Prolonged exposure of human chondrocytes to ascorbic acid modifies cellular behavior in an agarose gel.код для вставкиСкачать
THE ANATOMICAL RECORD 238:31-37 (1994) Prolonged Exposure of Human Chondrocytes to Ascorbic Acid Modifies Cellular Behavior in an Agarose Gel AMY LYNN AULTHOUSE Department of Anatomical Sciences, University of Oklahoma Health Sciences Center, College of Medicine BMSB 553, Oklahoma City, Oklahoma 73190 ABSTRACT Using an agarose gel culture system, the response of adult human chondrocytes to prolonged exposure of ascorbic acid was evaluated using histochemical, immunocytochemical and morphological techniques. The response of these cells to ascorbic acid was different from those previously reported in the literature. Many chondrocytes branched within the agarose gel with continued exposure to ascorbic acid while other chondrocytes maintained a round configuration typical of chondrocytes in vivo. Fibronectin and type I collagen were closely associated with the cell processes of the branching cells. Type I1 collagen and an alcian blue-staining matrix were associated with the rounded cells but not with the branched cells. These data suggest that the chondrocytes are able to express both dedifferentiated and redifferentiated phenotypes with ascorbic acid under these culture conditions. In addition, human chondrocytes were cultured in a collagen gel and began branching within 1 hour of culture. It is possible that an accumulation of type I collagen in the pericellular matrix of ascorbic acid treated cultures may enhance and explain the branching seen in these cultures. Studies by others have indicated that ascorbic acid may enhance, reduce, and/or modify the cartilage matrices produced by chondrocytes. These controversial reports in the literature are presumably due to variations between species and the culture methods employed. 0 1994 Wiley-Liss, Inc. Key words: Chondrocytes, Tissue culture, In Vitro Numerous in vitro studies have addressed the role of in monolayer-cultured bovine and chicken chondroascorbic acid on typical hyaline cartilage matrix syn- cytes treated with ascorbic acid (Daniel et al., 1984; thesis. Although various animal chondrocytes have Levenson, 1969). Proteoglycan synthesis was enhanced been cultured in the presence of ascorbic acid, it is not in bovine articular chondrocytes cultured in agarose surprising that the response of cells varies with the (Aydelotte e t al., 1986) and reduced when chick sternal species and culture methods. In some instances carti- chondrocytes were cultured in agarose and treated lage matrix production is enhanced or unchanged with ascorbic acid (Bounelis and Daniel, 1983). In adwhile in others it is modified andlor reduced. Ascorbic dition, preliminary observations from this laboratory acid caused a switch from type I1 collagen to type I (Aulthouse, 1991) have suggested that alcian blue collagen in bovine and rabbit chondrocytes cultured in stained proteoglycans were reduced when human cosmonolayer (Daniel et al., 1984; Sandell and Daniel, tochondral chondrocytes, cultured in agarose, were ex1988; Layman et al., 1972). Sandell and Daniel (1988) posed to ascorbic acid. In light of these contradictory also reported that collagen synthesis of chick sternal findings, it was important to extend the preliminary chondrocytes, cultured in monolayer, did not switch studies to determine what effect ascorbic acid had on phenotypes. Ascorbic acid has been shown to be essen- cartilage matrix synthesis of human chondrocytes cultial during mouse chondrogenesis in vitro and was re- tured in a three dimensional agarose gel. ported, by Dozin et al. (1992), to cause mouse embryMATERIALS AND METHODS onic chondrocytes to express type I1 collagen in liquid suspension culture only in the presence of ascorbic 1. Cell Culture acid. Human costochondral cartilage was obtained at auWith respect to proteoglycan synthesis, several stud- topsy and individuals with recognized skeletal abnories utilizing rabbit chondrocytes cultured in monolayer malities were excluded. Twelve cases ranging in age have indicated that ascorbic acid enhanced the production and accumulation of cartilage specific proteoglycans pericellularly (Wright et al., 1988; Jouis e t al., 1985; McDevitt et al., 1988). This pericellular accumuReceived May 11, 1993; accepted August 5, 1993 lation of proteoglycans and collagen was also observed 0 1994 WILEY-LISS. INC 32 A.L. AULTHOUSE from one day to six years were evaluated. Primary cultures were established as previously described (Aulthouse et al., 1989). In brief, released chondrocytes were plated in Dublecco’s Modified Eagle’s Media, (DMEM) containing 4.5 g/L glucose, (Gibco, Grand Island, NY) with 10% fetal calf serum, FCS (Irvine Scientific, Santa Ana, CA), 1% L-glutamine (Irvine Scientific, Santa Ana, CA), and with 0.1% penicillin-streptomycin (Gibco, Grand Island, NY), in 24 multiwell tissue culture dishes (Corning, Corning, NY). At confluence, primary cultures were passaged to tissue culture flasks. Cells were rinsed twice with Hanks’ balanced salt solution (HBSS) (Irvine Scientific, Santa Ana, CA) and dissociated in 0.2% trypsin (Gibco, Grand Island, NY) with 5 mM ethylenediamine-tetraacetic acid (EDTA) (Sigma Chemical Co., St. Louis, MO). The cells were then resuspended in 4 ml of media and passaged to 25 cm2 tissue culture flasks. Cells were passaged one to five times. cian blue with 25 mM sodium acetate (pH 5.6), and 0.4 M magnesium chloride. Fixation was followed by brief rinses with 3% acetic acid, then 25% and 50% ETOH with 3% acetic acid and finally 70% ETOH (Aydelotte et al., 1986). 111. Quantificationof Cell Clusters as an Expression of Chondrogenesis Alcian blue stained whole cultures were photographed with a n IMT-2 Olympus inverted microscope (EA4 objective). All single cells and cell clusters associated with alcian blue staining were counted. Using the Crunch Statistical program (Crunch Software Corporation, Oakland, CA) the means were calculated and a one-way analysis of variance was performed. The Newman-Keuls post-hoc test was performed to compare the different treatment groups. Four different cases were analyzed. Three companion cultures were established for each treatment group. The treatment groups included cultures that were fed twice weekly and served as untreated normal controls, cultures treated daily with 50 pg/ml ascorbic acid, and cultures with no treatment but had daily complete media change. Cells in agarose Cells were dissociated from monolayer, centrifuged, resuspended, and maintained in 5 ml of complete DMEM. The cell suspension was allowed to rest for 1h r at 4°C and then filtered through 2 ply, No. 20, nitex (Tetko Inc., Elmsford, NY). The cell suspension was IV. Transmission Electron Microscopy centrifuged and resuspended at 5 x lo5 cells in 1 ml of Cultures were rinsed 3 times in PBS and fixed for 1 0.5% low temperature agarose (Biorad Cat#162-0017, hour at room temperature in a mixture of 1.5% glutarRichmond, CA) in DMEM. A 10 pl drop of cell suspension was plated onto 35 mm tissue culture dishes aldehyde and 1.5%paraformaldehyde in 0.1 M sodium (Corning) that were coated with 1% high temperature cacodylate buffer, pH 7.2, with 0.15% ruthenium red. agarose (Biorad cat# 162-0100, Richmond, CA). The Cultures were rinsed with 0.1 M sodium cacodylate cultures were subsequently refrigerated at 4°C for 15 buffer with ruthenium red for two 15-min intervals and min to allow the low temperature agarose to gel. Cul- without ruthenium red for 15 min and then overnight. tures were treated daily with 50 pg/ml L-ascorbic acid After postfixation for 1 hour in 2% OsO, in 0.1 M so(Sigma Chemical Co., St. Louis, MO) with complete dium cacodylate buffer, the cultures were rinsed in the media change. To evaluate the effects of daily media buffer and dehydrated in a graded series of ethanol. change on chondrogenesis, parallel cultures were fed Specimens were then processed through propylene oxdaily by complete media change without ascorbic acid. ide-Epon 812 resin, embedded, and sectioned with a In addition, untreated normal control cultures (fed Reichert-Jung Ultracut E microtome. Thin sections twice weekly) were established. Cultures were evalu- were stained with 25% uranyl acetate in methanol and 2% Reynold’s lead citrate, and viewed with a Siemens ated after 3 weeks. 102 transmission electron microscope. Cells in collagen V. lmmunocytochemistry Used to Identify Cells were dissociated from monolayer culture and Matrix Macromolecules suspended in a type I collagen gel (Collaborative ReCultures were rinsed 3 times in PBS and fixed in search) (1 mg/ml) at a final concentration of 5 x lo5 cells/ml. One hundred microliters of cell suspension two, 5 min changes of methano1:acetone (1:l) and airwere plated in 100 mm Corning tissue culture dishes dried overnight. After rehydration in PBS, the cultures and incubated for 1 hour at 37°C and fed 2 ml of were incubated overnight a t 4°C in monoclonal antiDMEM. Cultures were observed and photographed a t 1 body to one of the following monoclonal antibodies to 2 hours and at 5 days. Some cultures were digested [purchased from the Developmental Studies Hybridwith 0.1% collagenase (Worthington Biochemical oma Bank, University of Iowa, Iowa City, IA]: human Cooporation) for 15 min at 37°C. The released chondro- type I1 collagen (CIICI, undiluted, Holmdahl et al., cytes were subsequently resuspended in 0.5% low tem- 1986), human type I procollagen (M38, undiluted, Mcperature agarose as described previously. The agarose Donald et al., 1986) or human fibronectin (HFN 7.1, cultures (5 x lo5 cells/ml) were maintained for 2 undiluted, Schoen et al., 1982). Cultures incubated in weeks and treated with ascorbic acid a s described conditioned medium from the NS1 myeloma cell line above. before fusion served a s negative controls. The cultures were rinscd and incubated for 1 hour a t room temper11. Light Microscopic Detection of Cartilage Proteoglycans ature in fluorescein-conjugated rabbit anti-mouse IgG With Alcian Blue (1:100, Cappel, Organon Teknika Corporation, West Cultures were rinsed in phosphate buffered saline Chester, PA). After final rinsing, the cultures were (PBS) and then simultaneously fixed and stained for 24 mounted in 80% glycerine in PBS and photographed hours in a mixture of 2.5% glutaraldehyde, 0.05% al- through a n Olympus Vanox microscope (DPlanApo 20 PROLONGED ASCORBIC ACID TREATMENT 33 UV PL Olympus objective) equipped for fluorescence microscopy. RESULTS Human costochondral chondrocytes were cultured for 1to 3 weeks in a n agarose gel and treated daily by complete media change with 50 pg/ml ascorbic acid or 0 p,g/ml ascorbic acid (complete media change without treatment). Some cultures not treated with ascorbic acid were fed twice weekly and served a s untreated normal controls. There were no differences between cultures fed by complete media change daily or fed by complete media change twice weekly. Cultures from both feeding schedules (twice weekly or daily) contained numerous clusters of isogenous cells that were surrounded with alcian blue-staining matrices. An alcian blue-staining matrix was first associated with several single cells at 1 week and, by 3 weeks of culture, numerous chondrogenic clusters were surrounded by a n alcian blue-staining matrix (Figs. lA,B). There was no significant difference in the number of clusters between these 2 treatment groups. In contrast, cultures that had been treated daily with 50 pg/ml ascorbic acid had a significant reduction of chondrogenic clusters when compared to cultures not treated with ascorbic acid (Fig. 2). Moreover, single cells with or without a n alcian blue-staining matrix were predominant in these cultures. Chondrocytes grown for 3 weeks in agarose with daily (Fig. 1B) or bi-weekly (Figs. lA, 3A) media changes showed no morphological differences. In both instances, the cells retained their typically round chondrocyte-like appearance. However, cultures treated daily with ascorbic acid contained cells with extended cell processes (Figs. lC, 3B). This change in cell morphology was not reversible. Once branching was established, continued culture in the absence of ascorbic acid did not cause the cells to return to the rounded state. With stereomicroscopy and Hoffman modulation contrast optics, i t was possible to determine that the cells were branching within the agarose and not spreading onto the plastic surface of the tissue culture dish. Typically, fibronectin and type I collagen are not associated with adult human chondrocytes cultured for 3 weeks in agarose, however, immunocytochemistry revealed that both fibronectin (Fig. 4A,B) and type I procollagen (Fig. 4C,D) were associated with these branches. Branching cells occasionally were seen wrapping around alcian blue-staining clusters (Fig. 3B). Type I procollagen and fibronection were found in the branching cells but not in the central groups staining with alcian blue (Fig. 4A,C). Round cells not labeled with fibronectin or type I procollagen stained positive for type I1 collagen (data not shown). These data demonstrate that both the dedifferentiated and differentiated chondrocyte phenotype were present in cultures treated with ascorbic acid. Numerous forms of cell branching were apparent, ranging from single to multibranched. Cell processes were closely associated with bundles of thick-banded collagen which accumulated over time (Fig. 5). Cells not treated with ascorbic acid lacked thick-banded collagen pericellularly, although delicate collagen fibrils were apparent along with proteoglycans. These observations are consistent Fig. 1. Human chondrocytes cultured for 3 weeks in an agarose gel stained with alcian blue. A: Untreated normal control culture. B Culture treated daily with 0 pgiml ascorbic acid. C: Culture treated daily with 50 pgiml ascorbic acid (original magnification, x 13.2). with those previously reported by this laboratory (Aulthouse et al., 1989). When adult human chondrocytes were cultured in a type I collagen gel, the cells did not maintain the round configuration a s seen in agarose culture but were branched. In many cells, branching was detected as early as 1 hour after plating. Cell branching became more extensive over time and, by 5 days, nearly all 34 f 4 A.L. AULTHOUSE 200 200 180 180 160 140 1~ 120 100 120 ,40 ; : rn 100 9 8 0 -0 60 80 640 40 20 20 o 0 NC OwAA 50pgAA Fig. 2.The quantification of chondrogenic clusters as a n expression of chondrogenic activity after 3 weeks exposure to ascorbic acid. Representative alcian blue stained cultures from each treatment group were analyzed and quantitated. NC = untreated normal control cultures with media change twice weekly. 0 pgiml AA = control cultures with daily media change receiving 0 pgiml ascorbic acid (AA). 50 pg/ml AA = cultures treated daily with 50 p g h l ascorbic acid. Values are mean 2 SEM. NC > 0 p d m l AA (p > 0.05, not significant); NC > 50 pg/ml AA (P5 0.01); 0 pgiml AA > 50 pg/ml AA (P 5 0.01). cells had a t least one cell process (Fig. 6). The typical morphology of branching cells in the collagen lattice was bipolar or multipolar. After culture for 5 days in a type I collagen gel no alcian blue-staining material was detected. Following release of the branched chondrocytes from the collagen gel with 0.1% collagenase, the cells rounded up by retracting their processes. Subsequent culture of these cells in a n agarose gel (without ascorbic acid treatment) allowed the cells to maintain their round configuration. After 2 to 3 weeks these cells had reexpressed the typical cartilage matrix (type I1 collagen and proteoglycans) as detected by immunocytochemistry and staining with alcian blue (data not shown). However, when chondrocytes were released from collagen gels and cultured in a n agarose gel, then treated daily with 50 pg/ml ascorbic acid, the branching pattern was re-established. Fig. 3. Micrograph of representative cells from 3 week alcian blue stained agarose cultures, A: Untreated normal control cultures. Note that the cells are round and that a n alcian blue-staining matrix is seen surrounding the cell clusters. B Culture treated daily with 50 DISCUSSION Previous observations published from this laboratory (Aulthouse, 1991) indicate that daily treatment of human chondrocytes with 50 pg/ml ascorbic acid reduces the production of alcian blue-staining proteoglycans. The present study further characterizes the response of human chondrocytes to ascorbic acid when cultured in agarose for 3 weeks. We found that cultures treated daily with 50 pg/ml ascorbic acid had a significant reduction in chondrogenic isogenous cell nests. Moreover, single cells predominated in the treated cultures, suggesting a decrease in mitotic activity. In addition, the morphology of the cells changed with ascorbic acid treatment. Typically, chondrocytes grown in agarose are round. However, daily exposure to ascorbic acid caused many cells to branch and extend cell processes. It is apparent that treatmentwith ascorbic acid and not daily media changes caused these modifications in behavior. ImmunocYtochemistrY revealed t h a t both fibronectin and type I collagen were associated with the cell processes. These matrices are typical of human chondrocytes grown in monolayer implying a dedifferentiated or fibroblast-like phenotype. Statistical analysis showed a significant decrease in chondrogenic activity, reduction of clusters, in cultures treated with ascorbic acid when compared to untreated controls. Moreover, human fibroblasts cultured under the same conditions, in agarose with daily ascorbic acid treatment, do not branch (data not shown). Therefore, it is unlikely that there is a contaminating population of fibroblasts within the agarose culture which were stimulated to branch with ascorbic acid treatment. Ascorbic acid has been associated with phenotypic switching of cultured cells. Layman e t al. (1972) reported that when rabbit chondrocytes are cultured in the presence of ascorbic acid they switched phenotype by producing collagen characteristic of skin and bone. Ascorbic acid has also been found to facilitate phenotype switching or transdifferentiation in other cells beside chondrocytes. For example, Itoh (1976) showed that cultured neural retinal cells of chick embryos dif- pgiml of ascorbic acid. Note that cell branching is obvious and in some instances the cell processes are wrapping around the alcian blue stained matrix (original magnification, X 66). PROLONGED ASCORBIC ACID TREATMENT 35 Fig. 4. Immunofluorescent detection of fibronectin and type I procollagen in human chondrocytes cultured in agarose and treated daily with 50 pg/ml ascorbic acid for 3 weeks. A: Fibronectin is associated with the cell processes of branching cells and is lacking in the rounded cells. B Phase contrast of A. C: Type I procollagen is associated with the cell processes of branching cells and is lacking in the rounded cells. D Phase contrast of C (original magnification, x 50). ferentiated into lentoid bodies and pigmented cells in the presence ascorbic acid. Similary, Itoh and Eguchi (1986) reported that in certain culture conditions including ascorbic acid, chick pigmented epithelial cells transdifferentiated into lens cells. It is unlikely that ascorbic acid is causing the cells to completely dedifferentiate or switch phenotype because they continue to produce cartilage specific matrices, type I1 collagen and alcian blue-staining proteoglycans. This simultaneous production of both types I and I1 collagen is similar to that seen with cultured bovine chondrocytes treated with ascorbic acid (Daniel et al., 1984; Sandell and Daniel, 1988). However, it was reported that while type I1 collagen was deposited in the pericellular matrix, both types I and I11 collagen were detected only in the culture media. This differs from the results of the current study in that type I collagen was closely associated with the branching cells. This suggests that the agarose may be facilitating the interaction and entrapment of the extracellular matrices. Indeed, it has been reported by others that ascorbic acid treatment enhanced a pericellular accumulation of matrices (Jouis et al., 1985; McDevitt et al., 1988; Wright et al., 1988). It is interesting that an alcian blue-staining matrix, i.e., proteoglycan presence, is not a requirement for cell branching since single cells without alcian blue halos are also branched. It is possible that the production and accumulation of type I collagen in the pericellular matrix may facilitate cell branching. It is interesting to note that adult human chondrocytes cultured in a collagen gel begin to branch as early as 1hour in culture, and that culture in a collagen gel did not appear to influence the re-expression of the chondrogenic phenotype when the cells were further cultured in an agarose gel. The behavior of cells in the collagen gel was reminiscent of that seen in monolayer. Nonetheless, the culture of chicken limb bud mesenchymal cells in a collagen gel supports chondrogenesis. Solursh and coworkers (1982) have shown that single mesenchymal cells maintain a rounded configuration and produce type I1 collagen and pericellular alcian blue-staining. While numerous studies have been conducted to evaluate the influence of ascorbic acid on the chondrogenic phenotype in culture, there have been no reports of a modification of the cellular morphology in response 36 A.L. AULTHOUSE Fig. 5. Transmission electron micrograph of human chondrocytes cultured in agarose and treated daily with 50 pg/ml ascorbic acid. A Cell processes from chondrocytes cultured for 5 weeks. B: Cell pro- cesses from chondrocytes cultured for 10 weeks. Note that the collagen is closely associated with the cell processes and is thick and banded (original magnification, x 8,000). to ascorbic acid treatment. It seems plausible that variations between species combined with numerous culture techniques may explain the disparity in the literature regarding the effects of ascorbic acid on chondrocytes. It is reasonable to suggest that, as observed with the bovine chondrocytes, ascorbic acid is stimulating both types I and I1 collagen synthesis in the human chondrocyte cultured in agarose. This would account for the simultaneous expression of both the differentiated and dedifferentiated phenotypes. Moreover, the production and accumulation of type I collagen would facilitate and explain the branching of cells as seen in both the cells grown in agarose with ascorbic acid treatment and the cells grown in a collagen gel. ACKNOWLEDGMENTS Special thanks to Dr. Sarah Johnson and colleagues for their help in acquiring tissue; Mr. Tod Dow, Mr. Melville Vaughan, Ms. Nancy Halliday, and Dr. James Tomasek for technical assistance; Mr. Ben Han for photographic assistance; Mr. John Nordquist for assistance with transmission electron microscopy; and Dr. Jane M. Jacob for editorial comments. This research is supported in part by research grants; OCAST grant PROLONGED ASCORBIC ACID TREATMENT 37 Fig. 6. Human chondrocytes cultured in a collagen gel were photographed at 2 hours (A) and a t 5 days (B). At 2 hours numerous cells have extended cell processes and by 5 days most chondrocytes have a bipolar or muitibranched morphology (original magnification. X 66). HN9-019, Presbyterian Harris Research Foundation, and Presbyterian Health Foundation #85. LITERATURE CITED Aulthouse, A.L. 1991 The response of cultured human chondrocytes to daily treatment with L-ascorbic acid. Anat. Rec., 229(4):7A. Aulthouse, A.L., M. Beck, E. Griffey, J. Sanford, K. Arden, M.A., Machado, and W. Horton 1989 Expression of the Human Chondrocyte Phenotype in vitro. In Vitro Cell. Dev. Biol., 25(7):659668. Aydelotte, M.B., R. Schleyerbach, B.J. Zeck, and K.E. Kuettner 1986 Articular chondrocytes cultured in agarose gel for study of chondrocytic chondrolysis. In: Articular Cartilage Biochemistry. K. Kuettner, et al., eds. Raven Press, New York, pp. 235-256. Bounelis, P., and J.C. Daniel 1983 The effect of ascorbate on embryonic chick sternal chondrocytes cultured in agarose. Tissue Cell, 15(5):683 -693. Daniel, J.C., B.U. Pauli, K.E. Kuettner 1984 Synthesis of cartilage matrix by mammalian chondrocytes in vitro. 111. Effects of ascorbate. J . Cell Biol., 99:1960-1969. Dozin, B., R. Quarto, G. Campanile, R. Cancedda 1992 In vitro differentiation of mouse embryo chondrocytes: requirement for ascorbic acid. Eur. J. Cell Biol., 58t390-394. Holmdahl, R., K. Rubin, L. Klareskog, E. Larsson, and H. Wigzell 1986 Characterization of the antibody response in mice with type I1 collagen-induced arthritis, using monoclonal anti-type I1 collagen antibodies. Arthritis Rheum., 29t400-410. Itoh, Y. 1976 Enhancement of differentiation of lens and pigment cells by ascorbic acid in cultures of neural retinal cells of chick embryos. Dev. Biol., 54t157-162. Itoh, Y., and G. Eguchi 1986 In vitro analysis of cellular metaplasia from pigmented epithelial cells to lens phenotypes: a unique model system for studying cellular and molecular mechanisms of “transdifferentiation.” Dev. Biol., 115t353-362. Jouis, V., J . Bocquet, J.P. Pujol, M. Brisset, and G. Loyau 1985 Effect of ascorbic acid on secreted proteoglycans from rabbit articular chondrocytes. FEBS Lett., 186t233-240. Layman, D.L., L. Sokoloff, and E.J. Miller 1972 Collagen synthesis by articular chondrocytes in monolayer culture. Exp. Cell Res., 73: 107-112. Levenson, G.E. 1969 The effect of ascorbic acid on monolayer cultures of three types of chondrocytes. Exp. Cell Res., 55t225-228. McDevitt, C.A., J.M. Lipman, R.J. Ruemer, and L. Sokoloff 1988 Stimulation of Matrix Formation in Rabbit Chondrocyte Cultures by Ascorbate. 2. Characterization of Proteoglycans. J. Orthop. Res., 6518-524. McDonald, J.A., T.J. Broekelmann, M.L. Matheke, E. Crouch, M. Koo, and C. Kuhn 1986 A monoclonal antibody to the carboxyterminal domain of procollagen type I visualizes collagen-synthesizing f i broblasts. Detection of an altered fibroblast phenotype in lungs of patients with pulmonary fibrosis. J. Clin. Invest., 78:12371244.56. Sandell, L.J., and J.C. Daniel 1988 Effects of ascorbic acid on collagen mRNA levels in short term chondrocyte cultures. Connect. Tissue Res. 17:ll-22. Schoen, R.C., K.L. Bentley, and R.J. Klebe 1982 Monoclonal antibody against human fibronectin which inhibits cell attachment. Hybridoma 1t99-108. Solursh, M., T.F. Linsenmayer, and K.L. Jensen 1982 Chondrogenesis from single limb mesenchyme cells. Dev. Biol., 94t259-264. Wright, G.C., Jr., X. Wei, C.A. McDevitt, B.P. Lane, and L. Sokoloff 1988 Stimulation of matrix formation in rabbit chondrocyte cultures by ascorbate. I. Effect of ascorbate analogs and P-aminopropionitrile. J . Orthop. Res., 6t397-407.