вход по аккаунту


Book Review Die Struktur der Atome und Molekle (The Structure of Atoms and Molecules). By J. Barrett. Translated by M. Ziegler

код для вставкиСкачать
on toxicology are written by H . Oettel (Ludwigshafen), and
many of those on economics by L. Franke (Frankfurt/Main).
With the appearance of this, the first, new alphabetical volume
it can be stated that in its new edition “Ullmann” retains
its unbeaten record as a handbook of technical chemistry
in respect to both the quality of its contents and to its lay-out.
Particular credit should go to the editors, who, in spite of
the large number of authors, have preserved the pleasant
and homogeneous presentation.
Ulfert Onken [NB 236 IE]
Die Struktur der Atome und Molekiile (The Structure of Atoms
and Molecules). By J . Barrett. Translated by M . Ziegler.
Verlag Chemie GmbH, Weinheim 1973. 1st Edit., x, 348
pp., 205 figures, 62 tables, paperback, DM 38.-.
The book leads from the particle-wave dualism of photons
and electrons to atomic structure and the periodic system.
The major part of the work is concerned with bonding in
diatomic molecules and gives a detailed treatment of Walsh
diagrams and the electron pair repulsion model. The whole
is rounded off by a chapter on rc-electrons and bonding in
solids and transition metal complexes.
The text is intended for first-year students and for teachers
who want an introduction to theoretical chemistry that does
not involve complicated derivations. Such readers demand
a clear text in which simplicity is not achieved at the expense
of correctness, and the important point to note is that since
most of today’s introductory chemistry books contain increasingly longer and better theoretical chapters, a book devoted
solely to theory must offer some advantages over the general
chemistry textbooks.
Unfortunately, this is not true of the book in question. The
observant reader will find so many mistakes that its usefulness
for students must often be questioned. For example, already
on page 3 the electrostatic nature of nuclear forces leads
to serious fears about the stability of our world, whereas
the nucleus and the electrons are held together by “nuclear
forces”. The translation is not particularly careful; for example,
we find “virtuelles Vakuum”, “degenerierte d-Orbitale” and
“nicht miissen” (for “must not”). This type of mistake, whether
trivial or grave, could be easily removed, but the language
mastery of either the author or the translator seems inadequate
for the conceptual difficulties of modern physics; for instance,
on page 48 it is interchangeably asserted that the wave nature
of electrons should be understood as statistical and non-statistical.
It is true that such mistakes and inaccuracies occur mainly
in the first part, but it seems dangerous to burden beginners
or other readers with them, particularly as this book may
remain the only one on theoretical chemistry that the reader
works through.
It should not be overlooked that the chemical part, in particular the last two chapters, is considerably more successful,
but the book cannot really be recommended until it has
received more careful-and editorial-revision.
Finally, some suggestions may be permissible. In recent years
quantum-chemical calculations have been used increasingly
in organic chemistry, so that a new edition should contain
chapters on the Woodward-Hoffmann rules and on Hiickel
theory. Also, photoelectron spectroscopy could be used as
convincing support for the shell structure of atoms and as
an experimental basis for the introduction of the M O model.
Klaus Wittel [NB 238 IE]
Registered names, trademarks, err. used in rhis journal, even wirhour spectpc indication :hereof, are nor
be considered unprorecred by law.
8 Verlag Chemie. GmbH. D-6940 Weinheim, 1975. Printed in Germany by Zechnersche Buchdruckerei. SpeyerIRhein.
AU rights rescrved (including those of translation into foreign languages). N o part of this issue may be reproduced in any form - by photoprint, microfilm, or any other means nor transmitted or translated into a machine language without written permission from the published Only single copies ofcontributions. or parts thereof. may be reproduced for personal use. Copies
reproduced and used other than for private purposes in an industrial or commercial undertaking are subject to copyright and, in such cases, a copyright fee must be paid to the VG Wissenschaft GmbH. FrankfurtfMain 1, Grosser Hirschgraben 17/21, from whom conditions of payment can be obtained on request.
Editorial office: Boschstrasse 12. D-6940 We,nheim, Germany, Telephone 4036, 4 0 3 7 . Telex 465516 vchwh d
Editor: H. Giiinewald , Translation Editors: A. J. Rackstrow and A. Srimson
Publishers: Verlag Chemie, GmbH. ( M a n a g n g Directors Jurqen Kreuzhaqe and Hans Schermer) Pappelallee 3. D-6940 Weinheim, Germany
and Academic Press Inc. (President Churlex Hurr), 111 Fifth Avenue, New York 3. N. Y.. USA. and Berkeley Square House, Berkeley Square, London, W. 1.. England.
Correspondence concerning advertisements shoulds be addressed to Verlag Chemie, GmbH. (Advertising Manager H. Borh). D-6940 Weinheim. Pappelallee 7. P. 0. Box 126011280 Germany.
Telephone Weinheim (06201) 4031. Telex 465516 vchwh d.
Anguw. Chem. inrernat. Edit.
1 Vol. 1 4 ( 1 9 7 5 ) 1 N o . 1
Без категории
Размер файла
102 Кб
die, ziegler, der, struktura, molecules, und, structure, translator, barreto, book, atom, molekle, review
Пожаловаться на содержимое документа