M/<%.% D.J/8P0/;23D5<% 28PS2,E23282% -42M/@25@F% 5.8D%
D0/M42653DCF% E/@/4L5% <L%.E821L;25<%;% PT~% D<5U@%
20
Небосвод №10, 2010 S/4<2@% Tzw9% G%/@8DAD5%/@% J54;/N/%.J/./M2% 015.P% 32<% 35%
J4D15@.C%;L42;3D;2@P%C4E/.@D%;47A37U%,%PT~%R@/%.15825@%
02%32.%H/R@/<7%;@/4/?%.J/./M%<35%M/855%.D<J2@DA53F%O/@C%
;/0</63/%D%J/E265@.C%M/855%.8/63L<%k15C%./.@/D@%;%@/<F%
A@/% J/.85%;.5O%/J542\D?%;% PT~%.% 42..@23/;E/?%
E/3@4/8P3LO% @/A5E% D%/J@D<D02\D?F% <L% D.E8UAD<%
356582@58P3L5% 0/3L% 32% 35E/@/4LO% D.O/13LO% E2142O% 18C%
.8/653DCF% @5% <L% 02J45@D<% J4/N42<<5% D.J/8P0/;2@P% R@D%
0/3L% J4D%.8/653DD% </02DED% b@/% 3763/% 1582@P% 765%
35J/.451.@;533/% J5451% SD328P3L<%.8/653D5<% 18C% @/N/F%
A@/ML% K357N/13L5K% 32<% 0/3L%/@42M/@28D%.;/5% J/% J/83/?%
J4/N42<<5% 32% J451L17[DO%.@21DCO% -E/3@4/8P3L5% @/AEDF%
/J@D<D02\DC%,% D.J42;853DC% D.E2653D?9F% 2% 765% J/.85% R@/N/%
<L%</65<%DO%D.E8UAD@P%e5825@.C%R@/%.8517U[D<%/M420/<%
>2%;.CED?%.87A2?%./O423C5<%32B%J4/5E@%;%PT~%32%.@21DD%
SD328P3/N/%.8/653DC% -wY*9% e2855%/@E4L;25<%;%
c/@/B/J5% Tzw,E214% -D0% 32M/42% 18C%.8/653DC% </02DED9F% 32%
E/@/4/<% <L% O/@D<% D.E8UAD@PF% E% J4D<547F% 3D63UU% A2.@P%
V2O/1D<%;% =2328L% -4D.!9% D% 6<5<% DE/3E7% T/012@P% 3/;L?%
E2328% -4D.!9% G% 45078P@2@5% J/87A25<% 28PS2,E2328%
WM42[2U%;3D<23D5% % <D3D2@U42% 28PS2,E23282% 1/8632%
ML@P% M58/?% j.8D%/32% 147N/N/%\;5@2F% 028P5<% 28PS2,E2328%
M58L<% -Y':wF%;% k.J/8P0/;2@P%;LMD425<% d58L?9% e2855F%
;.5% 1/863/% ML@P% E2E% 32% 4D.73E5% 3D65% % N820DE% 4C1/<%.%
<D3D2@U4/?% g~B% -18C% AM% % <D3D2@U42% T54L?9%;E8UA53%
-4D.!+9F%N820DE%4C1/<%.%28PS2,E2328/<%;E8UA53%D%28PS2,
E2328% 2E@D;53% -;L158539% -4D.!9% H4D% R@/<% <L% 1/863L%
;D15@P%32B5%8733/5%D0/M42653D5%%
%
lD.!%%
a5J54P% M545<% ED.@P% -4D.! 29%.% >5J4/042A3/.@PU% % D%
>26D</<% % -4D.! 9% =8DE25<% J42;/?% E82;DB5?% <LBD%
J/%D0/M42653DU%D%;%J/C;D;B5<.C%/E/BE5%5.@E/.@P%.@2;D<%
%-4D.! +9%%
%
lD.! %%
t;5@%18C%ED.@D%-4D.!9%;LMD425<%A543L?%-4D.!9%
%
lD.!%%
H/1MD425<% E;2142@3L<D%.E/ME2<D% 32% E82;D2@745% -M7E;L% OF%
Q9% 71/M3L?% 420<54% ED.@D% 18C% 4D./;23DC% D% 02E42BD;25<% 32%
32B5<% D0/M42653DD% 0/3LF% E/@/4L5% <L% O/@D<% D.E8UAD@P% D0%
.8/653DC%-R@D%0/3L%J/<5A2U@.C%E42.3L<%\;5@/<9%-4D.!!9%
%
%
lD.!!%%
a/8PE/% 3763/% D<5@P%;%;D17F% A@/% 71285332C% D0% R@/N/% E2142%
0/32%1/863L%ML@P%32%E2E/<,3DM71P%147N/<%E2145F%D32A5%<L%
J/87AD<% K1L4EDK%;% </02DE5% >763/%/.@2;D@P% O/@P% E2E/5,@/%
J545E4L@D5%;% ,% JDE.585?% j.8D% <L% 324D./;28D%
8DB35N/F% @/% <53C5<%\;5@% ED.@D% 32% M58L?% D%.@D425<%
K02J45@D@58P3L?K%E42.3L?%\;5@%
H545./O423C5<% 32B% Tzw%.% 28PS2,E2328/<% -E% S2?87%;.5N12%
</63/%;5437@P.C% D% J/1E/445E@D4/;2@P% 28PS2,E23289% D%
.3/;2% 15825<% SD328P3/5%.8/653D5% </02DED%;% PT~F% 3/%
765%M50%356582@58P3LO%0/3%j.8D%J/.85%1233/?%J4/\5174L%
32%SD328P3/?%</02DE5%;.5%65%J/C;D8D.P%24@5S2E@L%;%;D15%
J545J21/;% C4E/.@5?F% </63/% 5[5% 420% J/J4/M/;2@P% J4/;5.@D%
;L42;3D;23D5%C4E/.@5?%-02E821E2%X
Hg9%D%.8/6D@P%
</02DE7%.3/;2%%%%
n .3% H/.E/8PE7%;.5% J4D8DA3L5% J4/N42<<LF%
.E821L;2U[D5% J23/42<LF%;.5N12% J42;C@% 1D.@/4.DUF%/3D%
15S/4<D47U@% D0/M42653DC% -/./M533/% 32% E42CO9% k3/N12F%
5.8D%/J@DA5.ED5% D.E2653DC% J/8C% D% B7<L% 32% D0/M42653DCO%
ML8D%;58DEDF% R@/% </65@% J4D;5.@D% E% O242E@543/<7%
r42.@CND;23DUs% B7</;/?%.@47E@74LF% E/@/4/5%.@23/;D@.C%
02<5@3L<%18C%N8202%b@/%35J4DC@3/5%/M.@/C@58P.@;/%</63/%
J/M51D@PF% 5.8D%.E821L;2@P% </02DE7% D0% J451;24D@58P3/%
/@45.5<J8D4/;233LO% 1/% % D0/M42653D?% H/.85%
.8/653DC% 420<54% </02DED% </63/%;5437@P% E% 3/<D3287%
H42;12%;% @2E/<%.87A25F%/./M533/% E/N12% </02DED% M/8PBD5F%
@45M/;23DC% E% J4/D0;/1D@58P3/.@D% E/<JPU@542%.D8P3/%
;/042.@2U@F% @E%/MQ5<%;45<533LO% S2?8/;% D%;45<C%
.8/653DC%;L42.@2U@%;%420L%%%%
%%%%
Небосвод №10, 2010 21 %%%
5@35?% 3/APU% % DU8C% &% N/12% M2;24.ED?% <51DE% D%
32@7428D.@% c423\% S% H2782%`47?@N7?053% J/%/MLE3/;53DU%
J4/;/1D8% 32M8U153DC% 73L%;%.;/?% F,1U?</;L?%
45S42E@/4% k07A2C% 8733L5% 15@28D%;1/8P% 8D3DD%
@54<D32@/42F%`47?@N7?053%/M32476D8% 35/MLA3/5%
.//47653D5F% E/@/4/5% J/% 5N/% <353DU% ML8/% J/O/65% 32% N/4/1F%
/E476533L?% NDN23@.ED<D% E45J/.@3L<D%;282<D% H/%.8/;2<%
7A3/N/F%/@%;/8353DC%7%35N/%14/628D%47EDF%D%;%@7%3/AP%/3%35%
.</N%.1582@P% J/14/M3L?%
4D.73/E% W132E/% <518D@P%
ML8/% 358P0CF% D%`47?@N7?053%
J/.J5BD8%.//M[D@P% <D47%/%
.;/5<%/@E4L@DDF% 2% @2E65% 128%
5<7%320;23D5%q%
$%%%
=/35A3/F% 3215612%
A58/;5A5.@;2% 32?@D%
32.58CU[D5% 737% 4207<3L5%
.7[5.@;2% 8/J3782F% E2E%
<L8P3L?%J70L4P%H54;L5%65%
3502;D.D<L5% 32M8U153DC%
J/E2028DF% A@/% 733L?% N/4/1%
q%;.5N/% 8DBP% D88U0DCF%
/MLA32C%DN42%.;5@2%D%@53D%32%
8733/?% J/;54O3/.@D% f@/%
E2.25@.C%`47?@N7?0532F% @/%
35M/8PB/?% E/3S70% 3DE2E% 35%
J/<5B28% 5<7%.@2@P%;% &%
N/17% J4/S5../4/<%
2.@4/3/<DD%;% mU3O535%
T@/D@%.E202@PF% R@2%/BDME2% D%
J/.J5B3L?%;L;/1% q% 1285E/%
35% J54;/5% A712A5.@;/%
`47?@N7?0532% G% 327A3LO%
E47N2O% 021/8N/% 1/% R@/N/%
71D;D@58P3/N/% r/@E4L@DCs%
/3% 765% J4/.8L8%.;/D<%
M/N2@L<%;//M42653D5<F%%
%%
8DBP% 35<3/ND<% 7.@7J2U[D<% 5N/%.//@5A5.@;533DE7%
mU3ON270537%%%
=2E% ML% @/% 3D% ML8/F%`47?@N7?053%;35.% 35<28L?%;E821%;%
<51D\D37%D%ML8%15?.@;D@58P3/%O/4/BD<%32M8U12@585<%%
733L?% N/4/1%`47?@N7?053% 42.J/82N25@.C%;% 35.E/8PEDO%
15.C@E2O% ED8/<5@4/;%.5;54355% E42@542% 4@54% -Y
9%
22
Небосвод №10, 2010 =/35A3/F%;2<%J/@45M75@.C%M/8PB/5%;//M42653D5%-;/0</63/%
35% <53PB5F% A5<% 7%`47?@N7?05329F% A@/ML% 42..</@45@P%;% R@/?%
N47JJ5% O/8</;% 8733L?% N/4/1% a5<% 35% <5355F% 1/.@2@/A3/%
02M2;3/% 32?@D% 32% 8733/?% J/;54O3/.@D% R@/% D.@/4DA5.E/5%
<5.@/% D% J/JL@2@P.C% 78/;D@P% </<53@F% E/N12%;//M42653D5%
.</65@%/MQ51D3D@P%.;5@8L5% D% @5<3L5% 7A2.@ED%;% 35A@/%
J/O/655%32%.45135;5E/;7U%E45J/.@P%%
7AB55%;45<C% 18C% 32M8U153DC% N/4/12%`47?@N7?053% q%;/%
;45<C% 02O/12% 321% 3D<% T/83\2F% E/N12%;/042.@% 73L%
./.@2;8C5@% !% 13C% k<533/% J4D% @2EDO% 7.8/;DCO% J/A@D% %
85@% 32021% M2;24.ED?% 2.@4/3/<% D%.15828%.;/%/BDM/A3/5%
/@E4L@D5%%
%
%
j[5%/13/%/BDM/A3/5%/@E4L@D5%.851/;%;3505<3/?%6D03D%32%
735% J4/D0/B8/%;% "!% N/17% D% 3215828/% M82N/124C% Tmk%
N/4201/% M/8PB5% B7<2% e58/% ML8/% @2E% "% DU8C% "!% N/12%
e6/3% W>D88F% 327A3L?% 4512E@/4% >PU,/4E% 5428P1%
a4DMPU3F% 32J42;D8%.;/?% ,1U?</;L?% 45S42E@/4% 32% 737% D%
32% 7;58DA53DD%"O% J4D3C8.C% 42..<2@4D;2@P% 02J2137U%
/J42;7% m/4C% =4D0D./;% V2O/1C[55% 321% m/45<% =4D0D./;%
T/83\5%.;/D<D% E/.L<D% 87A2<D%/.;5[28/%;L./ED5% JDEDF%
E/@/4L5%.@/C8D%E2E%/.@4/;2%;%A543/<%</45%@53D%G3D<23D5%
W>D882% J4D;85E% <2853PED?%/.@4/;/E%.;5@2F% E/@/4L?%
;L158C8.C%32%S/35%/E4762U[5?%@5<3/@L%W3%;LN8C158%E2E%
J4/N28D32% <5617% <L.2<D% W8D;DC% D% 2;D3D?%
V2D3@545./;233L?% R@D<% C;853D5<F% W>D88% 420/N328%
7;58DA53D5% 1/% O% =2E/;/% 65% ML8/% 5N/% 71D;853D5F% E/N12%
J5451% 3D<% J451.@28% 24/A3L?% </.@F%./51D3CU[D?% <5617%
./M/?%/M2%<L.2%%%%
H/O/6D5% 24ED% </63/% 32M8U12@P% J/;.U17% 32% V5<85%
>2J4D<54F%;% To% J/8P075@.C%/./M/?% J/J78C43/.@PU%
32\D/328P3L?% J24E% o4EDF% N15% @2EDO% J4D4/13LO% A715.%
32.AD@L;25@.C%J242%@L.CA%
W132E/% J/%.42;353DU%.% 05<3L<D% 87332C% 24E2%/E20282.P%
J4/.@/% D.J/8D3/<% T8517U[D<% 7@4/<% W>D88%/J/;5.@D8%/%
.;/5<%/@E4L@DD%147NDO%32M8U12@585?%PU%H54.D%GD8ED3.F%
1D45E@/4% 733/?% T5E\DD% d4D@23.E/?% o.@4/3/<DA5.E/?%
o../\D2\DDF% J/87AD;BD?% @585N42<<7% D0% ToF% J/32A287%
/@35..C% E%/@E4L@DU% </.@2% 32% 735%.%/J45158533/?% 1/85?%
.E5J@D\D0<2% GD8ED3.% ML8% 7;2625<L<% 32M8U12@585<F%/3%
J4/.82;D8.C%;LJ7.E/<%/A53P% J/14/M3/?% E24@L% 73L% q%
J4/17E@2%15.C@D85@D?%@[2@58P3/N/%@4712%q%DF%5.@5.@;533/F%
42355% 3DA5N/% J/1/M3/N/% D<% 35% ML8/% 02<5A53/%;% R@/<%
42?/35%%
% 2;N7.@2F% E/N12% 8733L?% @54<D32@/4% 42.J/82N28.C%
J4D<543/%;%@/<%65%<5.@5F%E2E%D%@/N12F%E/N12%W>D88%.15828%
.;/%/@E4L@D5F% GD8ED3.% M50%/./MLO% J4/M85<% 420N8C158%
24/A3L?%</.@%;%.;/?% ,1U?</;L?%45S85E@/4%>2%!O%5N/%
@585.E/J% C;3/% J/E20L;28% 24E7F% E/@/42C%/@M42.L;282% @53P%
H4/1/862C%.;/D% 32M8U153DCF% GD8ED3.% 02<5@D8F% A@/% @53P%
<518533/%J545<5[25@.C%;.851.@;D5%02O/12%T/83\2F%2%.2<2%
24E2%/.@25@.C% 35J/1;D63/?% k0<5453DC% J/E2028DF% A@/% 24E2%
D<55@% 18D37% J4D<543/% % <D8DF% A@/%;% % 420% <53PB5%
7E20233/N/%W>D88/<%;%.//M[53DD%T/<353D?%M/8PB5%35@F%D%
GD8ED3.%.J5BD@% J/0142;D@P%.;/5N/% E/885N7%.%/@E4L@D5<%
W132E/% J/0142;853D5%/J/0128/F% >PU,/4E.ED?%
32M8U12@58P%.E/4/J/.@D63/%.E/3A28.CF% 35% 7.J5;% J/87AD@P%
@585N42<<7%%
T@24L?%.;5@% 8DE/;28% GD8ED3.% 125@% D3@54;PU% BBCF% N15%
N/;/4D@F% A@/%.15823/% 73DE28P3/5%/@E4L@D5% f@/% </.@% 32%
735F%;35%;.CE/N/%./<353DCF%D.E7..@;533/N/%J4/D.O/6153DCF%
@2E% E2E% 24E7% @2E/N/% 420<542% 35% </N82%./012@P% J4D4/12% b@7%
3/;/.@P% J/1O;2@D8D% <3/ND5% D0123DC% D% 420178D% D0% 355%
32.@/C[7U%.53.2\DU%%
G% >/;/<% T;5@5% 7A53L5% ML8D% M/855%/.@/4/63L%;%
;L.E20L;23DCO% u/8@54% 22.F% 1D45E@/4% o../\D2\DD% 733/,
H8235@3LO% >2M8U12@585?% -{PO9F%/@E4L@/%;L420D8%
./<353DCF% A@/%/MQ5E@% @2E/N/% 420<542% </N% ML@P% J4/J7[53%
<3/ND<D% 32M8U12@58C<D%;% @5A53D5% 35.E/8PEDO%.@/85@D?%
WN4/<3/5% E/8DA5.@;/% 8UMD@585?% D% J4/S5..D/328/;%
32J42;D8D%.;/D% @585.E/JL% 32% @2D3.@;533L?% 8733L?% </.@%
m3/N/AD.8533L5%32M8U153DC%;%/A54513/?%420%42047BD8D%;%
JL8P%@;/453D5%<DSDA5.EDO%8733LO%6D@585?%m/.@%/E2028.C%
/A54513/?% DN4/?% @53D% D%.;5@2% k.JL@L;2C% <3/65.@;/%
32.<5B5EF% GD8ED3.%;L3761533/% 128%/A54513/5% D3@54;PU%
TmkF%;% E/@/4/<%/M;D3D8% DO%;% @/<F% A@/%/3D%;L4;28D% S420L%
D0%E/3@5E.@2%D%D.E7..@;533/%./0128D%.53.2\DU%%%
k.@/4DUF% E2E%/MLA3/F% 1/.@2@/A3/% ML.@4/% 02ML8DF% J42;12%
/32%7.J582%7;5E/;5AD@P.C%;%42M/@2O%4208DA3LO%2;@/4/;F%%
Небосвод №10, 2010 23 %
E/@/4L5%.J5E78D47U@% 32% D3@545.5% 8U15?% E% >W% a2<% m/.@%
W>D882% J4D;/1D@.C% E2E% 24N7<53@%.7[5.@;/;23DC%
;3505<3/?% 6D03D% q% CE/ML% @2D3.@;533L5% D3/J8235@C35%
ML.@4/%;/01;DN8D% 5N/% 18C%.;/DO% 3761F% 2% J/@/<% J4/.@/%
02<58D%.851LF%J/83/.@PU%42047BD;%j[5%/13/%7J/<D323D5%
</63/% 32?@D%;% 327A3/?% S23@2.@DE5% G% " % N/17%;LB58%
4/<23% o4@742% =824E2% r7332C% JL8PsF%/1D3% D0% J54./3265?%
E/@/4/N/%/@J42;D8.C% 32% 737% 18C% J/D.E/;% 1/E202@58P.@;2%
.7[5.@;/;23DC%m/.@2%W>D82%%%
TJ7.@C% M/855% J/87;5E2% m/.@% W>D882%;.5% 5[5% </63/%
32M8U12@P% 32% 7ML;2U[5?% 735F% 5.8D% 32J42;D@P% @585.E/J%
32%/E42D37% m/4C% =4D0D./;F% E/N12%.5853/N42SDA5.E2C%
1/8N/@2%@54<D32@/42%-+9%42;32% #%-G/042.@%73L%
J4D<543/% #F% 135?9% a/A3/5%;45<C% C;853DC%;.5N12% </63/%
42..AD@2@P%;%J4/N42<<5%
%(%%
%
>7% D% 32J/.851/E%/M42@D@5%;3D<23D5% 32% 5[5%/137%
032<53D@7U%87337U%D88U0DU%q%733L?%F%@2E65%D0;5.@37U%
E2E% G54354% F% J/.E/8PE7% 32O/1D@.C%/32% 35J/1285E7%/@%#,
ED8/<5@4/;/N/% E42@542% G54354% -
9% e/J/18D33/% 35%
D0;5.@3/F%E@/%J54;L?%5%32M8U128%D%128%320;23D5F%3/%%q%
/1D3%D0%C4EDO%J4D<54/;%@/N/F%E2E%./A5@23D5%/.;5[533/.@D%D%
458P5S2% </65@%./012;2@P% J4DA718D;L5% 70/4LF% E/@/4L5%
;D13L% E261L?% <5.C\F% 3/%.@23/;C@.C% 1/.@7J3L%;0/47%
32M8U12@58C% 32%/A53P% E/4/@E/5%;45<C% d7E;2% %
J4/C;8C5@.CF%E/N12%;/.O/1C[55%T/83\5%32AD325@%/.;5[2@P%
./J4DE2.2U[D5.C%.@53ED% E42@54/;% d823ED3%
-B+9F% 2E2?8P% -{% C9% D% H74M2O%
-P
+9F% 18D@.C% R@/% J4D<543/% % A2.2F%
E/N12% 732% 32O/1D@.C%;% S205% J54;/?%
A5@;54@D% -1/8N/@2% @54<D32@/42% J4D<543/%
!#,!"9%eR;D1%f5J<53%J4/;58%1/.@2@/A3/%
M/8PB/5% D..851/;23D5% R@/N/% S53/<532% D%
/JD.28%;%.;/5?%.@2@P5%T%{
%Z%wF%N15%
J4/2328D0D4/;28% <3/65.@;/% 32M8U153D?F%
32%/.3/;23DD% E/@/4LO%.15828% J/JL@E7%
/J4515853DC% 32D87AB5N/% J54D/12% 18C% 5N/%
32M8U153DC%
%
%%%%%
%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
24
Небосвод №10, 2010 %
%%%%%
L.%%
%
a4D% 3/;LO% J545<533LO% 0;501L%;%./0;501DD% W;32% ML8D%
/@E4L@L% 32% 7128533/% 7J42;8C5</<% 2.@4/SD0DA5.E/<%
45S42E@/45% ol, &%/M.54;2@/4DD% T+% (% -To9%;% J/85%
0453DC%420<54/<%&#%%&!%E2@2E8D0<DA5.E/?%J545<533/?%
0;501L% aa% W;32% b@D% 0;501L%,% Y)O,B % #, "F%
Y)O,B % ", #% D% Y)O,B % &,% %
ML8D% J451;24D@58P3/% 0245ND.@4D4/;23L%;% E2@28/N5% YZ%
-
% Y
% ZF% YO9% D% J/87AD8D%.//@;5@.@;533/%
32D<53/;23DC% YZ% v!&: !F% YZ%
v#! : !%D%YZ%v #: !%
H54;L5% 1;5% 0;501L% % 02@<533L5% 1;/?3L5F% D% ML8D%
E82..DSD\D4/;23L% E2E% 0;501L% @DJ2% % (% -X9% =4D;2C%
@45@P5?% 0;501L% <28/2<J8D@7132C% D%.D37./D128P32C% b@2%
0;5012% </65@% ML@P% E82..DSD\D4/;232% E2E% e58P@2% D@2%
-YCT9% D8D% E2E% 1;/?32C%.D.@5<2%.% <28L<% 32E8/3/<% M50%
02@<53D?%%@DJ%X%%
30
mL% 32M8U128D% J/85% E2@2E8D0<DA5.E/?% J545<533/?% 0;501L%
aa% W;32%;% J54D/1%.% v % J/% v% G.5%
32M8U153DC% ML8D% J/87A53L% 32% 7128533/% 7J42;8C5</<%
45S42E@/45% ol, &% - &F% w ! #9%/M.54;2@/4DD%
T+% (% -(F% )% (+F% Y9F% E/@/4L?%/M/471/;23%
HVT% E2<54/?% YBz~% YT{, % H/85% 0453DC% &#% % &!%
m2E.D<7<% E;23@/;/?% RSS5E@D;3/.@D%.53./42% R@/?% E2<54L%
M8D0/E%E%.@23124@3/?%J/8/.5%g%H/R@/<7%18C%E28DM4/;ED%<L%
D.J/8P0/;28D%0;5013L5%;58DAD3L%;%SD8P@45%g%
T451D% J4D<543/% % @/A5A3LO% D.@/A3DE/;F%
/@/615.@;8533LO% 32% 32BDO%.3D<E2OF% <L% 32B8D%!%
J545<533L5%0;501L%%
314.
e8C% @/N/% A@/ML%;L158D@P% 3/;L5% J545<533L5% 0;501LF% <L%
1;261L% D..851/;28D% 87ABD5%.3D<ED% J/8C% D%
J4/2328D0D4/;28D% 02;D.D</.@P% 1D.J54.DD%/@%.45135N/%
032A53DC% C4E/.@D%;% J4/N42<<5% C,(+$% -(F% #9%
H54;L<% B2N/<% ML8/% D..851/;23D5% 32DM/855% 18D33/?%
.54DD%-#%A2./;9F%E/@/42C%ML82% J/87A532%v% F%A@/ML%
;LC;D@P% E/4/@E/J54D/1DA5.ED5% J545<533L5% G@/4/?% B2N%,%
J4/;54E2%.3D<E/;% 02%;5.P% J54D/1% 32M8U153D?% 18C%
D..851/;23DC% 328DADC% 1/8N/J54D/1DA5.EDO% J545<533LO%
0;501%e8C%R@/N/%;LMD428/.P%35.E/8PE/%.3D<E/;%;%3/AP%
l5078P@2@/<% J54;/N/% B2N2%/E2028D.P%!% 3/;LO% J545<533LO%
Y)O,B % #, "F% Y)O,B % ", #% D%
Y)O,B % &,% =%./62853DUF%
1/8N/J54D/1DA5.ED5% J545<533L5% 35% ML8D% 32?153Lf@/ML%
J4/;54D@PF% C;8CU@.C% 8D% 32?1533L5% J545<533L5% 0;501L%
5[%35D0;5.@3L<DF%D.J/8P0/;28.C%.54;D.%g%
H/8/653DC%3/;LO%J545<533LO%0;501%J/E2023L%32%lD.% %%!%
mL%;LM428D%!% 0;501L%.42;353DC% Y)O,B % ,
#F% Y)O,B % ,###% % Y)O,B % ,
% kO% 0;5013L5%;58DAD3L%;% SD8P@45% g% D% J/E202@58D%
\;5@2% ,gF%./N82.3/% o% 531537% -#9F% 123L%;% a2M% F% 2% DO%
42.J/8/653D5%/@<5A53/% 32% lD.% % f@/ML%/J45158D@P%
\;5@/;L5%E/RSSD\D53@L%@423.S/4<2\DDF%<L%D.J/8P0/;28D%
.4513D5% 032A53DC% 0;5013LO%;58DAD3%!"% 0;501% J/% 32BD<%
32M8U153DC<%D%.//@;5@.@;7U[D5%1233L5%D0%M20L%531532%
T//@3/B53D5% <5617% 32B5?% D3.@47<53@28P3/?%.D.@5</?% D%
.D.@5</?% 531532% ML8/%;LAD.853/%.% J/</[PU% J4/N42<<L%
KOK%-
*F% 9%
%
DBDHFXHBHQIHDHGGHBHXH −
⋅
±
+
±
−
=
−
%
N15%CUV32BD%0;5013L5%;58DAD3LF%U%D%W%%;58DAD3L%;%
.@23124@3LO%J/8/.2O%g%D%%V32A53DC%E/RSSD\D53@/;%
@423.S/4<2\DD%M8D0ED%E%378UF%J/R@/<7%18C%E28DM4/;ED%
S/@/<5@4DD%<L%D.J/8P0/;28D%0;5013L5%;58DAD3L%0;501%
.42;353DC%;%J/8/.5%U%
%%%%
a2M8D\2% %V;01L%.42;353DC%%
% Y)O,
B %
g%-9% +% g% ,g%
Co@
p
,
#
%
"!&
%: "&
% ! % %
Co@
p
,
##
#%
#
#
%: !"
% ! % #%
Co@
p
,
%
#
!! %: % !&% !!%
%
7"GFH-!1$ !!*..
sROcBGHGHXYcHHFGpnN%
%
%%%
%
7"IFH-!1$ !!*..
sROcBGHGHXQcHHFFXNF
Небосвод №10, 2010 25 %
%7"FFH-!1$ !!*..
sROcBGHGHXncHHFGYXp
%
%
7"XTTAh""..!!"'
.!"'FHxFH
%
3'+
H4DM8D0D@58P3L5% 032A53DC% S/@/<5@4DA5.EDO%
J54D/1/;% 3/;LO% J545<533LO% 0;501% ML8D% J451;24D@58P3/%
/J4515853L%;% J4/N42<<5% X''+% -~
$F% 9% e8C%
J54D/1/N42<<3/N/% 2328D02% <L% D.J/8P0/;28D% <5@/1%
2S8542%D%=D3<232%- "9%%
e8C%/M5DO%0;501F%D%18C%Y)O,B % #, "F%D%18C%
Y)O,B % ", #%@DJ%J545<533/.@D%ML8%/J4515853%
E2E% X% -% (9F% 2% 18C% Y)O,B % &,% % <L%
J/87AD8D% 1;2%;/0</63LO% 45B53DC% YCT% -% Y+9% D% X%
V2@5<% <L% D.J/8P0/;28D% J4/N42<<7% wC)% -
*F% ""F%
!9F%.% J/</[PU% E/@/4/?%;LAD.8D8D% E/RSSD\D53@L%
.@2@D.@DA5.ED%/J@D<28P3LO%.N826D;2U[DO%
@4DN/3/<5@4DA5.EDO% J/8D3/</;% <5@/1/<% 32D<53PBDO%
E;2142@/;F% 2% @2E65% 1DSS5453\D28P3L5% J/J42;ED% E%
J54D/12<% =4/<5% @/N/F% ML8D% %/J4515853L%;.5% J242<5@4LF%
35/MO/1D<L5% 18C% WM[5N/% =2@28/N2% H545<533LO% V;501%
-~CYF% Y% % % 9%.%.//@;5@.@;7U[D<D%
J/N45B3/.@C<D% H/.85% E82..DSDE2\DD% D% 7@/A353DC%
32DM/855%;263LO% J242<5@4/;F% <L% 0245ND.@4D4/;28D%
3/;//@E4L@L5%J545<533L5%0;501L%;%E2@28/N5%
%Y
%
Z%%YZ%-YO9%
l]hO!B3 $"!% % % 02@<5332C% 1;/?32C%
.D.@5<2%.% J/A@D%/1D32E/;L<D% <D3D<7<2<D%
HHIHXGnGXh±=
F%
HHIHINIGXh±=
% m2E.D<7<%
HHXHFGnGXx
±
=
F% J54D/1%
bHHHHHGpHpNnIIF
±
=
F% 32A28P32C% RJ/O2%
H
Hv FXppGQGIYGY HHHHQ
= ± %
k.J/8P0/;28.C% @4DN/3/<5@4DA5.ED?% J/8D3/<%.@2@D.@DA5.ED%
/J@D<28P3/?%.@5J53D%
N
=
% c20/;2C% E4D;2C% J/E20232% 32%
lD.% % H/<D</% RSS5E@2% R88DJ./D128P3/.@DF% R@2%.D.@5<2%
J/E20L;25@% 35M/8PB/?% RSS5E@%/@42653DC% G% E2@28/N5% YZ%
R@2%0;5012%J/87AD82%3/<54%v!&: !%%
l]hO!B3 $%!"$ % @2E65% 02@<5332C%
1;/?32C% 0;5012%.% 35/MLA3/% M/8PB/?% 2<J8D@71/?%
HQQ
A
=
F% HHnHIXXGpx
±
=
F%
HGGHFIGGNh±=
F% HGFHHnXGNh±=
%%
=4/<5%@/N/F%R@2%.D.@5<2%D<55@%1/.@2@/A3/%E/4/@ED?%J54D/1%
HFFIXXp HHHHHHG
= ±
% 135?F% R@/% 7E20L;25@% 32% @/F%
A@/%.D.@5<2%/A53P% @5.32C% >2A28P32C% RJ/O2%
H
Hv FXppGQGGYGI HHHHI
= ± % c20/;2C%
E4D;2C% J/E20232% 32% lD.% % G% E2@28/N5% YZ% 3/<54%
v#! : !%
`87MD3L%N82;3/N/%D%;@/4DA3/N/%<D3D<7</;%&&#%%D%
#% F%.//@;5@.@;533/% b@D%;58DAD3L% 1/.@2@/A3/%
;58DED%G;515<%;%42..</@453D5%J242<5@4%X%
(
)
(
)
G F
HX HX
G GH G GH
− Δ − Δ
= − + − %
.//@;5@.@;7U[D?%/@3/B53DU%.7<<L% 15SD\D@/;% J/@/E2%;%
N82;3/<% D%;@/4DA3/<% <D3D<7<2O% E% <2E.D<28P3/?% C4E/.@D%
.D.@5<L% b@/@% J242<5@4% 42;53% 51D3D\5%;% J451J/8/653DDF%
A@/%/M5%0;501L%.S54DA5.ED%.D<<5@4DA3LF%42;3LO%421D7./;%
D%/M2% 02@<53DC% C;8CU@.C% J/83L<D% -@/% 5.@P% 32E8/353D5%
/4MD@L% L"9% e8C%.S54DA5.EDO% 0;501% R@/@% J242<5@4%
7<53PBD@.C% -J4D% J4/ADO% 42;3LO% J242<5@42O9% 5.8D% L%
/@E8/3D@.C%/@%"F% D8D% 5.8D% 421D7.L% M717@% 4208DA3LF%
J/.E/8PE7% O/@C% ML%/13/% D0% 02@<53D?% M715@% A2.@DA3L<% G%
.87A25% 0;501L% YZ% v#! : !% J242<5@4%X&:"" #F% A@/% 35;/0</63/% 18C%.S54DA5.ED%
.D<<5@4DA3LO% 0;501% b@/% C;8C5@.C% 24N7<53@/<%;% J/8P07%
35/MO/1D</.@D% J4D3C@P%;/%;3D<23D5% R88DJ@DA3/.@P%
E/<J/353@% DF%;/0</63/F% RSS5E@%/@42653DC% T% R@/?%\58PU%
<L%.</158D4/;28D%;3502@<5337U% A2.@P% E4D;/?%
.D<<5@4DA5.ED<%;L42653D5<%
%
m-
φ
9C
Z
:C
1
+-
πφ
9:C
>
+-
πφ
9F%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
- 9%
%
N15% C
Z
%.//@;5@.@;75@%.45135<7% 032A53DU% M85.E2F% C
1
% %
J/872<J8D@712% RSS5E@2%/@42653DCF% 2% C
>
% % J/872<J8D@712%
RSS5E@2% R88DJ./D128P3/.@D% T@4/N/% N/;/4CF% 5.8D% RSS5E@%
/@42653DC%.42;3D<%18C%/M5DO%0;501F%@/%/3%;3/.D@%;E821%35%
@/8PE/%;%/4MD@28P37U% A2.@/@7F% 3/% D%;% 71;/5337U%
/4MD@28P37U%A2.@/@7%-+'%% ""F%T*+% "# 9%%
k..851/;23D5% @4DN/3/<5@4DA5.E/N/% J/8D3/<%
.@2@D.@DA5.ED%/J@D<28P3/?%.@5J53D% +&F% E/@/4L?%
D.J/8P0/;28.C%18C%/J4515853DC%J242<5@4/;F%J/E2028/F%A@/%
J/87BD4D32% 02@<53DC%./.@2;8C5@% % J54D/12%
.851/;2@58P3/F%;3502@<533L5%S20L% %%%D%%%"%G%
R@/@% D3@54;28% S20% J/J2125@% !% @/AED% D0%.7<<243LO% # %
=/RSSD\D53@L% ML8D%;LAD.853L%;% J4/N42<<5% (C%
-
*%%B$*%9%
%
C
Z
]%
C
1
#]%
C
>
%
%
V2<5@D<F% A@/% E/RSSD\D53@% C
>
% J4D<543/%;% % 420%
J45;/.O/1D@% C
1
F% C
1
% @2E65% C;8C5@.C%.@2@D.@DA5.ED%
032AD<L<% e8C% R@DO% E/RSSD\D53@/;% 45078P@D47U[2C%
.N826D;2U[2C% E4D;2C% D<55@% <2E.D<7<% 42;3L?%
!&F% N82;3L?% <D3D<7<% " "% D%;@/4DA3L?%
<D3D<7<% % GLAD.8CC% N87MD3L% <D3D<7</;% E2E%
4203/.@D% <5617%.N826D;2U[D<D% 032A53DC<D% D% 032A53DC<D%
18C% r;3502@<533/N/s% J/8D3/<2%;<5.@/% <2E.D<7</;F% <L%
26
Небосвод №10, 2010 J/87AD<%Δ
% %
Δ
!& % DF%
.//@;5@.@;533/F%
J242<5@4%X!":!!#%
b@2%;58DAD32%
032AD@58P3/% <53PB5%
51D3D\LF% D%./N82.75@.C%
.% @5/45@DA5.ED%
/6D125<L<% A2.@DA3L<%
02@<53D5<%
a2ED<%/M420/<F%<L%
02E8UAD8DF% A@/%.D.@5<2%
/M82125@%.D8P3L<%
RSS5E@/<%
R88DJ./D128P3/.@DF%
N/4201/% M/855%.82ML<%
RSS5E@/<%/@42653DCF% D%
J/% E42?35?% <545%/13/%
02@<53D5% C;8C5@.C%
A2.@DA3L<% m2853PE2C%
4203/.@P% <5617%
N87MD32<D% <D3D<7</;%
@DJDA32% 18C% 0;501% @DJ2%
%(%
%
l]hO!B3 $#!$ /M82125@% J/A@D%
.D37./D128P3/?%.D<<5@4DA3/?% E4D;/?F% J/R@/<7%.@5J53P%
.@2@D.@DA5.ED%/J@D<28P3/N/%@4DN/3/<5@4DA5.E/N/%J/8D3/<2%
G
=
% u% R@/?% 0;501L% <2853PE2C% 2<J8D@712% &#!%
% D% E/4/@ED?% J54D/1%
HHFHpnHGIx
±
=
% F%
HHFHNYYGIh
±
=
% F%
HGQHnFn HHHHHHp
= ±
135?%A@/%J/O/65%32%0;501L%
@DJ2% % Y+% % G% R@/<%.87A25% 32A28P32C% RJ/O2%%
H
HvFXppGQGYHpX HHHHQ
= ±
% c20/;2C% E4D;2C%
J/E20232%32%lD.%#%%
e47ND<%;/0</63L<%/MQC.353D5<% <28/?% 2<J8D@71L% D%
.D37./D128P3/?% S/4<L% E4D;/?% </65@% ML@P% 1;/?32C%
.D.@5<2% M50% 02@<53D?%.% <28L<% 7N8/<% 32E8/32%/4MD@L%
c20/;2C%E4D;2C%J4D;51532%32%lD.&%G%R@/<%.87A25%.@5J53P%
.@2@D.@DA5.ED%/J@D<28P3/N/% J/8D3/<2%
F
=
F% % J54D/1%
HINGQXn HHHHHGG
= ±
% 135?% -A@/%./;J2125@%.%
71;/533L<% J54D/1/<F% 7J/<C37@L<%;LB5F%;% J451582O%
J/N45B3/.@D9F% 32A28P32C% RJ/O2%
H
Hv FXppGQGNGXG HHHHn
= ± % % e8C% R@/?%
0;501L% <L%.3/;2% D.J/8P0/;28D% 742;353D5% - 9%
T//@;5@.@;7U[D5%E/RSSD\D53@L%%
7"p_.'-"'sROcBGHGHXYcHHFGpnN
7."!0&(."! ! !)(!"*
%
lD.%%c20/;2C%E4D;2C%Y)O,B % ", #%%
l208DA3L5%\;5@2%.//@;5@.@;7U@%4208DA3L<%3/A2<%
32M8U153D?%
C
Z
!!%
C
1
#"%
C
>
!#&%
%
W@3/B53DC% 032A53D?% E/RSSD\D53@/;% E%/\53E2<% DO%
J/N45B3/.@5?%./.@2;8CU@% #% D% !% 18C% C
1
% D% C
>
%
.//@;5@.@;533/% =4/<5% @/N/F% E/RSSD\D53@% C
1
N/4201/%
<53PB5% A5<% C
>
F% S/4<28P3/% DO%/M2% </63/%.AD@2@P%
.@2@D.@DA5.ED% 032AD<L<D% a2ED<%/M420/<F% 358P0C%
D.E8UA2@P%;/0</63/.@P% @/N/F% A@/%/MQ5E@% C;8C5@.C% @5.3/?%
1;/?3/?%.D.@5</?%.% M8D0ED<D% E/<J/353@2<D% D% </63/%
J4D;5.@D% 1/E202@58P.@;2% 328DADC% RSS5E@2%/@42653DC%
DD8D%/@E8/353DC%S/4<L%/@%R88DJ@DA3/?%-;%.87A25%M8D0/.@D%
E%02J/8353DU%J/8/.@D%l/B29%%%
%%
k0% AD.@/?% S/@/<5@4DD% 35;/0</63/%;LM42@P% <5617%
R@D<D% 1;7<C% E82..DSDE2\DC<D% e28P35?B2C% <3/N/\;5@32C%
S/@/<5@4DC%D8D%.J5E@428P3L?%2328D0%</N7@%42045BD@P%R@/@%
;/J4/.% G% E2@28/N5% YZ% 0;5012% J/87AD82% 3/<54%
v #: !%
%
WE/3A2@58P3L5%
45078P@2@L%
.;5153L%;% @2M8D\7%
F% N15% J4D;5153L%
E//41D32@LF%3/<542%
;% E2@28/N2O% Y)O,
B % D% YZF% D%;%
@2M8D\7%!F% N15%
J4D;5153L%;.5%
35/MO/1D<L5%
J242<5@4L%.%
.//@;5@.@;7U[D<D%
/BDME2<D%%
c2?8L%.%
/4DND328P3/?%
S/@/<5@4D5?% -Hv,
F% Cg%
9F% D%
51D32C% E24@2F% 32%
E/@/4/?%/@<5A53L%!%
3/;L5% J545<533L5F%
0;501L%.42;353DC% D%
TT% F% 1/.@7J3L% 32%
;5M,.2?@5%OXv%
%
%
%%
Небосвод №10, 2010 27 7"Y_.'-"'sROcBGHGHXQcHHFFXNF
&"-">"0"1..&--vsCT
%
7"Q_.'-"'sROcBGHGHXQcHHFFXNF
&"=..*!'" %
a2M8D\2%%H242<5@4L%/@E4L@LO%0;501%
%
%
a2M8D\2%!% =//41D32@L% D% E4/..,D153@DSDE2\DC%
3/;//@E4L@LO%0;501%
n
%
Y)O,B % g% +% YZ%
% Y)O,B %
#, "%
%
!#" %
: !!
%
YZ%
v!&:
!%
% Y)O,B %
", #%
#
%
! & %
: !#
%
YZ%
v#! :
!%
!% Y)O,B %
&,%
%
#"
%
: !
%
YZ%
v #:
!%
%
%
o,
b@2% 42M/@2% M20D475@.C% 32% 1233LOF%./M4233LO%;%
/M.54;2@/4DD%T+%(F%7J42;8C5</?%S/31/<%T+%(%
o;@/4%;L42625@% M82N/1243/.@P% l/37% G/12.ED% -1D45E@/4%
/M.54;2@/4DDD9% D% e/335% d4273,G/12.ED% -1D45E@/4% S/312%
T+%(9%
o;@/4% M82N/124D@% ES,<3% kN/42% =7105C% D% H2;/82%
e7M/;.E/N/% 02% N/.@5J4DD<.@;/% 32% E/3S5453\DD% O{OY,
"F%N15%R@D%45078P@2@L%ML8D%J451.@2;853L%;J54;L5%
a2E65% 2;@/4% M82N/12432% J4/S% k% % o314/3/;7% 02%
J/8503L5%02<5A23DC%D%E/<<53@24DD%
%
&+,
•% YOF%
*
%%
•% *%z{F% ""F%OP%"F%"F%
*+
OP#"'
%%
•% *%z{F% F%OP% F%F%
+,
'
OP %
•% *%z{F%!F%YPC%"F%!" F%
+,
'
!YPC"!" %%
•% ~
$%PF%F%
*
'
'
%
•% H%F%#F%
''*
++
*
%
•% *%P)F% ""F%
+,
'
""YY &!
%%
•% %F% ""F%C%B
%Y
%{%
C%|%HF% ""F%
""+$
%
%%•% {'
%vF%%TF% "F%vYF% F% %
*
"vY {
%%
•% (%F%#F%C,(+$%P
+%* F%
++++$
%
•% Y%))%%F% F%~
%C%'%
%Y
F%%
+
+*
%
•% T*+%%P%-9F% "# F%z
%
%
%%'%
%*%X+%
*
F%($*%)$F%!%%
"# +'T
%
•% gF% F%
*
,
'
*,
g
%
%
%%%%%%
n% T% P
F%% % %-
z
9
%
zz
% z%+F%Hv%
% X% "!! % "% "!% !!!% & !# #&%
% X% ! % !"% ! % " % & # !!%
!% YCT%
X%
&""%
! &" %
!"%
!&#%
!##%
!#"%
%
!#%
& #%&%
& %"%
1$$.9<@$)
30
<
*
+** '
%%
%
H7M8DE75@.C%.%8UM503/N/%42045B53DC%2;@/42%
%
28
Небосвод №10, 2010 8
@/[\H]>Z1Z
I.$ $MNOPNEp+
%
!% D% b>% -9F% % D% R3P,S7% -9% % D%`23P%`u>%
-`23P% eRF% =D@2?9% 2.@4/3/<L% D% 2.@4/8/ND%./.@2;D8D% J54;L?%
0;013L?%E2@28/N%-rTD3N,fD3Ns9%D0%&"%0;01% %./0;501D?%
D0;5.@3LO%;% =D@25% D% 18C% %/J45158D8D% RE8DJ@DA5.ED5%
E//41D32@L% G% 7N8/;LO% D0<5453DCO% D.J/8P0/;28D%
2.@4/3/<DA5.ED?%J/./O%D%@4DE;5@4%.%1D/J@42<D%H/%02JD.C<%
D% R3P% C;.@;75@F% A@/% 2.@4/8/NDC% J4/\;5@282%;% =D@25F%@2E%
E2E% J42;853D5% N/.7124C% D% <D3D.@4/;%.;C0L;28D%.%
1;D653D5<% 73L% o;@/4% 35.E/8PEDO%./AD353D?% J/%
2.@4/3/<DD%
%%%%=% R@/<7%;45<53D%/@3/.D@.C% 145;35ED@2?.E2C% E3DN2%
rW.3/;L%/J4515853DC%0;01s%jN/%D<535<%320;23%E42@54%32%
735%
%%%%=4/<5% @/N/F%`23P%`u>% J4DJD.L;2U@% J54;/5% 32M8U153D5%
JD@542% W3%/JD.28% R@7% J8235@7% E2E% C4E7U% D%.;5@C[7U.C%%
`23P% eR%/@<5A28F% A@/%;D158%/137% D0% 873% JD@542% -8DM/%
`23D<51F% 8DM/% =288D.@/9% 35;//476533L<% N820/<%;%!% 1/%
3RF% 021/8N/% 1/% @/N/F% E2E%`28D85/%`28D85?% J42013/;28% R@/%
/@E4L@D5%;% % N/17% G.5% A5@L45% 873L% @5O3DA5.ED%;D13LF%
3/%J42E@DA5.ED%/3D%/MLA3/%.J4C@23L%.DC3D5<%JD@542%
%%%%rT/%;45<53%23P%.451D%@5OF% E@/%ML8%D.E7.53%;%35M5.3LO%
J/1.A5@2O% x% D0;5.@3Ly% a23% e7%,J/% 0;5012<F% G23% /,% J/%
J242<% D% @7<232<F% GR?% TC3P%,J/% N2123DC<%/M% 74/625% G%
02E/32O% 1;D653DC% JC@D% J8235@F%;L;51533LO%`23Px,N73/<y% D%
D% xR35<yF%.AD@28/.PF% A@/% @/8PE/% J8235@2% k3,O/% -m24.9%
D<582% J/JC@3/5% 1;D653D5F% 3/% x<L% 0325<F% A@/y%/M42@3L5%
1;D653DC% D%/.@23/;ED% xJ4D.7[D% D% 147ND<% J8235@2<y% b@D%
/M42@3L5%1;D653DC%J8235@%D%A2.@DA3L5%D%J/83L5%J/E4L@DC%
J8235@% T/83\5<% D% 73/?% q%;.5%.876D8/% 18C% N2123D?s% D%
\0D%`82;2%#%%
q$% Hkcj% -HkajoTF% ¡¢£F%!&,! F% m2..28DC%
-m24.58P9F% e4`45\DC9% E7J5\F% </45J82;2@58PF% 2.@4/3/<F%
<2@5<2@DE% D% N5/N42S% m5617%!% D%!% 1/% 3% R%./;54BD8%
J82;23D5%;1/8P% A2.@D%.5;543LO% D% 02J213LO% M545N/;%
j;4/JL% H451J/8/6D@58P3/%/3%/M/N378%/.@4/;%
G58DE/M4D@23DC% D% ML8% J54;L<%;% D.@/4DDF% E@/%/JD.28%
J/8C43L?%153PF%J/8C43/5%.DC3D5%D%;5A3L5%8P1L%=%@/<7%65%
/3%/JD.28% D% 128% 320;23D5% N54<23.ED<% J85<532<F% 2%
d4D@23DC%.@28/%/M[57J/@45MD@58P3L<% 320;23D5<%/.@4/;2%
W@E4L8%/,;2% V58231DCF% G58DE/M4D@23DC% D% k48231DCF% J,/;2%
d45@23P% D% TE231D32;.ED?F% </4C% T5;543/5% D% k48231.E/5F%
J4/8% =2@@5N2@% D% dD.E2?.ED?% 028% H/%/JD.23DU%/3% 1/.@DN%
05<58PF% 32O/1C[DO.C% 32% %.B% >2M8U12C% M/8PBD5%
J4D8D;L% D%/@8D;L% 32% M545N2O% o@823@DA5.E/N/%/E5232F%
7.@232;8D;25@%.;C0P%R@DO%C;853D?%.%73/?%%
%%%%HD@52.%;LAD.8D8%32E8/3%J8/.E/.@D%RE8DJ@DED%E%J8/.E/.@D%
35M5.3/N/%RE;2@/42%%
%%%G%!N% 1/E2028F% A@/% 7N8/;2C%;L./@2% J/8U.2% <D42% 321%
N/4D0/3@/<%;.5N12% 42;32% N5/N42SDA5.E/?% BD4/@5% F% @2E% E2E%
ML8%7M5613F%A@/%V5<8C%B24//M42032%%%
%%r%`jlo=ke% H/3@D?.ED?% -!&#,! F% % e4%`45\DC9%
SD8/./S% D% 2.@4/3/<F% J45182N25@F% A@/% V5<8C% 1;D65@.C% K%
;42[2@58P3/F%;/E47N%.;/5?%/.DF%32J/1/MD5%E/85.2F%.%02J212%
32%;/.@/E%;/E47N%./M.@;533/N/%\53@42K% -R@/%/MQC.3C8/%
.7@/A3/5%;42[53D5% 35M5.3/?%.S54L9% k082N25@%.D.@5<7%
.@4/53DC% <D42F%./15462[7U% D15U% 145;3DO% 5NDJ@C3%/M%
/M42[53DD%;/E47N%T/83\2%m54E74DC%D%G5354L%J/% E47N/;L<%
/4MD@2<% G<5.@5%.% T/83\5<% R@D% J8235@L% 1;D67@.C%;/E47N%
V5<8D-.O5<2%.85;29%`542E8D1% J/82N28F% A@/% D% T/83\5F% D%
G53542F%D%V5<8C%;42[2U@.C%J/%/E4763/.@C<%;/E47N%51D3/N/%
\53@42F% J4DA<% J54D/1%/13/N/%/M/4/@2% V5<8D%./.@2;8C5@%
/1D3%N/1%%
%%%TAD@28F% A@/% 0;501L% J/% S/4<5% J/1/M3L% V5<85F% @% 5%
C;8CU@.C% B24//M4203L<D% 35M5.3L<D% @582<D% D% 65.@E/%
J4DE45J853L% E% 35M5.3/?%.S545% r=2612C% 0;5012%
J451.@2;8C5@%./M/?%<D4F%;E8UA2U[D?%05<8UF%;/017OF%RSD4%
xE/@/4L?%.2<%32O/1D@.Cy%;%M5.J45158P3/<%RSD45s%%%
%
%
%%%H/82N28% A@/%;5[5.@;/%./.@/D@% D0% A5@L4O%.@DOD?F% <5617%
E/@/4L<D% 15?.@;7U@% 1;5%.D8L% q% UM/;P% D% G42612% >/%
.2<D% R@D%.@DODD%/3% J/82N28%./.@/C[D<D% D0% <58PA2?BDO%
A2.@D\F% 2328/N/;% 15</E4D@/;.EDO% 2@/</;]% UM/;P%
.J/./M.@;75@%/MQ51D353DU% 2@/</;%/13/N/% D% @/N/% 65%
R85<53@2% a2ED<%/M420/<F%;%/@8DAD5%/@% e5</E4D@2%/3%
.AD@28F%A@/%<5617%2@/<2<D%15?.@;7U@%128P3/15?.@;7U[D5%
.D8L% e47ND<%/@8DAD5<%/@%;/00453D?% 2@/<D.@/;% C;8C5@.C%
@/F% A@/%`542E8D1%/@4D\28%.7[5.@;/;23D5% 2M./8U@3/?%
J7.@/@L%/3% J/82N28F% A@/% <D4% 02J/8353% @/3A2?BD<%
;5[5.@;/<%q%RSD4/<%%
%%%%l/1D8.C%;%`542E855% q% N45A5.E/?% E/8/3DD% 32% M545N7%
f43/N/% </4C% -H/3@29% -;% 32.@/C[55%;45<C% q% N% b45N8DF%
a74\DC9% H4DML;% J/01355%;% oSD3LF% ML8%.87B2@585<%
JDS2N/45?\5;F% H82@/32F% o4D.@/@58C% G%.;/<% 4/13/<%
N/4/15%`542E8D1% 7MD8% <5.@3/N/% @D4232F% ML8%;5.P<2%
RE.@42;2N23@3L<% A58/;5E/<F%.E8/33L<% E% <D.@DSDE2\DC<%
jN/%./AD353DC%ML8D%J/J78C43LF%3/%1/%32.%35%1/B8D%%%
!% G/03DE25@% 3/;2C%.@/8D\2% D<J54DD% N/4/1%
o85E.2314DCF%;L.@4/5332C% J/% 7E2023DU%!!N% o85E.23142%!%
m2E51/3.E/N/% - #!, !!!F% J42;%.%!!N% J/.85%
.<54@D%/@\2F% <2E51/3.E/N/%\24C% cD8DJJ2% FJ42;!",!!N9F%
.%!!N% 5N/% J/8E/;/15\% 2NF%.@2;BD?% H@/85<55<% % T/@54%
-\24P%!,&!9% 7J42;8C5@% jNDJ@/<F% E2E% D%/.@28P3L5%@4D% 5N/%
E47J35?BDO%;/532A28P3DE2F%;/0N82;D;BD5% 147ND5%\24.@;2%
D<J54DD% T% 42.J21/<% D<J54DDF% N/4/1%.@23/;D@.C%.@/8D\5?%
jNDJ5@.E/N/%\24.@;2% -;%!!&N% 1/% >b%`45\DC% ML82% 02;/;232%
<2E51/3\2<D% D% 5% </N7[5.@;/% E/3AD8/.P9F%;/0N82;8C5</N/%
1D32.@D5?%H@/85<55;%-!,!%1/%>b9%%
%%%G% O/15%.@4/D@58P.@;2% N/4/12% 765%;% !!N%;% o85E.2314DD%
;/03DE25@% BE/82% 2.@4/3/</;% D% J4D% J/11546E5% e5<5@4DC%
c28543.E/N/% J/% @DJ7% DE5C% o4D.@/@58C%;/03DE25@% J54;L?%
73D;54.D@5@%,% m7.5?/3% D% 032<53D@2C% MDM8D/@5E2% V15.P%
7N2.2U[2C% BE/82% o4D.@/@58C% D% N45A5.E2C% 327E2%;.JLO378D%
5[% 420% H@/85<5?% % J4D;85E25@%.U12% 87ABDO% 7A53LO% D%
J/R@/;F%2%N/4/1%J45;42[25@.C%;%E47J35?BD?%;%<D45%
%%%%G% m7.5?/35F%./51D3533/<%.% 1;/4\/<% H@/85<5CF% ML8D%
028L% 18C% 023C@D?F% M/@23DA5.ED?% D% 0//8/NDA5.ED?%.21LF%
2.@4/3/<DA5.ED?% E2MD35@F% 2.@4/3/<DA5.E2C% M2B3CF%
E/<32@L% 18C% 751D333/?% 42M/@L% D% 18C% 6D03D% 7A3LOF%
232@/<DA5.ED?% @52@4% D% 147ND5%.876ML% 18C% J4/;5153DC%
RE.J54D<53@28P3LO% 42M/@% o.@4/3/<L% J4/;/1D8D% @/A3L5%
32M8U153DCF% E/3.@47D4/;28D% 4208DA3L5% J4DM/4LF%;% @/<%
AD.85%D%18C%D0<5453DC%42..@/C3DC%1/%T/83\2%D%73L%%
%%%%T451D% J4DN82B33LO% ML8% D% 032<53D@L?% <2@5<2@DE%
j;E8D1F%/.3/;2;BD?%;% o85E.2314DD% 032<53D@7U%
<2@5<2@DA5.E7U% BE/87% D% 32JD.2;BD?% 18C% 5% 7A53DE/;%
S7312<53@28P3L?% @471% r>2A282s% -!N9%;% !% E3DN2O% -32%
/.3/;23DD% % 2E.D/<% D% % J/.@782@/;F% J4D3D<25<LO% M50%
1/E202@58P.@;2F%;J54;L5%.@4/D@%;.U%.D.@5<7% N5/<5@4DDF%
32AD32C%.%/J4515853DC% J/3C@D?% @/AE2F% 8D3DCF% J8/.E/.@PF%
SDN742%D%@19%uA5M3DE%ML8%32.@/8P3/?%E3DN/?%<2@5<2@DE/;%
;%@5A53D5%%85@F%2%32%J4/@C653DD%%85@%J7M8DE/;28.C%
% 420% j;E8D1F%;% 42M/@2O% rWJ@DE2s% D% r=2@/J@4DE2sF%
Небосвод №10, 2010 29 42..<2@4D;25@% J4C</8D35?3/5% 42.J4/.@42353D5%.;5@2% D%
/@E4L8% 02E/3%/@42653DC%.;5@2F% @/% 5.@P% D082N25@% 02E/3L%
N5/<5@4DA5.E/?%/J@DED% G% m7.5?/35% 42M/@28% D% 032<53D@L?%
2.@4/3/<%o4D.@24OF%7@;54612;BD?F%A@/%\53@4/<%G.58533/?%
C;8C5@.C%T/83\5F%2%35%V5<8C%
%%%%>/% N82;3/5% 1/.@/D3.@;/% m7.5?/32F% 032<53D@2C%
o85E.2314D?.E2C% MDM8D/@5E2F%;% E/@/47U% H@/85<5?% %
cD82158PS%./MD428%./%;.5O% E/3\/;%/4DND328L% E3DN% D% E% &N%
1/% 3% R%;% 35?% 32.AD@L;28/.P%#@L.% 47E/JD.5?%
-J2JD47.3LO%D%J54N2<53@3LO%.;D@E/;F%J82.@D3/E%D0%1545;2%D%
E/.@DF% J28P</;LO% 8D.@/;%,% 32% N45A5.E/<F% 5NDJ5@.E/<F%
82@D3.E/<F% D31D?.E/<% D% 02ML@LO%.@24LO% JD.P<532O9%
dDM8D/@5E2% J54;L?% 420% J/.@421282%;% &N% J4D%/.215%
o85E.2314DD% % t50245<% D%/E/3A2@58P3/% J/NDM82%;%!" NF%
E2E%D%m7.5?/3F%;/%;45<C%J/N4/</;%O4D.@D23,S232@DE/;%
%%%%e/% N%1/%>b%jNDJ5@%;O/1D8%;%./.@2;%`45\DDF%2%.%#N%1/%
>b% lD<.E/?% D<J54DDF%/E/3A2@58P3/% 02;/;23% 4D<8C32<D%;%
!N%1/%>b%%
%%%H4D%7A2.@DD%<3/NDO%/MD@2@585?%m7.5?/32%32%/.@4%c24/.%
7%;O/12%;% N2;23P% 24OD@5E@/4/<% T/.@42@/<% =4D@.ED<%
;/01;DN37@%;% &N% 1/% >b% o85E.2314D?.ED?% -c24/..D?9% <2CE%
-/1D3%D0%#%A715.%.;5@29,%@4OQC47.32C%M2B3C,E/8/.%;L./@/?%
&% <% J4D%\245% H@/85<55% zz% cD82158PS5% m2CE% A2.@DA3/%
ML8% 42047B53%;% % N% >b% D% J/83/.@PU% 05<85@4C.53D5<%
!#N% G% 32.@/C[55%;45<C%/.@28.C% @/8PE/%\/E/8P% <2CE2%
J/83/.@PU%;.@4/533L?%;%.45135;5E/;7U% E45J/.@P% T5?A2.%
M202%5NDJ5@.E/N/%S8/@2%
! W@% %/E@CM4C%;51@.C%;% @5A53D5% M/855% % 85@%;%
G2;D8/3DDF% TD4DD% D% H285.@D35% 85@/D.AD.853D5% % rb42%
T585;ED1/;s%.;C0233L5%.% D<535<%/.3/;2@58C%\24.E/?%
1D32.@DD%;% TD4DDF%/13/N/% D0% J/8E/;/1\5;% o% m2E51/3.E/N/%
T585;E2% >DE2@/42% -J4! ,& F% E47J35?B2C% @544D@/4DC%
ML;B5?% D<J54DDF%;E8UA2;B2C% TD4DUF% H54.DU% D%
m5./J/@2<DU9%%%
%
%
W132E/% rR42% T585;ED1/;s%;J8/@P% 1/% J/0135?% 23@DA3/.@D%
/.@2;282.P% 21<D3D.@42@D;3/?% D% 35% 7J/@45M8C82.P%
D.@/4DE2<D% GJ/.851.@;DD%/32%;/B82%;% 242<5?.E7UF% 02@5<%
242M.E7U% D.@/4D/N42SDU% -J/1% 35;543L<% 32D<53/;23D5<%
rR4L% o85E.23142s9% D% 7J/@45M8C82.P%.D4D?.ED<D%
O4D.@D232<D%;J8/@P% 1/% ZzZ%;5E2% G% & % 1/% 3% R% 7MD@%
H@/85<55<%%%
8^8<%
H4/@/,R82<D@L%-!q#%1/%3%R9%%
e6D4/S@%-!q%1/%3%R9%%
b82<%-#q!"%1/%3%R9%%
m2332%- q#%1/%3%R9%%
mD1DC%-#&q%1/%3%R9%%
oO5<53D1L%-&q!!%1/%3%R9%%
T585;ED1L%-!!q %1/%3%R9%%
o4B2ED1L%-%1/%3%R%q%%3%R9%%
T2.23D1L%-q9%%
k.82<.E/5%02;/5;23D5%-!#q 9%%
%%% T58P167ED%- !#q "9%%
`74D1L%- "q 9%%
/450<B2OD%- ##q ! 9%%
782N7D1L%- q !!9%%
m702SS24D1L%- ! q !"!9%%
f/M23D1L%- !!#q !#9%%
T54M5124L%- !!#q !& 9%%
e6282D4D1L%- !#q !9%%
a74E/<23L%=242,=/U387%- #q &9%%
a74E/<23L%oE,=/U387%- !#&q &9%
W<5?C1L%- q#9%%
oMM2.D1L%-#q &9%%
a2OD4D1L%-& q&#!9%%
o82;D1L%-&q"&9%%
T2SS24D1L%-& q !9%%
T2<23D1L%-&#q"""9%%
VDC4D1L%-"&q !9%%
d7D1L%-"!q 9%%
`2035;D1L%-"!q &#9%% T5S5;D1L%- q # #!9%%
/@2ED%- #q #"9%%
oSB24D1L%- #!q &9%%
V531L%- #q #"9%%
=21624L%- #& q "9%%
H5O85;D%- "q "#"9%%
k.82<.E2C%45;/8U\DC%;%k4235%- "#"9%%
G45<533/5%J42;D@58P.@;/%- "#"9%%
k.82<.E2C%45.J7M8DE2%k423%-.% "&9%%%
=542;3/<% jN/% J/@/<ED% T585;ED1L% J42;D8D% TD4D5?% 1/%
02;/5;23DC%.@423L%4D<8C32<D%%1/%3%R%%
H54.D1.E2C%D<J54DC%%q%H54.D1.ED5%\24D%
H4/@/,R82<D@L%-!q#%1/%3%R9%%
e6D4/S@%-!q%1/%3%R9%%
b82<%-#q!"%1/%3%R9%%
m2332%- q#%1/%3%R9%%
mD1DC%-#&q%1/%3%R9%%
oO5<53D1L%-&q!!%1/%3%R9%%
T585;ED1L%-!!q %1/%3%R9%%
o4B2ED1L%-%1/%3%R%q%%3%R9%%
T2.23D1L%-q9%%
k.82<.E/5%02;/5;23D5%-!#q 9%%
%%% T58P167ED%- !#q "9%%
`74D1L%- "q 9%%
/450<B2OD%- ##q ! 9%%
782N7D1L%- q !!9%%
m702SS24D1L%- ! q !"!9%%
f/M23D1L%- !!#q !#9%%
T54M5124L%- !!#q !& 9%%
e6282D4D1L%- !#q !9%%
a74E/<23L%=242,=/U387%- #q &9%%
a74E/<23L%oE,=/U387%- !#&q &9%
W<5?C1L%- q#9%%
oMM2.D1L%-#q &9%%
a2OD4D1L%-& q&#!9%%
o82;D1L%-&q"&9%%
T2SS24D1L%-& q !9%%
T2<23D1L%-&#q"""9%%
VDC4D1L%-"&q !9%%
d7D1L%-"!q 9%%
`2035;D1L%-"!q &#9%% T5S5;D1L%- q # #!9%%
/@2ED%- #q #"9%%
oSB24D1L%- #!q &9%%
V531L%- #q #"9%%
=21624L%- #& q "9%%
H5O85;D%- "q "#"9%%
k.82<.E2C%45;/8U\DC%;%k4235%- "#"9%%
G45<533/5%J42;D@58P.@;/%- "#"9%%
k.82<.E2C%45.J7M8DE2%k423%-.% "&9%%%
! % bHk=ul% T2</..ED?% -¤¥¦§¨©¨£F%! ,#% F%/.@4%
T2</.F% e4`45\DD% 9% SD8/./SF% J4/1/862@58P% 7A53DC%
5;EDJJ% D% e5</E4D@2F%/.3/;28%;% oSD32O% SD8/./S.E7U%
BE/87% r=5J/.s,rT21s% l20158C8%.;/5% 7A53D5% 32% @4D% A2.@D%
@5/4DC%J/0323DC%-rE23/3DE2s9F%7A53D5%/%J4D4/15%-rSD0DE2s9%
D%R@DE2%
%%%%TAD@28F% A@/% <D4%./.@/D@% D0% M5.E/35A3/N/% <3/65.@;2%
2@/</;F% 1;D67[DO.C% 35J454L;3/% D%;5A3/%;% M5.E/35A3/?%
J7.@/@5% -1;D653D5%/@%.@/8E3/;53DC%;M/E% D8D%;3D0F%;;54O%
-J/1% 15?.@;D5<%.D8L% @C65.@D9% D%.2</J4/D0;/8P3/5%
/@E8/353D5%/@% 1;D653DC%;3D09% mD4%;5A53% D% 35D0<5353%
TAD@28F% A@/% 2@/<L% D<5U@% 4203L?%;5.F% S/4<7% D%;58DAD37F%
/1D32E/;7U%.E/4/.@P% J4D% J4C</8D35?3/<% 1;D653DD% 1/%
.@/8E3/;53DC%;% J7.@/@5F% 2% O242E@54% DO% 1;D653DC%
/M7.8/;853/%;37@4533D<D%J4DAD32<D%-D.@/A3DE/<%R354NDD9%
rT;/?.@;/% 2@/</;% %;5.F% 1;D653D5% ªs% % e;D653D5% 2@/</;%
J4D;/1D@% E%/M420/;23DU% <D4/;F% V5<8D% W@% V5<8D% 02@5<%
/@158D8/.P% 35M/F%.@28/%/@O/1D@P% </45F%/M/./MD;BD.P%
;/13L<% J4/.@423.@;/<% D%;L158C@P.C%/N3D%.@28D%;% AD.@/<%
RSD45% V5<8C% J/4/1D82% 6D03PF% 2%;.% @/F% A@/% 35% ML8/%
30
Небосвод №10, 2010 J4D.J/./M853/% E% 6D03DF% 7<D428/% a/% 5.@P%/MQC.3C5@%
02E/3/<543/.@D%;/03DE3/;53DC% G.58533/?% D.O/1C% D0%
2@/<D.@DA5.E/?% @5/4DD% G% 35?% 35@% <5.@2% d/N7% 3D%;%
./@;/453DDF% 3D%;% 5% 420;D@DC% H4/;/0N82B2C%
35/MO/1D</.@P% J/0323D5%.7[3/.@D% <D42F% JL@28.C%
/MQC.3D@P% 35E/@/4L5% SD0DA5.ED5% C;853DC% -</83DDF%
02@<53D5% T/83\2% D% 149% 5.@5.@;533L<D% J4DAD32<D% b@2%
@5/4DC%;% <28/D0<5333/<%;D15% 1/B82% 1/% RJ/OD%
5;4/J5?.E/N/%;/04/6153DC% jN/% J4D0L;/<% ML82% S4202%
rH4/6D;D%3502<5@3/s%-D;D%751D3533/9%%
%
%
%%%%u@;546128F% A@/%.% J/;54O3/.@D% J451<5@/;% 35J454L;3/%;/%
;.5%.@/4/3L%/@85@2U@%rJ4D042EDs%-R?1/82@D9F%./O423CU[D5%
/M8DE% R@DO% J451<5@/;F% D% J/J212C%;% N8202F%;/0M7612U@%
A7;.@;/% 0453DCF% 12;2C% @5<%.2<D<% @/A3/5% J451.@2;853D5%/%
J451<5@5%
%%%%>2J2128% 32% 458DNDUF% 1/E20L;2C% <2@54D28P3/.@P% D%
.<54@3/.@P% 17BDF% D%/@4D\28%;<5B2@58P.@;/% M/65.@;533LO%
.D8%;% 6D03P% J4D4/1L% D% A58/;5E2% H/R@/<7%;% 128P35?B5<%
.8/;/%rRJDE74D5\s%.@28/%.D<;/8/<%M50M/6DC%
%%%%bJDE74%;L4/.% 32%/.@4/;5% T2</.% D%.% % 85@% 32A28%
D3@545./;2@P.C%SD8/./SD5?%G% &%85@%/3%J4D5O28%;%oSD3L%
=/N12% D0N328D% 2SD3C3%.% T2</.2F% bJDE74% 32J42;D8.C% E%
.;/5<7%/@\7%;% =/8/S/3% -N/4/1%;% k/3DDF% m282C% o0DC9F% N15%
J4/6D8% 35E/@/4/5%;45<C% D%./M428%;/E47N%.5MC% 7A53DE/;% G%
;/042.@5%!% 85@%/3%/.3/;28%.;/U% SD8/./S.E7U% BE/87F%
E/@/42C%J54;/32A28P3/%32O/1D82.P%;%mD@D8535%-32%/.@4/;5%
5.M/.9% D% 2<J.2E5% -32% 20D2@.E/<% M545N7% J4/8D;2%
e24123588L9F%2%.%!%N%1/%3%R%q%;%oSD32O%G%R@/<%N/4/15%
bJDE74%./%.;/D<D% 7A53DE2<D% J/.58D8.C%;% E7J8533/<% D<%
.217% -/@.U12% 32D<53/;23D5% RJDE745?\5;% rSD8/./SL%
T212s9% >21%;O/1/<%;D.58/% D045A53D5% r`/.@PF% @5M5% 015.P%
M715@% O/4/B/% V15.P% 71/;/8P.@;D5% q%;L.B55% M82N/s%
>2JD.28%/E/8/%!% J4/D0;5153D?F% 3/%./O423D8D.P% @/8PE/%
S42N<53@L%%
!% H54;2C% 02JD.P%/% 32M8U153DD%;% =D@25%./835A3LO%
JC@53% V2% J/.8517U[D5%"N% 5.@P% 5[% % 02JD.5?%/%
32M8U153DD% JC@53% a2E%;% &N% 1/% >b% 5.@P% 02JD.P%/%
32M8U153DD% JC@53% 23P.ED<D% 2.@4/3/<2<D%;% E3DN5%
1D32.@DD% 23P% -% N% 1/% >b,N% >b9F% 7J/4C1/A532%
JD.P<533/.@P% D0% % N47JJ% D54/N8DS/;% rWA54@23DC%
;.5853.E/N/% 054E282s% V15.P% 65% 5.@P% 02JD.D% 32M8U153DD%
E/<5@L%`2885C%;%2;N7.@5%%.53@CM45%&#N%%1/%>b%%
%
%
%%%%G% =D@25F% E/@/4L?%;% N% 1/% >b%;J54;L5%/MQ51D3C5@.C%
J7@5<% 02;/5;2@58P3LO%;/D3% k3% f6R3% -D% 723,1D% J42;%.%
, F% J54;L?% D<J542@/4%.% !% 85@F%.% N% J54;L?%
;.5ED@2?.ED?% D<J542@/4F% J42;D@% 51D3L<% =D@25<9% 1D32.@DC%
tD3P% - ,#9F% E/@/4L?%.% N% 32AD325@%.@4/D@58P.@;/%
;58DE/?% =D@2?.E/?%.@53L% W3%;;58%;%.@4235% 51D3/5%
02E/3/12@58P.@;/F% 51D37U% 1535637U%.D.@5<7F% 51D37U%
JD.P<533/.@PF%3/%73DA@/6D8%;.5%E3DNDF%J4/@D;/45A2[D5%5N/%
D15C<% W3%;;58% 51D37U% 18D37% @58563LO%/.5?F% A@/%
./M8U125@.C% 1/%.DO% J/4% k<J54DC% 42.J282.P% J/.85% 5N/%
.<54@D%
%%%%T@4/D@58P.@;/%;58/.P%;/532A28P3DE/<% mR3% aR32%.%
!%42M/ADOF%;/0;51C%02% %85@%.;C07U[55%0;53/%.@53L%
18D3/?%;% &E<% D% J/J42;D8% D<5U[D5% 7A2.@ED% WM[2C%
J4/@C6533/.@P%.@53L% 1/.@DN25@% E<% -51D3.@;533L?% 32%
V5<85%/MQ5E@F%;D1D<L?% D0% E/.</.29% WE/3A53/%
.@4/D@58P.@;/%;% N% 1/% >b% u%.2</?% 02J213/?% N423D\L%
;/0;51532% E45J/.@P%;% !#N% D%;% ,/<%;5E5%.7[5.@;533/%
.@532% J545.@4/532%;% J54D/1% 1D32.@DD% mD3% T% J4DO/1/<% E%
;82.@D%;% N% <23PA674/;F% N423D\L% N/.7124.@;2%.@28D%
J4/.@D82@P.C% E%.5;547%/@%.@53L% D%/32% 7@42@D82%.;/5%
032A53D5%
%%%%G% @/% 65%;45<C%/%./835A3LO% JC@32O%.//M[25@% r/@5\%
M/@23DEDs% a28P<23% ajWcloTa% -c5/S42.@9F% 7A53DE%
H82@/32%D%o4D.@/@58C%%
q%% =kek>>% -!,#F% TDJJ242F% G2;D8/39%
;LAD.8C5@%;5.P<2% M8D0E/% E% D.@D33/<7% J4/1/86D@58P3/.@P%
N/12F% 7.@23/;D;% J4/1/86D@58P3/.@P% 8733/N/% <5.C\2% % "%
135?F% % A2./;F% % <D37@L% D%!F!%.5E731L% -./;45<533/5%
032A53D5%./.@2;8C5@% "% 135?F% % A2./;F% % <D37@L% D% F&#%
.5E731L9%T/.@2;8C5@%@2M8D\L%;D1D</N/%1;D653DC%J8235@%D%
73L%
%%%WE/8/%! N% 1/% 3R%/3%/.3/;28% 2.@4/8/NDA5.E7U% BE/87%;%
G2;D8/35F% E/@/42C% J4/1/86282%.7[5.@;/;2@P% 1265% 1;2%
.@/85@DC%.J7.@C% G% R@/?% BE/85% ML8% J4/15823% JD/354.ED?%
/JL@% J45J/12;23DC%;2;D8/3.E/?% 2.@4/8/NDD% N45A5.ED<%
.@7153@2<% -M/8PB/5% E/8DA5.@;/% N45E/;% J/C;D8/.P%;%
m5./J/@2<DD%;% N/1L% J/.85% 5% 02;/5;23DC% o85E.2314/<%
m2E51/3.ED<9%
%%%%=2E%.@/85@D5<% 423PB5% j;E@5</3F% J4518/6D8%.D.@5<7%
@4/JDA5.E/N/% V/1D2E2]%/132E/F%;%/@8DAD5%/@% N45A5.E/N/%
7A3/N/F%/3% 42.J/8/6D8% @/AED% 42;3/153.@;D?% D%
./83\5.@/C3D?%;%;/.P</<%N4217.5%E241D328P3LO%032E/;%
%%%%W3%/13D<% D0% J54;LO% D.J/8P0/;28% 0/1D2E28P3L?% E47NF%
J/15833L?%32%!%
%%%%T/N82.3/% H8D3DU% T@24B5<7F% =D1D33%/@E4L8F% A@/%
m54E74D?% 3DE/N12% 35% 7128C5@.C%/@% T/83\2% M/855F% A5<% 32%
!%
%%%%k07A28%8733L5%\DE8L%D%/@E4L8%;263L?%18C%/J4515853DC%
;45<53D% % 02@<53D?% J54D/1F%;% E/@/4/<% %.D3/1DA5.ED?%
<5.C\%.//@3/.D@.C%.% "% 23/<28D.@DA5.ED<D% <5.C\2<D%
b@/@% J54D/1% ML8% 02@5<% 02D<.@;/;23%`DJJ24O/<% % G% A5.@P%
5N/%320;23%8733L?%E42@54%%%
!" olkTak% D% akmWolkT% -,!;% 1/% >bF% jNDJ5@F%
o85E.2314DC9% 32A2;%;% "N%;J54;L5%.D.@5<2@DA5.E/5%
32M8U153D5% 0;5013/N/% 35M2F%./.@2;8CU@% J54;L?%;% j;4/J5%
0;5013L?% E2@28/N% -.JD./E9%/@3/.D@58P3/% J/.@/C33LO% @/A5E%
35M/.;/12% -;J54;L5%/J4515853L% E//41D32@L% 0;5019% G%
E2A5.@;5%/13/?% D0% E//41D32@% 7E20L;282.P% RE8DJ@DA5.E2C%
BD4/@2F% 147N2C%,% RE8DJ@DA5.E2C% 1/8N/@2F%/@.AD@L;2;B2C.C%
/@%C4EDO%0;01%GJ54;L5F%E2E%D%;%e45;35<%lD<5F%3235.8D%32%
E24@7% 0;5013/N/% 35M2% J7@P% T/83\2% D% 02J5A2@858D% </<53@L%
J545.5A53DC%35M5.3/N/%RE;2@/42%;%./0;501DCO%W;32%D%G5.L%
H4D% D0<5453DD% E//41D32@% o4D.@D88% D% aD</O24D.%
D.J/8P0/;28D%E47NDF%420158533L5%32%;2;D8/3.ED?%<2354%32%
%A2.@5?%,%%N4217./;%
%%%%l2042M/@28D% 7A53D5%/%.S54DE5% -35M5.3/?%.S5459%
H4/D0;58D% D0<5453DC% J/8/653DC% T/83\2F% 73L% D% 147NDO%
J8235@% k0/M458D%./835A3L5% A2.L% D% 7J/4C1/AD8D%
E2853124P% kO% 32M8U153DC% D.J/8P0/;28D.P%`DJJ24O/<% D%%
H@/85<55<%
%%%G%A5.@P%DO%320;23L%8733L5%E42@54L%o4D.@D88F%aD</O24D.%
aD</O24D.7%J4DJD.L;2U@%J54;/5%7J/<D323D5%/%m54E74DDF%2%
@2E65%/M3247653D5F% A@/%;.5% 1/8N/@L% 0;01% 7;58DAD;2U@.C%
J4D<543/% -J/% 5N/%/\53E59% 32% % E261L5% % 85@%
-J451;2453D5%42;3/153.@;DC%,%J45\5..DC9%%
! olkTaol%T2</..ED?%-! ,!F%/.@4%T2</.F%o85E.2314DCF%
jNDJ5@9%2.@4/3/<F%;L1;D378%D15U%/%1;D653DD%V5<8D%;/E47N%
35J/1;D63/N/% T/83\2F% 32O/1C[5N/.C%;%\53@45% <D4/0123DC%
Небосвод №10, 2010 31 D% 1;D653D5% V5<8D%;/E47N%/.DF%.1582;% 7J4/[33L5%
J451J/8/653DC%
%%,V5<8C%;42[25@.C% D% R@D<%;42[53D5<%/MQC.3C5@.C%
1;D653D5%0;01%-J4DAD32%.7@/A3/N/%;42[53DC%35M29]%
%%,V5<8C%1;D65@.C%;/E47N%T/83\2F%./;54B2C%J/83L?%/M/4/@%
;% @5A53DD% N/12F% @2E% E2E%/32% <53PB5% T/83\2% o328/NDA3L<%
/M420/<%1;D67@.C%D%147ND5%J8235@L%%
%%%%G% 42M/@5% rW%;58DAD32O% D%
42..@/C3DCO% T/83\2% D% 73Ls% JD.28%
rE/N12% 732% C;8C5@.C% 32<%
42..5A533/?% J/J/82<F% @/% 55%
42..@/C3D5% <53PB5% A5@;54@D%
/E4763/.@D% M50% @4D1\2@/?% A2.@D% R@/?%
A5@;54@Ds% DF%/\53D;% 42..@/C3D5% 1/%
73L%-32?1CF%A@/%1D2<5@4%@53D%V5<8DF%
J212U[D?% 32% 737%;% F% 4202% M/8PB5%
1D2<5@42% 73L% D% D0,02% E/37.2% @53P%
.7625@.C%32%\58L?%8733L?%1D2<5@49%;%
F&%421D7.2%V5<8D%WJ45158C5@%42..@/C3DC%1/%T/83\2%-J/%
S205%73L%;% %A5@;54@D%D0%J4C</7N/8P3/N/%@457N/8P3DE2F%@%
5%;J54;L5% D.J/8P075@% M20D.3L?% <5@/1% VTV+%
&#« "¬V9% l21D7.% 73L%/J45158D8%;%# "% 421D7.2% V5<8DF%
2% T/83\2%;% F!% 421D7./;% V5<8D% -32%.2</<% 1585%;% "% 4209%
>2%.2</<% 1585% 7N/8% 35% &#% 2% &"% D% J/R@/<7% T/83\5%
128PB5% 73L%;% % 420% H4518/6533L5% 42..@/C3DC%
D.J/8P0/;28D.P%<3/ND5%.@/85@DC%2.@4/3/<2<D%
%%%%k.O/1C%D0%@/N/F%A@/%T/83\5%J/%5N/%J/1.A5@2<%M/855%A5<%;%
!% 420% J45;/.O/1D@% J/%/MQ5<7% V5<8UF%./012@% J54;7U%
N58D/\53@4DA5.E7U%.D.@5<7%.@4/53DC% <D42%.S54DA5.E2C% D%
J8235@L% 1;D67@.C%;/E47N% T/83\2% J/% E47N/;L<%/4MD@2<%
-<28/5%;/E47N% M/8PB/N/9%.5<P%.S54% 732F% m54E74D?F%
G53542F% m24.F% JD@54F% T2@743% D% 0;01L,;.% 1;D65@.C%
;/E47N% T/83\2F% E2E% D% V5<8C% rG.C%/4MD@2% V5<8D% J/%
.42;353DU%./%.S54/?% 0;501% 35%M/855% A5<% @/AE2s% H8235@L%
128PB5% 73LF% 2% 0;501LF% E/@/4L5% 35J/1;D63L% D% </N7@%
42.J/82N2@P.C%32%35.E/8PEDO%.S542OF%5[5%128PB5%TD.@5<2%
J4/@D;/45AD82% @421D\DC<% D% 35% D<582% 1/E202@58P3LO%
S2E@/4/;% D% <2@5<2@DA5.E/?% 42042M/@EDF% @2E% 5[%
o4D.@/@58P% 02<5@D8F% A@/% 5.8D% ML% V5<8C% 1;DN282.PF% @/% R@/%
;L0;28/% ML% E267[55.C% J545<5[53D5% 0;01% >/% D<533/%
.D8P32C% 7128533/.@P% 0;501% J/% o4D.@24O7% 35% J/0;/8C82%
32M8U12@P%J242882E./;%
%%%%WJ45158D8% 032A53D5% 18D3L%.D3/1DA5.E/N/% <5.C\2% "%
135?%! K&KKKF% %/% A5<%;.@45A25@.C% 02JD.P%;%
;2;D8/3.EDO%@2M8D\2O%
%%%%H45J/12;28%;% m7.5?/35% D%;8%./M.@;533/5% 32M8U153D5%
T/0128%./835A3L5%A2.L%;%;D15%A2BD%-J/87B24DC9%WM;D33%
02%.;/D%;0N8C1L%;% M50M/6DDF%;L376153% M562@P% D0% oSD3% G%
32BD%13D%5N/%320L;2U@%r=/J543DE/<%23@DA3/N/%<D42s%%
%
!$% oloa% D0% T/8% % -# % q% !F% N% T/8LF% =D8DEDC9F%
145;35N45A5.ED?% J/R@% JDB5@% 51D3.@;533/5% J/83/.@PU%
./O423D;B55.C% J4/D0;5153D5% q% % 1D12E@DA5.E2C% J/R<2%
r;853DCs%-82@%P%%
+]%;%47.%J545;/15%
q%;% E3% >5M/F% 327E2F% J/R0DC% mF% ""9% T@4/ED% ,##%
J451.@2;8CU@%./M/?%.@DO/@;/43/5% J5458/653D5% @4712% J/%
2.@4/3/<DD% j;1/E.2% =3D1.E/N/% D%/JD.L;2U@% 4D.73ED% D%
J/8/653D5%./0;501D?F% E/3SDN742\DU% N82;3LO% 0;501F%
;J/.851.@;DD% 85NBD5%;%/.3/;7%;.5O% 5;4/J5?.EDO% E24@%
0;5013/N/%35M2%%
G% @5E.@5% J/R<L% 32.AD@L;25@.C% %./0;501D?F% 3/% AD.8/% R@/%
J4D<543/5%,% @4713/%.E202@PF% E2ED5% D0% R@DO%./0;501D?%
.AD@28D.P%.2</.@/C@58P3L<DF% 2% E2ED5% 7J/<D32U@.C% J4/.@/%
E2E% A2.@P% 147NDO% e2%;D1D</F%;% @5%;45<532% R@/% D% 35% ML8/%
/./M533/%;263/% H4D<54% @2EDO%./0;501D?%.% 35J/3C@3L<%
.@2@7./<%,% G/12F%.@47C[2C.C% D0%./.712% G/1/85CF% 7E%
T@458P\2%
%%%%T@4/ED%#&, F%;/0</63/F% D082N2U@% J4/D0;5153D5%
a5/S42.@2% rW% J4D<5@2Os% D% J/.;C[53L%/JD.23DU% J4D<5@%
J/N/1L%
%%%%H/R<2% o42@2% J/8P0/;282.P% M/8PB/?% J/J78C43/.@PUF% E%
35?% ML8D%./.@2;853L% <3/N/AD.8533L5% E/<<53@24DDF%
32DM/855% 032AD@58P3L?% D0% E/@/4LOF% J4D3218562[D?%
`DJJ24O7F% 1/B58% 1/% 32BDO% 135?% >2% 82@D3.ED?% C0LE%
r;853DCs%J545;/1D8D%tD\54/3F%t5024P%`54<23DE%D%o;D53]%
1;2% J/.8513DO%;24D23@2%./O423D8D.P% J/83/.@PUF%
J5458/653D5% tD\54/32% q%;/% S42N<53@2O% W1D3%.@DO% D0%
;.@7JD@58P3/N/%/M42[53DC% E% V5;.7%.@28%/./M533/%
032<53D@L<F% @2E% E2E% 5N/% J4/\D@D4/;28% 2J/.@/8% H2;58F%
J4/J/;517C%;%oSD32O%-kM/%<L%k<%6D;5<%D%.7[5.@;75<F%E2E%
D% 35E/@/4L5% D0%;2BDO%.@DO/@;/4\5;% N/;/4D8D% r<L% jN/% D%
4/1s%q%e5C3% #&9%
%
%
%%%%o42@% K;853DCK% -@5E.@% 35%;E8UA25@% J/.8513UUF%
K<5@5/4/8/NDA5.E7UKF% A2.@P9% D8% J4D% 1;/42O%\245?%
o3@DN/32%zz%`/32@2%;%m2E51/3DD%D%T585;E2%z%;%TD4DD%%
%
!$% bloaWTcj>% =D453.ED?% -#, "F% =D453L%
-T5;5432C%oS4DE2F%jNDJ5@9%J4/D0;51C%D0<5453DC%%DU3C%;%
o85E.2314DD% 7N82% <5617%;54@DE28PU% D% 32J42;853D5<% 32%
T/83\5%;%J/8153P%-.AD@28F%A@/%420%T/83\5%/A53P%1285E/F%@/%
87AD% J2428858P3L9% D% D.J/8P07C% 02JD.D% 32M8U153D?%;% @/@%
65% 153P% J2153DC% 87A5?%.;5@2%;% N87M/ED?% E/8/15\%;% TD535%
-o.7239% -;% %.@21D?% % % 1/8D% 05<3/?%/E4763/.@D%
-/E/8/% &E<9% @% 5% T/83\5% 32O/1D8/.P%;% 053D@59% J/87A25@%
4203/.@P% 7N8/;%;%# % D%/J45158C5@% 420<54% 05<3/N/% B242F%
J/87AD;%18D37%/E4763/.@D%B242%!""%E<%-421D7.! E<9%
a2E% ML82% 45B532% 0212A2%/J4515853DC% 420<542% V5<8DF%
D.J/8P07C% 2.@4/N5/150DA5.ED?%.J/./M% l5078P@2@% 35% ML8%
J4/D0;513% 1/% #%;5E2F% 8DBP% 2.@4/3/<L% d2N121.E/?%
/M.54;2@/4DD%;%&#N%35<3/N/%J/J42;D8D%5N/%/BDME7%TJ/./M%
D0<5453DC% 420<54/;% V5<8D% D08/653%;% @42E@2@5% WM%
D0<5453DD% V5<8D% W.@25@.C%.J/43L<F% J/87AD8/.P% 8D% 7%
b42@/.S532%;% D@/N5% % %.@2
Автор
tavintsev
Документ
Категория
Научные
Просмотров
126
Размер файла
6 719 Кб
Теги
Небосвод
1/--страниц
Пожаловаться на содержимое документа