OTu3E.2.pdf OFC/NFOEC Technical Digest © 2013 OSA Emerging Disruptive Wireless Technologies – Prospects and Challenges for Integration with Optical Networks Dalma Novak and Rod Waterhouse Pharad, LLC; 797 Cromwell Park Drive, Suite V; Glen Burnie MD 21061 firstname.lastname@example.org Abstract: We describe some emerging technologies that are being investigated for the realization of next generation wireless networks capable of supporting multiple standards and meeting capacity demands. The challenges associated with their efficient integration in a converged wireless/optical network are also discussed. OCIS codes: (060.2360) Fiber optics links and subsystems; (060.5625) Radio frequency photonics 1. Introduction The convergence of optical and wireless networks continues to evolve, ever since the first reports of extending wireless coverage areas using optical fiber as feeder links, that were proposed more than two decades ago [1, 2]. The benefits of creating integrated end-to-end network solutions that can provide reliable service for both fixed and mobile users is now well-recognized. Today wireless networks are evolving more rapidly than ever before. The demand for wireless access to highspeed data communications continues to increase at an unprecedented rate, driven by the proliferation of connected high capacity devices such as tablets and smart phones as well as the increase in the number of broadband multimedia services available to the consumer. By 2015 it is forecast that more than 5 billion consumers will be exposed to wireless connectivity leading to an aggregate mobile traffic of almost 7,000 Petabytes per month . In addition, the expected associated number of mobile backhaul connections that will be provided by optical fiber links will total more than 3.5 million . The realization of integrated optical/wireless networks that can reliably and cost-effectively support current and future capacity demands, traffic growth rates, new services, as well as multiple wireless standards (GSM, CDMA, LTE, WiMAX, HSPA+) is an ongoing challenge for carriers. In this paper we discuss some emerging technologies that are being investigated as potential solutions to this problem and describe the implications for their successful integration with optical networks. 2. Active Antenna Systems Presently, traditional macro-cell infrastructure features a distributed base station architecture in which the radio hardware is positioned in close proximity to the tower-mounted passive antennas. This remote radio head (RRH) contains the RF circuitry (including amplifiers, diplexer and bandpass filters) as well as analog-to-digital/digital-toanalog converters and frequency conversion components. Meanwhile the base station server (BTS) or baseband unit (BBU) comprising the digital baseband processing circuitry (the channel cards) is located separately and interfaces with the RRH via a digital fiber optic link; CPRI (Common Public Radio Interface) and OBSAI (Open Base Station Architecture Initiative) are two standards that have been developed for this serial link and a number of vendors currently supply the associated optical transceivers for these wireless backhaul standards. One architecture concept that is currently attracting significant interest for meeting the growing capacity demands of wireless networks is the deployment of smaller sized cells that would coexist with, and complement larger macro sized cells. These small cells (anywhere from 50 m to 5 km in size) could include micro-, pico-, or femto-cells, as well as Wi-Fi deployments. They would provide additional capacity and data rates beyond the capabilities of macro-cell sized networks by being deployed selectively where traffic demand is not being met, such as coverage hotspots and inside buildings. Ultimately network control would be utilized to coordinate how a user is most optimally connected to the wireless network infrastructure, considering the different cell layers and radio technologies available. As part of the trend towards smaller sized cells, the cell site hardware is becoming more advanced; active antenna systems are key examples of this technology innovation. Active antenna systems are essentially an extension of the distributed base station concept whereby the RRH functionality is now directly integrated with the antenna elements . In this emerging cell site technology, the active antenna is also becoming more ‘intelligent’ since its radiation patterns can be adapted to accommodate changing capacity demands and even multiple wireless 978-1-55752-962-6/13/$31.00 ©2013 Optical Society of America OTu3E.2.pdf OFC/NFOEC Technical Digest © 2013 OSA standards in the one cell. The energy efficiency and performance benefits of active antenna system technology lead directly to improvements in base station capacity and coverage, as has been reported in recent network trial demonstrations [6 – 8]. Another key benefit of an active antenna architecture is the potential to significantly reduce the footprint of the cell site. Research is underway into a number of different aspects of realizing high performance active antenna systems that can support current and emerging wireless air interface standards, spectrum bands and data bandwidths. Novel technologies related to new efficient amplifier structures, adaptive beamforming technologies, RF/antenna integration techniques, advanced baseband processing concepts, redundant subsystems, as well as wideband antenna array designs, are all being actively investigated. Innovative antenna structures that can accommodate the next generation form factors of cell sites and be compliant with system on chip (SoC) RF technologies are also being pursued. New antennas that can support a variety of wireless standards will naturally require appropriate hardware to carry out the digitization process required for interfacing with the BBU. Antenna arrays that can support multiple frequency bands will play a key role in future implementations of wireless base stations featuring active antenna systems [6 – 8]. A key requirement for these arrays is the ability to operate efficiently over the entire frequency spectrum that would support current and new wireless services (2G, 3G, and 4G). Beam steering capability over a wide field of view in a small factor, are additional requirements for the wideband arrays, however the combination of all these factors presents a significant challenge. One promising new radiator solution for implementation in next generation multi-radio active antenna systems is the balanced anti-podal Vivaldi antenna (BAVA) structure . These antenna elements are inherently wideband in nature, electrically small and also modular, allowing easy formation into an array. Due to its electrically small size, the BAVA radiating element does not encounter the typical scan blindness and grating lobe issues associated with creating large arrays of wideband antenna elements, which leads to a very efficient radiating system. It is also very suited to being integrated with SoC technologies for small cell applications, where the RF hardware can be positioned behind an individual element or integrated into an active antenna array to achieve a very compact footprint. Figure 1 shows an array of BAVA elements in a highly compact single platform that we recently designed to efficiently cover the 700 – 3600 MHz frequency range, with very good beam steering capabilities over multiple octaves . Fig. 1 BAVA radiator for next generation active antenna systems: Single element and cross-section (left); Array of elements (right) 3. Integration of Small Cells with Optical Networks Alongside the move towards smaller cell sites with integrated antennas and RRH functionality, the interconnections between the active antenna systems and the baseband units are also evolving. In the traditional arrangement the BBU is located in a cabinet at the base of the cell tower however the concept of a centralized architecture in which a number of BBUs are remotely co-located together in a secure Central Office, is being actively investigated [11, 12]. In this scenario, the typical CPRI digital fiber-optic link between the active antenna system and the BBU would be longer in length and the optical distribution network comprising the digital links constitutes the fronthaul of the wireless network. A centralized BBU architecture will lead to savings in OPEX as well as improved performance since there is no transmission delay between adjacent cells. If the co-located BBUs are also pooled together such that the baseband processing resources can be effectively shared across a large number of cell sites in a “virtual” configuration, the resulting cloud radio access network (C-RAN) can also enable CAPEX reductions while enabling the connectivity between different wireless network layers to be optimized. OTu3E.2.pdf OFC/NFOEC Technical Digest © 2013 OSA One of the key challenges associated with remoting pooled BBUs from the active antenna systems in next generation wireless networks is the very high bit-rates that must be accommodated by the digital links since the data rate will depend on the sampling frequency (proportional to the wireless data bandwidth) and sampling resolution . This problem becomes more pronounced with the trend towards using multiple transmit and receive antennas at the cell site as a means to increase capacity. For example, an LTE network with 20 MHz bandwidth, 2 × 2 MIMO in the downlink, and 3 sectors (RRHs) per cell site would equate to an aggregate data rate of more than 7 Gb/s after digital sampling of the analog radio signals . The implementation of active antenna systems with multiple radios that support a diversity of wireless standards can lead to expected data rates well in excess of 10 Gb/s. In addition, there are strict requirements on transmission latency and jitter that must be satisfied, which are even more stringent for emerging higher data rate 4G wireless networks. Ultimately these constraints will limit the fiber distances between the active antenna systems and the baseband processing hardware to a few tens of kilometers. A variety of architectures for realizing the fronthaul optical distribution network are currently being evaluated with regards to efficient fiber usage and cost, including point-to-point fiber links between the RRH and BBU and multiplexing of the CPRI links via TDM, WDM or OFDMA PONs [11 – 13]. Depending on the required bandwidth, a dedicated dense WDM (DWDM) network architecture may be required with dedicated wavelengths assigned for one or more active antenna systems . Also being investigated is the possibility of deploying fiberconnected small cells within existing macrocells that may already have sufficient baseband processing capacity and are integrated with conventional optical transport links. One approach to addressing the challenge of realizing high data rate fiber optic links for future wireless fronthaul networks is the development of novel digital compression algorithms to reduce the bandwidth . A complete paradigm shift however would be to consider implementing analog RF optical links which would avoid the sampling process altogether [13, 14]. An analog optical distribution network connecting the RRHs and BBUs would also greatly simplify the cell site hardware and reduce power consumption since the ADC/DACs and frequency up/downconversion circuitry are no longer required. The main drawback with transporting the wireless signals as an analog signal over fiber is the reduced dynamic range which limits the fiber transmission distance. This issue can be mitigated somewhat through the use of power or gain control techniques in the wireless network, however the achievable dynamic range will still limit the potential applications for this transport scheme. An analog based connection would also have an impact on feasible architecture options for the optical distribution network that interfaces multiple small cell sites to a centralized pool of BBUs. 4. Conclusions Meeting current and future capacity demands and supporting multiple wireless standards continue to drive the evolution of wireless networks. Active antenna systems and C-RANs are some of the emerging concepts being investigated for these next generation wireless systems, and have the potential to significantly impact the evolution of converged optical and wireless networks. A key challenge in successfully realizing the optical distribution network for future wireless fronthaul will be the very large bit rates per cell site that must be supported. 5. References               J. Cooper, “'Fibre/Radio' for the provision of cordless/mobile telephony services in the access network”, Electron. Lett., Vol. 26. No. 24, pp. 2054 – 2056, (1990). D. M. Fye, “Design of fiber optic antenna remoting links for cellular radio applications”, Proc. IEEE Vehic. Technol. Conf., pp. 622 – 625, (1990). Alcatel Lucent LightRadio™ Portfolio White Paper (2011). Infonetics Research, Mobile Backhaul Equipment and Services, Market Size, Share, and Forecasts, (March 2012). 4G Americas MIMO and Smart Antennas for Mobile Systems, (October 2012). www.commscope.com www.lgsinnovations.com www.nokiasiemensnetworks.com M. W. Elsallal and D. H. Schaubert, “On the performance trade-offs associated with modular element of single- and dual-polarized DmBAVA”, Proc. Ant. Appl. Symp., pp. 166 – 187, (2006). www.pharad.com D. Di Mola and A. Lometti, “Photonic integrated technologies for optical backhauling”, Proc. Int. Conf. Transparent Opt. Netw., (2011). A. Pizzinat, F. Bourgart, P. Chanclou, B. Charbonnier, F. Le Clech, and B. Landousies, “An opportunity for access network convergence and consolidation: Digital radio over fiber”, Proc. OFC/NFOEC, (2012). A Nirmalathas, P. A. Gamage, C. Lim, D. Novak, R. Waterhouse, and Y. Yang, ”Digitized radio-over-fiber technologies for converged optical wireless access network”, J. Lightw. Technol, Vol. 28, No. 16, pp. 2366 - 2375, (2010). D. Wake, S. Pato, J. Pedro, E. Lopez, N. Gomes, and P. Monteiro, “A comparison of remote radio head optical transmission technologies for next generation wireless systems”, Proc. IEEE Photon. Soc. Ann. Meet., pp. 442 – 443, (2009).